Doing Show HN generates a ton of automated email pitches

(petervandijck.com)

51 points | by petervandijck 4 hours ago ago

46 comments

  • reactordev 3 hours ago ago

    Posting anything to HN with any contact information floods my inbox with sales pitches, investment pitches, partnership pitches, scams, occasional job offer from a recruiter on the other side of the world.

    • reactordev 3 hours ago ago

      (I received one after posting this)

      • oblio 3 hours ago ago

        Hey reactordev,

        I saw your comment on HN and you look like just the right partner for my new startup: FTX for AI agent managed cryptocurrencies.

        Would you like to know more?

      • revolution88 3 hours ago ago

        Looks like they want you to stop posting :)

    • nirui an hour ago ago

      Really?

      I love it when I saw sales pitches in my inbox which is webmaster@mail.localhost, I can't wait to receive partnership pitches to my inbox noreply@my.localhost, please send promotional material to my email me@me.localhost or to my company email sale@com.localhost. Make sure to upload all files on the computer as attachments when sending the email, and keep retrying until the email is delivered, make no mistake.

  • joshstrange an hour ago ago

    Posting anything on HN gets spam.

    See my post from last week "I saw your HN Comment" [0] and the HN discussion [1].

    [0] https://joshstrange.com/2026/11/09/i-saw-your-hn-comment/

    [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50426582

  • Risse 4 hours ago ago

    Yep, it's crazy how many you get from Show HN.

    I also regret commenting to the "Seeking freelancers" post, I seriously have gotten over 20 spam emails just over the weekend.

    • LoganDark 3 hours ago ago

      My favorites are the ones that check my email domain in an automated fashion, see that it returns a status code of 403, and proceed to tell me that my LCP is slow, my scripts are unoptimized and my assets are uncompressed.

      That website is currently a text/plain 9 bytes: "Forbidden"

  • CalRobert 3 hours ago ago

    I get spam from HN, but I also sometimes get interesting messages from real people that I appreciate, which is more important to me. There's also been a few services specifically to make it easier to meet people with similar interest (findkismet, meet.hn, etc)

  • Oras 3 hours ago ago

    17 emails is really nothing, you’re selling so expect to be pitched :)

    Not saying spamming is right, definitely wrong and I ignore all these emails, but not everyone is selling in the same way.

    • pryanshu89 3 hours ago ago

      Love how we've normalised spam as a perk of doing business. :)

  • roman-kosenko 3 hours ago ago

    If you share a link to your GitHub, you can select the "Keep my email addresses private" option in your profile settings - this will prevent spam.

  • hurfdurf 4 hours ago ago

    Previously: "Tell HN: HN is being scraped for emails to scam"

    103 points by eks391 8 hours ago | 31 comments

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50513451

  • zahlman 3 hours ago ago

    > Not relevant? Just reply "no" and I won't email again.

    I've seen this verbatim several times now.

    • cornfieldlabs 3 hours ago ago

      And replying to them validates our email address as a valid spam target and also probably increases their domain reputation since reply rate is high

    • rethab 3 hours ago ago

      I've received them as well, but consistently marked them as spam. Not bothering to respond with "no".

    • baxtr 3 hours ago ago

      This is most probably included to comply with anti-spam laws / legal reasons.

      It's not spam, it's an offer to collaborate!

      • literalAardvark 3 hours ago ago

        Under EU law putting the offer in the initial mail is illegal. You must only request permission to connect.

        Sadly enforcement is rather sparse, just like with GDPR violations.

  • popcar2 3 hours ago ago

    I did a show HN for a small website I made and while I only got 13 votes it's incredible how much spam I got for it. Does ANYONE care about these emails? Who are they trying to trick?

    The worst are ones that gave me a "free spot" in their paid advertisement board so it looks like their website has lots of activity and people are paying to get their websites featured. I got something like 25 promotional emails since that post two weeks ago.

  • codenius 2 hours ago ago

    I'm a long-time non-account lurker on HN and when I wanted to use Show HN for a product I built, HN itself says there is a moratorium of sorts (for new accounts) due to the sheer volume of AI slop products.

    I'm guessing that the grift is not just in spam but also in products too.

    I think this type of aggressive marketing is driven by 'hustle' culture and "making the bag" by any means necessary.

  • jorl17 3 hours ago ago

    It's not just Show HN. I regularly get e-mails because of random comments I make.

    • RugnirViking 3 hours ago ago

      yep, same. Its often tenuously linked to something I mentioned. I have occasionally had some actual non scam stuff, but mostly when I wrote explicitly that people are free to email me as part of a longer effortful comment

  • andrewstuart 3 hours ago ago

    I was just about to post about this.

    I’ve done lots of Show HN - pre AI/LLM I got a handful of emails including some pitches, across all my Show HNs.

    The other day my show HN has resulted in maybe 20 sincere sounding AI pitches all carefully trying to approach me in just the right way.

  • miroljub 3 hours ago ago

    Isn't it how it was supposed to work?

    You publish something to HN, an internet forum, seeking publicity, and then people start reacting to it.

    Yes, more publicity, more spam. Unfortunately, that's how it works. You can either go on and fight spam or just not publish anything at all.

    • whizzter 3 hours ago ago

      I think the difference is that in the past we had:

      1: Actual people reaching out with something specific, but at least it was real people so the ratio was sane.

      2: Totally sloppy sausage enhancment spam

      The difference now is that the spam, while at least marginally relevant is targeted enough that you need to spend brainmatter to discern it before tossing (but what many of them don't realize is that their spam will become spam nonetheless and make the reputation sink).

      • stevekemp 3 hours ago ago

        I get messages like this:

        "Hi Steve I saw your comment/post on hacker news so I thought I'd get in touch to let you know we've added you to our AI directory .."

        Same story on github, "I saw your repository on CP/M and wanted to let you know we've added it to our AI directory so other users who have the same challenges can be directed to it"

        I report them as spam, and often make a GDPR request. The latter does nothing but I hope it eats up ten minutes of some interns time, and gently discourages the mass-spamming a little in the future.

    • bovermyer 3 hours ago ago

      Except these aren't people, they're usually bots. Sometimes pretty sophisticated bots, but bots all the same.

      • miroljub 3 hours ago ago

        Yes, but we lost that battle a long time ago. On the internet, you can't reach people without exposing yourself to bots. All we can do is try to fight bots, but it's not realistic to expect they'll just disappear.

  • bityard 3 hours ago ago

    Amazed that anyone is still surprised about getting spam after posting their email to a public forum.

    • marginalia_nu 3 hours ago ago

      Mostly hasn't been a problem before 2026. The CAN-SPAM act has not been revoked and emailing random addresses you find online with unsolicited spam can land you a fine of over $60k USD per email you've sent if you skirt the rules. That's mostly made that not much of a thing.

      Most spam you get is from emails sold by companies after you've signed up for something. Never sign up for anything, never get spam, has been true up until 2026. This was done to avoid honeypots.

      You still get a fairly peaceful inbox if you block anything from a sender with .ai in the address, or a sender name including "jarvis" or "assistant".

    • stavros 3 hours ago ago

      That says something about you, not about the people here. The amount of spam has really skyrocketed in the past year.

  • SMAAART an hour ago ago

    "Cold reach" is the new euphemism for sp*m.

    Wonder what the next euphemism would be.

  • salman10 3 hours ago ago

    Hah! Well once my next ShowHN doesn't get flagged I'll keep my eye out for this.

    Probably because you have your email in your about in profile?

  • ssijak 3 hours ago ago

    I suggest never to try ProductHunt then, can't get rid of the stream of spam coming because of it

  • frereubu 3 hours ago ago

    > I replaced the names of the services and the people with [brackets] and took out the links, to protect the innocent.

    Names, maybe, but none of these services are innocent! In fact, their lack of innocence is exactly why the blog post was written, no?

  • 0gs 3 hours ago ago

    yeah, maybe if your product doesn't suck! i would be thrilled to get pitches as a result of my SHNs.

  • napolux 3 hours ago ago

    having a SaaS or similar exposes you to this too.

  • marginalia_nu 3 hours ago ago

    I grieve the fact that HN is no longer a place where you can connect with cool people working on neat things with interesting things to say.

    Like we've gone from 'build something people want' to a human centipede of grifting.

    • segfaltnh 3 hours ago ago

      It's the entire industry. I don't remember the last job outreach I got for a product that seemed genuinely useful.

    • goodpoint 3 hours ago ago

      HN was already a joke

      • marginalia_nu 2 hours ago ago

        Eh it's always had some clowns but it attracted enough high quality contributors to generally make it worth while.

        What we've witnessed the last year though is something akin to the dead sea effect, a process where the quality of discussion declining as those contributors have been driven away by the declining quality of discussion.

  • RicoElectrico 3 hours ago ago

    There's too much desperation and too little dignity.

    I am curious where are those companies based.

  • youngtaff 3 hours ago ago

    Don't even need to do a Show HN to get many, many services sending you crappy autogenerated pitch emails

    I've stopped looking at how many we get as the spam filters tend to catch them successfully

  • petervandijck 4 hours ago ago

    and they're still coming in

    • brunoarueira 3 hours ago ago

      Maybe the current Show HN on the title could trigger many more (if they didn't parse it correctly), so you'll provably receive a lot more

  • LoganDark 3 hours ago ago

    I post in "who wants to be hired?" because I've been unemployed all year. I've started to just filter out any email that starts with an introduction or includes the word "confidential" or says I can unsubscribe (by reaching out, of course) or doesn't have a concrete role up front or purports to be an agency or recruitment firm or is applying to work for me. Some of them follow up multiple times. I've stopped entertaining them at all. My answer is no.

    I had someone reach out pretending to be LaunchDarkly, but then they asked for my resume/CV and that gets an automatic no. I need interviews, not scanners.

    Organic outreach wants to schedule a call right away. They don't need documents from me to apply to the job. Every job I've gotten from HN asked to schedule a call from the very first email.