Everything Made by an AI Is in the Public Domain

(pluralistic.net)

6 points | by signa11 10 hours ago ago

3 comments

  • gnabgib 10 hours ago ago

    (2023)

    Related discussion: All AI-generated code should be Open Source (1076 points, 614 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50507303

  • davydm 8 hours ago ago

    By this rationale, the transpiled output from a typescript program is in the public domain too. Same for compiled binaries.

    AI codegen is a tool, driven by human prompts. The outputs are generations, albeit not deterministic. I expect the decision to be challenged by simple examples like these.

  • AnimalMuppet 9 hours ago ago

    The recent discussion was about a should. This one is an actual court decision.

    But: Not quite so fast.

    Yes, a federal judge so ruled. I wouldn't bank on it, though, until it's been through appeals court, and then the Supreme Court. This is too big a ruling, with too much money at stake; it will be appealed.