> Every record has gam_audiences and audiences_member_of populated, Google Ad Manager audience segments, with values like coach-nudge experiment groups, trial eligibility, lapsed-user cohorts and rating-band targeting.
It sure seems like the evidence doesn't point to scraping to me.
> The data had been pulled by abusing the platform’s find-friends feature
Sounds like the find-friends feature shouldn't allow access to the majority of that data unless the "friend" accepts, don't think the "scraper" got 7mil accepts just because they had access to emails... To me this is 100% a breach, even more so because its already happened once years ago to 700k, and they changed nothing to prevent it.
It might very well be possible that there were API endpoints that exposed way too much information. I also think that this wouldn't qualify as "scraping".
> Every record has gam_audiences and audiences_member_of populated, Google Ad Manager audience segments, with values like coach-nudge experiment groups, trial eligibility, lapsed-user cohorts and rating-band targeting.
It sure seems like the evidence doesn't point to scraping to me.
I'm assuming they're basing this on the no-passwords part.
> The data had been pulled by abusing the platform’s find-friends feature
Sounds like the find-friends feature shouldn't allow access to the majority of that data unless the "friend" accepts, don't think the "scraper" got 7mil accepts just because they had access to emails... To me this is 100% a breach, even more so because its already happened once years ago to 700k, and they changed nothing to prevent it.
It might very well be possible that there were API endpoints that exposed way too much information. I also think that this wouldn't qualify as "scraping".
Basically our data is free.
email? Is a user's email up for grabs just like that?
Is scraping wrong that, is the question.