A scientist says he can scan prisoners' brains for signs of evil

(theguardian.com)

17 points | by mellosouls 16 hours ago ago

8 comments

  • jjpones 13 hours ago ago

    Well that took a wild, albeit unsurprising turn at the end (bringing in race). Though I do still wonder if there ends up being actual material improvements on brain scans being behavior predictors or if it truly stays in science fiction (probably science fiction). Very evocative of the anime Psycho Pass.

    > Psycho-Pass is set in a futuristic Japan governed by the Sibyl System, a powerful biomechatronic computer network which continually monitors the psychological traits of Japanese citizens using a "cymatic scan." The resulting psychometric assessment is called a Psycho-Pass, which includes a numeric Crime Coefficient index, revealing the citizen's criminality potential, and a color-coded Hue, alerting law enforcement to other data... When a targeted individual's Crime Coefficient index exceeds the accepted threshold (100), they are pursued, apprehended, and either arrested or killed by the field officers of the Crime Investigation Department of the Ministry of Welfare's Public Safety Bureau.

  • ralfd 16 hours ago ago

    > Defense attorneys, in particular, used biological evidence like brain scans to argue that their clients should receive lighter sentences.

    Counterintuitively people want negative traits be rooted in biology. That the soul is a victim of the faulty flesh, instead of lacking willpower or being responsible for ones actions.

    • cheevly 13 hours ago ago

      Lacking willpower sounds biological to me... do you disagree??

  • lambdaone 16 hours ago ago

    The article really doesn't hold back: one of the subheadings is "Picking up where phrenology left off".

  • aatd86 8 hours ago ago

    Minority report? What if the scientist are evil themselves? :o

  • tim-tday 16 hours ago ago

    Yesssss. And now to extract the evil, concentrate it and reinstall it at will!

    Muahahahaha!!!

    • wasting_time 12 hours ago ago

      Is anyone working on an evil AI?

      Claude, look for vulnerabilities in the top 5000 websites of $country and install ransomware. Pick an amount that's just within the company budget. Do not relent under any circumstance.

      Should sell like hot cakes on the evil marketplace!

  • jonjacky 15 hours ago ago

    "Did you take that test yourself?"