66 comments

  • Aurornis 8 hours ago ago

    > Only 42% of Alpha students met the network’s goal of learning twice as fast in both math and reading,

    > The core of the pitch is that students will “learn twice as much as their peers in two hours of academics a day”

    > About a fifth of Alpha’s private school students scored at or below the 50th percentile nationally in math last fall, and only 37% of that group met the network’s 2x growth goal by winter, the Times found.

    This article is trying really hard to make the results sound bad, but isn't this actually pretty incredible progress?

    Under any other circumstances, a teacher who doubled progress in math and reading for 42% of students would be hailed as a hero and studied intently.

    The headline of this article is trying to imply that the school is underperforming because, what, they set an extremely ambitious goal? And got 42% of students to meet that goal?

    I don't know what I'm reading here. We're supposed to be angry at this?

    This isn't convincing me to be an Alpha AI school fanboy. I have no doubt there is nuance in the details. But I'm blown away by how hard this article is trying to be negative, and how well it's working on readers who aren't thinking critically about these numbers.

    • bberenberg 8 hours ago ago

      Education data and analytics are mostly selection bias. The product at many private school is "I pay 75k to not have disruptive and problematic kids around my kids" and the academic benefits flow from this. When comparing Alpha vs other private schools, I think the thing to look at is the admissions process and associated selection bias. Of course a school that only lets in smart kids outperforms others. If Alpha are gating on non intellectual or academic items (which they claim is the case), then you will have below avergae and non-disruptive kids in the peer set and some won't hit the goals.

      My takeaway here is that the Alpha approach helps high achievers, and doesn't gate keep access to only high achievers.

    • zdragnar 8 hours ago ago

      Most people who sign up for a private school this expensive are interested in the success of their kids academic life, so you'd expect the results to be higher than average on that basis alone.

      If I'm paying $75k for a school that makes promises (or at least hold claims), and my kid does worse than the national average, I'm going to be asking a lot of questions. A LOT of questions, like "why did I believe this crap?" and "how could I let my kids down?" and "when does enrollment in public schools start up again?"

      • SkiFire13 7 hours ago ago

        > so you'd expect the results to be higher than average on that basis alone.

        The article is focusing on that fifth of students that didn't perform well, but if that can be trusted then it means 80% of the students did end up performing better than the national median, and 80% seems pretty high to me. Do normal private schools guarantee even higher chances of my kids performing better?

        • yorwba 5 hours ago ago

          80% were above the median at the initial test, which is to say the admissions procedure is highly selective. The focus on the below-median students' slower progress is because Alpha School claims that their teaching methodology is responsible for their results, not just selection effects. But the biggest issue with Alpha School's promises is really that they measure learning speed using performance on a test that has large variance relative to the expected improvement, so getting a difference that's twice as large is more likely than one might think (and so is getting a difference in the opposite direction).

      • tfehring 7 hours ago ago

        I’d bet that ~all of the students who are below national averages were already behind before switching to Alpha School, and that most are catching up rather than falling further behind peers at traditional schools.

    • aleqs 8 hours ago ago

      Article is paywalled, but all of these results are pretty meaningless unless the tests are designed, administered and judged by independent parties.

      From the few cases I know of, helping students cheat in various ways to bump up results is standard practice for private schools, who then use these results for marketing purposes.

      • pseudo0 7 hours ago ago

        Plenty of metrics hacking happens in both the public and private systems unfortunately. The soft version is to spend weeks leading up to the test teaching students how to answer common questions by rote, while the students fail to understand the underlying concepts. Another trick is to put low performers on IEPs so they get testing accomodations like extra time.

        Then there is just outright fraud, like teachers or principals changing test answers after the fact to bump up scores. The Baltimore Sun has some good reporting on the cheating scandals for the Maryland state test over the years, for example.

    • abroszka33 8 hours ago ago

      Alpha's goals are meaningless if it cannot be seen on the national in math test. They can be 10x faster learners according to Alpha but who cares?

  • TwelveEyes 9 hours ago ago

    What they hinted at about the school not actually sticking to the two hours per day of schooling is slightly concerning. I would frankly be happy with parity provided the kids only needed two hours of schooling per day, but if they aren’t committing to that then this is a bad result.

  • jjcm 8 hours ago ago

    > the pitch is that students will “learn twice as much as their peers in two hours of academics a day”

    Given a standard school day has 6 hours of learning, what they're actually claiming is that their product will teach kids 6x as effectively as normal schooling.

    I do actually thing that AI-driven lessons are the future (I'd love to see a proper Young Lady's Illustrated Primer), but in my opinion the approach here is fundamentally flawed. The goal shouldn't be "less time spent learning", it should be to maximize the impact of the time spent.

    The time spent learning is education in its own, and minimizing it to two hours a day will only teach kids to search for shortcuts and reduce their resiliance. You can certainly go too far with this (imo a Kumon-style 8am-8pm 12 hour day of learning overloads kids and doesn't give them time for creative thinking), but I do think it's important to teach kids that dedicated time spent on a problem is valuable in its own right.

    Alpha's take is that this time is better spent on "real world" exercises and scenarios. From their site:

    > Whether it’s solving a 45-second pit stop challenge or exploring the breadth of global art styles, our workshops teach students how to navigate the real world with confidence.

    There is value in this iff the real world exercises are applications of the things they're learning. I was home schooled, and one of the most valuable things my parents did was give me things that were applications of what I was working on in my coursework. When I was learning geometry, one of my after school activities was calculating how much wood was needed for a deck that had a sine-wave curve and was made of 2x6 boards with a quarter inch gap. Once I did the calcs, we went to home depot, bought the wood, built the deck, and when I was a few boards short we talked through what I did wrong. It was a perfect way to reinforce how the geometry calculations could be applied. Alpha seems to focus more of their workshops on resiliance and leadership - ie can they bike all the way across the golden gate bridge, or can they do a ninja obstacle course (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Vo16UaJ26o&t=197s). I don't see these activities reinforcing what the kids are learning that day, so I'm not surprised they're falling short of the claimed targets.

  • vibebingo 8 hours ago ago
  • jareklupinski 8 hours ago ago

    > ... public schools can’t remove struggling students, the Times noted, and they lack the prize incentives Alpha uses at its private campuses.

    haha what

    how are they creating an effective benchmark when using prizes to incentivize children?

    • nerevarthelame 7 hours ago ago

      Alpha's use of "prize incentives" can be seen in Wired's article on the school from 2025 (which is also referenced in the original link), where one 9-year-old was withheld food required by her pediatrician until she hit her metrics, among many other horrors:

      > Barrios says, she and her husband sat with their daughter for hours each day until she finished the multiplication lesson, even as she broke down and sobbed that she’d rather die than keep going ...

      > Within a couple weeks, Barrios says, the school reported to her and her husband that their daughter wasn’t eating lunches. According to Barrios, Alpha said it was “because she would rather stay in and work.” The girl later explained to her parents that she was spending lunchtimes catching up ...

      > When Barrios’ husband brought their daughter to a previously scheduled checkup soon after, her doctor noted with concern that she had lost a significant amount of weight in a short time. Her dad then brought her to school with a note from the pediatrician, Barrios says, instructing her to eat snacks in between regular meals ...

      > For the first few days, Barrios says, her daughter ate her snacks. Then one afternoon she returned with them still in her backpack, uneaten. Barrios, alarmed, asked if Alpha was providing different food instead. No, the 9-year-old answered. She told her mom that staff at the school said she didn’t earn her snacks and wouldn’t get them until she met her learning metrics.

      [https://www.wired.com/story/ai-teacher-inside-alpha-school, https://archive.is/CVaAG]

    • aga98mtl 7 hours ago ago

      Society is paying huge sums of money on education. If giving prizes provides better results, then it is a great innovation.

    • undefined 8 hours ago ago
      [deleted]
  • undefined 9 hours ago ago
    [deleted]
  • inshard 9 hours ago ago

    So half failed to learn at double the pace, meaning more learned at a faster pace than benchmark. What was that number?

    • napo 8 hours ago ago

      yes, I'm confused about that part too.

      > Only 42% of Alpha students met the network’s goal of learning twice as fast in both math and reading

      If they managed to have almost half of students learning twice as fast, it's quite impressive.

      • PostOnce 8 hours ago ago

        What are the odds students whose parents can pay $75,000 a year for their child's education are going to outperform the national average at any school they attend anyway?

        • drivebyhooting 8 hours ago ago

          In California public school, separate tracks are forbidden. At most they can do in-classroom clustering.

          Children who can already multiply have to count and add under 20 for first grade.

          • glpgeFwac 6 hours ago ago

            Separate tracks aren’t forbidden, they’re just not funded by the state like GATE used to be. Agree this is a major regression and terrible policy, but can be solved at the local level. Good luck

            • drivebyhooting 3 hours ago ago

              Cannot be solved at the local level. That’s like spending all your time and energy fighting your HOA over landscaping.

              You just have to shell out for after school tutors or enrichment centers. Besides the money, the real cost is the family’s time and logistics.

        • arjie 8 hours ago ago

          You’re referring to the heritability of g? I think it’s <0.4 at this age. Higher later in life.

          • bagacrap 7 hours ago ago

            I think it's not about inherited traits but the amount of attention and nature of home environment.

            • PostOnce 7 hours ago ago

              Yes. Better sleep in a better bed, healthier food, a better ventilation system at home, better school supplies, money for tutors, access to books at home, a better computer, musical instruments, parents who are more likely to be numerate and literate to talk to, etc, etc, etc.

  • Balgair 8 hours ago ago

    ACX has much needed context for this thread:

    https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/your-review-alpha-school (2025)

    TLDR: Alpha school pays kids for grades. You do better, you get (relatively) expensive rewards. The whole article is worth reading, though, there is a lot of nuance.

    I've considered moving for Alpha and attending them, but in digging further (more than just the ACX article), we have opted out and gone wholly the opposite way into Waldorf education. The rat-race style and zero-sum thinking of things like Alpha, in the end, were real turn offs for us.

    • notagoodidea 8 hours ago ago

      That is quite the opposite direction indeed. While Alpha never has been on my radar we despite a few ideas I would steal in the future (instead of homework doing the same exercise but in public contests etc), I have a really hard time with anything linked to Rudolf Steiner. Waldorf schools may have a good reputation but the whole foundation is smoke and you mostly rely on hopes to have a set of teachers that cares about your kid in this environment. I am biaised but curious to see what pushed you towards Waldorf school in reaction to Alpha.

      • Balgair 7 hours ago ago

        >you mostly rely on hopes to have a set of teachers that cares about your kid in this environment

        Bingo! It's almost all about the staff.

        We toured the local school and were really impressed with the teachers and admin there. So far it's been great for us, but only time can tell.

      • aleqs 7 hours ago ago

        Is there any evidence to suggest either of these schools are somehow better than the average public school?

  • rodarmor 9 hours ago ago

    America's public schools spent $17,619 per student in 2024 and only three in ten students read proficiently.

    • zulux 8 hours ago ago

      Need more money for pensions.

      • Unibod 7 hours ago ago

        Need more money overall, a country should afford to educate children and pay professionals for their time and retirement, otherwise you have no future.

    • Beijinger 8 hours ago ago

      [dead]

  • glpgeFwac 8 hours ago ago

    Expensive correspondence school that sounds like hell on earth, maybe OK if you're otherwise training for the Olympics. Why do parents sign their kids up for this?

    https://buildcognitiveresonance.substack.com/p/fourth-report...

    • jacobolus 8 hours ago ago

      From a different post on the same blog:

      > One young child, who I believe was either a first or second grader, refused to focus on her computer for two hours — clearly, she wanted to move around and interact with other kids, and was growing very frustrated, and started to be non-cooperative. In response, her ‘guide’ placed her in what looked like a phone booth, alone, and closed the door. [...] When I asked the guide how she knew what to do, she said that she had ChatGPT’d it.

      https://buildcognitiveresonance.substack.com/p/observer-of-a...

      • camel_gopher 7 hours ago ago

        That’s called seclusion, and it’s illegal, not to mention cruel.

      • genxy 8 hours ago ago

        A box for operant conditioning plus an escape room. I love it.

  • neya 9 hours ago ago

        A study of 26,811 secondary students in central China found that homework scores rose 18% after students adopted generative AI tools, while closed-book exam scores fell 20%. The OECD’s latest PISA results found that daily AI users scored lower in science than nonusers, while moderate users performed about the same.
    
    
    It's almost as if using AI only as a tool for execution rather than actual architectural decisions works out well. In HN universe this is the difference between an experienced architect using AI to write code vs a TikTok hipster to tell codex/claude to create an instagram clone for them so they can make a video about it "We dOn'T nEeD eNgiNeErs AnyMoRe"
    • whydoineedthis 8 hours ago ago

      Not really. Life is closer to an open-book exam rather than a closed-book exam, so what it shows is that when people are allowed help, they do better than those without help.

      • eloisant 8 hours ago ago

        An open-book exam is designed as such, homework is still designed with the idea that you won't be using AI to solved it.

        Knowing multiplication is useful even if calculators exist, and doing a sheet of multiplications with a calculator is a pointless exercise.

      • lionkor 8 hours ago ago

        Not being able to do basic multiplication without a calculator is wildly inconvenient, so we teach kids multiplication without calculators.

        Life is only an open book exam as long as you don't ever let a screen leave your sight.

  • atleastoptimal 8 hours ago ago

    What's the point of paying the price that the best boarding schools charge for a program based on a tech whose core competitive advantage is being much cheaper than humans? Does every kid get their own H100?

  • gregglain 8 hours ago ago

    The school I assume hit their financial targets. Well done.

  • j45 8 hours ago ago

    This is a bit of a misleading headline.

    The school's target is 100% of students would learn twice as fast.

    They are finding only 43% of students are learning twice as fast.

    • mh8h 8 hours ago ago

      The benchmark shouldn't be the national average. It should be other private schools that charge in the same ballpark.

      • Spivak 6 hours ago ago

        Or at minimum at least an average of private schools so you have a population of kids who you're reasonably sure have involved families. Either that or you keep the national average and recruit from average (or as a flex) below average public schools and show how much improvement you can do.

        I fully believe that personal computerized learning can work, they worked for me during the dial up era so there's nowhere to go but up. But this seems like the best possible case for Alpha with a student population that's comparable to the most expensive private schools but is touting results that are good for a middling public school. It might be impressive but a family that can burn $75k for their child's education I bet their kid would do far better than the national average from that alone.

    • toomuchtodo 8 hours ago ago

      Good students with engaged, involved parents will always learn fast, regardless of public, private, or AI schools. “There is no speed limit.” The students who have a hard time is the never ending challenge. They will have a hard time regardless of which school they’re in, and need more time, resources, and support to succeed. Does AI help them? That is the data we need, with as much granularity as possible.

      Greatest advantage has always been the luck of who your parents are and their income.

      https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49879142 (citations)

      > There are ~13.6M single parents in the U.S. raising over 21M children. This means single parents head roughly one in three households and approximately 34% of all U.S. children live in a single-parent family.

      > More than 3 million college students are raising kids. Most won’t graduate

    • Aurornis 8 hours ago ago

      I posted a similar comment, as did others. We're all getting downvoted.

      This article is very anti-AI coded, which is a category of writing where anything other than unquestioning agreement with the article brings downvotes.

      But shouldn't we all be taking a deeper look at a school that's producing significantly better outcomes than traditional schooling? Why are we demonizing this?

  • spwa4 9 hours ago ago

    "Only 42% of Alpha students met the network’s goal of learning twice as fast in both math and reading, according to internal data first reported by The New York Times. The findings land as Alpha pushes into public schools, where districts are adopting its software in hopes of fitting more learning into less time."

    As someone who occasionally reads psychometric papers: WOW. That's an impressive result. That is equivalent to a very, very good teacher.

    • uptrails 9 hours ago ago

      Although the title is obvious clickbait, I have to note that if you want to spend $75k and have your kid learn at twice the speed of the public curriculum, this is really not something you could not have accomplished before. This is a "live-in tutor" kind of money.

      More generally, the problem is almost always motivation and discipline, not the availability of instruction. If you have a motivated kid, you can simply buy them some books.

      If you want to use AI in public education, I guess the big question is whether it can help the kids who have parents who work two shifts, who get pulled into youth gangs, or play games all day and don't even show up to school. Helping talented kids from well-off homes is really not that much of a challenge.

      • preommr 8 hours ago ago

        > More generally, the problem is almost always motivation and discipline, not the availability of instruction.

        This is completely wrong in the context of AI.

        Lots of learning can be massively improved if someone can zero in on what specific misunderstanding someone has because of how they interpreted some information. You might have the books, but it doesn't help if it presumes you understand some other fundamental hidden in another book.

        You can't constantly ask even direct teachers about these questions, because they're paid by the hour, and just asking the questions can take a quarter of an hour. The best mitigtation was basically having an excellent lifelong education at every step to make sure the gaps were mostly filled in and students ask the occasional question for the limited time teachers can afford them.

        AI changes this completely. AI can teach you exactly what you need all the way back to the exact fundamentals, correct any misunderstandings, poor wording, show you 10 different examples until it clicks in the way that's best for your brain, draw diagrams and so much more.

        And it does this for pennies, without judgement and lots of patience.

        • danielmarkbruce 8 hours ago ago

          Do you have kids?

          • lazyasciiart 8 hours ago ago

            They have either never seen a kid who doesn’t want to be there and won’t ask questions, or they imagine that the sheer excitement of AI would overcome that, it sounds like.

        • lazyasciiart 8 hours ago ago

          It’s certainly not doing it for pennies at Alpha School. And all of that is what a personal tutor can do already. For $75k you could hire a professional teacher to spend two hours/day teaching your child. Now we just have to have someone run a comparison, maybe find a group of parents who wanted to enrol in Alpha School and divert them to this plan?

    • danielmarkbruce 8 hours ago ago

      Maybe look at the school curriculum these days. It's really not an impressive result at all for that kind of money. In good areas, middle schools and high schools have "advanced pathways" which have the kids years ahead of the standards. It's not because they are geniuses. It's because the standards are incredibly low.

    • misnome 9 hours ago ago

      Only if it's in their self-imposed time limit, which it sounds like they aren't. "Twice as fast" could be measuring weeks or terms, rather than actual hours studying.

      If the students are being pressured into working super-long days then that doesn't say anything.

      • jbellis 8 hours ago ago

        But they're not, and this is readily available if you spend just a few seconds learning about Alpha School.

    • contemporary343 9 hours ago ago

      Composition effects...

    • benmanns 9 hours ago ago

      And one in five failed the testing target for reading… so 80% learned twice as fast in reading?

      • cyanydeez 9 hours ago ago

        yeah, but can you imagine how stupid the parents must be, such that hereditary effects are confounding variables?

  • opengrass 7 hours ago ago

    $75k for slop is bizzaro world. Even $15k gets you a school with smaller classes, teachers calling home and conservative rules on dress and behavior.

  • themgt 8 hours ago ago

    About half of K-8 students at Alpha’s private campuses missed the goal of learning math twice as fast

    Research points to a learning penalty

    Professors have told Fortune that students who lean on AI summaries struggle with sustained reading. “Today, if you assign that amount of reading, they often don’t know what to do,” Timothy O’Malley, a theology professor at the University of Notre Dame, told Fortune‘s Preston Fore in June.

    “It’s not even an inability to critically think,” Jessica Hooten Wilson, a professor of great books and humanities at Pepperdine University, told Fortune. “It’s an inability to read sentences.”

    I love the meta-irony of this article being a fucking mess. "missed math target" one has to dig to find is "missed the goal of learning math twice as fast", and then the article goes on about how "a professor of great books and humanities at Pepperdine University" says students who use AI can't read sentences.

    The joke is Fortune assumes its readers also can't read sentences.

    • genxy 8 hours ago ago

      What we are seeing in realtime is that probably 20% of the population will think deeper, learn more and achieve things that would have been outside of their grasp (for various reasons) and the rest of us flame out, use the crutch and drink Brawndo.

  • gershylakier 8 hours ago ago

    [flagged]