58 comments

  • legacynl 3 hours ago ago

    From a former call-center phone operator, I think the 10 1-sec pushes, is just a way to make sure the customer presses the buttons long enough. In our callcenter we often had to ask customer to hold the reset button on their router for 3 seconds. When the router didn't reboot, I would send replacements, until a colleague advised me to tell customers to hold the button for 10 seconds. Apparently when you ask customers to hold the button for 3 seconds, some will actually only hold it for 1 or 2 seconds. Suddenly most customers were able to reset their routers.

    • rozularen 2 hours ago ago

      This just saved my Lenovo Legion laptop! :) My gf dropped it a few days ago, and it hadn't booted since. I had already tried the static discharge procedure, but it didn't work for some reason. After reading your comment, I figured I'd give it one more shot, and it finally booted up. Thanks a lot!

    • gpvos an hour ago ago

      The article says 10 pushes at 1-second intervals, which can each still be a very short push. Otherwise, yes, better press a little too long.

  • Freestyler_3 3 hours ago ago

    Its a standard step in troubleshooting "bricked" devices, not specifically the amount of pushes but the unplug any power source and then hit the power on button to discharge power left in the system (caps)

    • pockybum522 3 hours ago ago

      Correct on all counts. Static discharge is a strange way for the article (and tech on the phone) to say discharging capacitors but that's what it's doing.

      • kotaKat 3 hours ago ago

        The problem is if you sound too smart to the customer, it's an insult to their intelligence.

        Telling them "we're draining the flea power" and now the customer's freaking out they have a bug infestation and Dell has unleashed a storm of locusts upon them.

        • freeopinion an hour ago ago

          Ah, the balancing act of a support tech. If you ask, "Is the device plugged in?" you are condescending. If you don't ask, you waste 30 minutes. If you ever try to help a customer avoid the problem in the future by explaining the root cause you are either condescending or overcomplicating things. So you stick to the minimum, simplest communication.

          That's how you get, "Nationwide air traffic control was shutdown by a switchover from copper to fiber at a single, tiny, very remote location." And then you regret including the details "single, tiny, very remote". In the next release, you just say, "It was gophers."

        • 0xbadcafebee an hour ago ago

          This happens every time I need the customer to supply inverse reactive current to the synchronizing cardinal grammeters

    • AdmiralAsshat 2 hours ago ago

      Yeah, the advice sounded similar to what I recall a Toshiba tech once telling my dad to do when his Toshiba laptop wouldn't power on.

  • theandrewbailey 2 hours ago ago

    > Two months ago, I got a new laptop. It’s a Lenovo Thinkpad z61t. I actually ordered a t61, but I accidentally got the z61 instead — and, I actually really like it.

    The college I went to supplied every student with a Thinkpad. Everyone in my quarter got the z61p. (This college went year-round, a new class started every 3 months.) No other students before or after had z61p Thinkpads.

    Despite the high quality everyone regarded Thinkpads with, this model had some issues that only exposed themselves in a large deployment. (I don't recall any that affected my Thinkpad.) At one point, they had a Lenovo service guy come out and replace the power board in every z61p on campus.

    When students graduate, they could buy their Thinkpad for $1. I asked if they accepted change. It's probably the best laptop that I will ever buy with change. It kept working for another 5 years. Now I'm kicking myself that I had not stumbled across this back then before I threw it out.

    Today, I work in an ewaste recycling company. I haven't come across any z61p Thinkpads yet. (but I'll remember this 'one neat trick')

    • fullstop an hour ago ago

      > Today, I work in an ewaste recycling company. I haven't come across any z61p Thinkpads yet.

      My daughter started a laptop recycling club at her university where they refurbish old laptops, mostly those without the ability to run newer versions of Windows, and install Linux on them. The laptops are then paired with students who are unable to afford a laptop, through the disabilities office. The devices which are broken beyond repair go to an ewaste facility like the one you work at.

      Thanks for doing what you do -- there's so much electronic waste out there!

      • fnimick an hour ago ago

        That's so lovely to hear. I do the same thing on a small scale locally as a solo passion project - I have gotten 30+ laptops to students in need that would otherwise have gone to e-waste.

        Out of curiosity, what distribution do they use? I've got quite a few laptops sitting around atm as I'm waiting for a user-friendly atomic distribution to become available.

        • fullstop an hour ago ago

          I just asked her. Most have been Elementary OS, but they have also used Mint and Kubuntu. I'm not sure what drives that decision, other than "Let's see if they like it".

          I have used an atomic desktop for the last two years now, first Aurora-DX and now Bazzite as I actually have a GPU now. I was able to rebase from Aurora to Bazzite, and I thought that was kinda cool. It does require having a different mindset and you have to be willing to run some things in containers.

      • theandrewbailey an hour ago ago

        > mostly those without the ability to run newer versions of Windows, and install Linux on them.

        We don't have a Windows OEM license, so between the certifications and auditors, the things we sell have nothing, or Linux. The things I list on the company Ebay account have Mint (due to their OEM install option) or Debian (touchscreens work best with KDE, IMO).

        https://www.ebay.com/str/evolutionecycling

        • fullstop an hour ago ago

          That makes sense. I am so thankful for open source software, as it extends the life of so many things.

    • ToucanLoucan an hour ago ago

      We use thinkpads at our office and I mostly like them, though they can't seem to track their powered state worth a damn (which weirdly kind of intersects with the topic of the thread):

      I'm primarily a mac user due to my work but I have a thinkpad in addition to my Macbook because the company is still largely a windows shop, and accessing a lot of source code, plus managing my AD account and whatnot all needs doing with the thinkpad, and honestly that doesn't bother me, apart from seemingly every time I pull it out of my bag and it's been awhile, I have to push the power button... then hold the power button... then hold the power button... then push it a couple times... and go around with this routine for awhile before the stupid screen finally lights and it boots up.

      And I have no reason to believe this is a fault, it's done this since it was issued to me and I've witnessed coworkers also struggling with it. But yeah. Overall, great machine, I enjoy the little nipple-mouse, good stuff, but the thing seems to struggle hard with just turning off and on.

  • Sesse__ 3 hours ago ago

    My ThinkPad (X280) has a much simpler way of dealing with this: There's a tiny hole in the bottom, and if you stick something sharp into it and hold for a while, the embedded controller will reboot (or was it turn off?).

    It basically saved me from buying a new laptop at some point, when it completely refused to charge the battery for whatever weird reason (it would charge for a second or so, and then cut off, then the charger would restart it, new cut, etc.).

    • ho_schi 21 minutes ago ago

      As far as I know:

      The tiny hole resets the Embedded-Controller (EC). I think on older ThinkPads the same is done by pressing for 10 seconds continuously the power button, while the battery is removed. Other sources say 30 seconds pressing, but for me 10 were enough.

      We cannot remove the battery on newer models, therefore the tiny hole.

    • omnimus an hour ago ago

      I think that may be solving different issue. I needed to do this for lenovo yoga after using random USB-C charger that the laptop couldn't negotiate power delivery with. The controller got confused and that pin can reset the controller. It doesn't discharge the battery.

    • dlgeek an hour ago ago

      It's a battery disconnect. So it completely cuts off power for the embedded controller. (You hold for the caps to discharge).

    • andrewshadura 2 hours ago ago

      Didn't help with X270. The only thing that helped was buying the original rectangular plug charger and using that instead of USB-C.

      • Sesse__ 39 minutes ago ago

        X280 and newer doesn't have a rectangular plug anymore…

        • andrewshadura 12 minutes ago ago

          I know. X270 I think was the first one to allow charging from USB-C, and it was a bit buggy.

    • dizhn 2 hours ago ago

      I needed this exactly once on my T480S and it was great to have it.

  • ImPleadThe5th 3 hours ago ago

    I have a dead Lenovo gaming laptop that has been sitting around for the last year. Literally just tried this. And it posted for the first time since it bricked and booted right into my drive once I plugged it back in.

    I knew about discharging capacitors and tried holding the power button down and pulsing it before. But I guess this time its magic?

    I bet it'll stop working again shortly, but was funny to see.

    • tacker2000 an hour ago ago

      Strange... wouldnt these capacitors be discharged anyway if it's been sitting around for so long?

  • Neil44 35 minutes ago ago

    Seems the laptop failed to sleep and overheated in the bag. Maybe it hadn't cooled down enough the first time he popped the battery out. Modern laptops that don't have removable batteries often respond to a 20-30 second hold of power - e.g. Dells do that.

  • maybewhenthesun an hour ago ago

    Interesting.

    Had a lenovo thinkpad (another model though) 'die' one me. No way to turn it on. Actually opened it up and did some simple troubleshooting with a voltmeter, checking required voltages according to some guide. No dice. completely dead. 2 months later when I already had a new laptop I was cleaning the cupboard and was going to throw it away. Decided to stick the charger in one more time and see if something worked: good as new. (Had to put all the scavenged parts back in of course, the hdd and the ram mainly).

    It has been working fine since (I guess that was about ~10 years ago? )

  • dtgriscom 2 hours ago ago

    Tech support for naive (no offense) customers is an art. A friend's mom was a customer service rep for RCA TVs back in the day (way, way back in the day). Customers would call and complain that their TVs were doing nothing: no lights, nothing.

    The standard response would be to ask them to pull the TV's (non-polarized) plug, reverse it, and plug it back in. This was generally successful, NOT because the plug polarity mattered, but because the customer had actually forgotten to plug in their TV.

    If the rep had said "is your TV plugged in?", many customers would indignantly say "Of course!" without even checking. The "reverse your plug" request was more successful because it sounded like the customer was doing something intelligent. And, when they went to perform this task, they would discoverer that they'd forgotten to plug their TVs in. The customer could then report that the reversal worked, nobody would mention the unplugged TV, and everyone would be happy.

    • jeroenhd 28 minutes ago ago

      Similarly: when I needed to guide users to check the wiring of their DSL modems, they of course always claimed that everything was hooked up exactly as stated on the little diagram that we sent out.

      Asking them to blow the dust out of the RJ11 ports made them remove the cables and actually plug them in the right way around. Hard to say how many of them just got it right the second time and how many of them noticed their mistake but didn't want to admit it, but either way, it saved them waiting a day for a tech to come out (often at their own cost).

    • igleria an hour ago ago

      This is so thoughtful that it should be able to be transposed to software support

  • anilakar 2 hours ago ago

    I had a Microsoft Sidewinder 2 joystick that suffered from static buildup. Shelving it for a month always fixed the issue by itself. I wonder if there were hidden tricks like this to unbrick the controller.

    • xattt 2 hours ago ago

      Is it static buildup, or is there a failing cap that gets reformed after a period without power?

  • mystifyingpoi an hour ago ago

    Is there a special combination for phones with glued-in battery? Recently I had an issue with some older Samsung smartphone, where the touchscreen refused to drag lines across the lock pattern. I spent solid 20 minutes trying to unlock it, then thought for another 20 minutes how to reboot it - no hole, power button does nothing, battery at 100% so discharging it would take a day of continuously turning on the screen (or maybe suck the power via USB load).

    By accident, I've discovered that yanking out the SIM card shows up the notification that can be used to reboot the phone without unlocking. After reboot, everything worked fine again.

    • coldpie an hour ago ago

      On most Android phones for the past ~10 years, just holding the power button down for like 10 or maybe 30 seconds does a hardware reboot. I know this because it happens in my pocket all the freaking time and I hate it.

  • haritha-j 3 hours ago ago

    Not limited to thinkpads by any means, this is I believe common to most laptops. On my last MSI (no removable battery), the trick was to unplug, hold down the power button for 30 seconds, maybe press the power button a couple of times. I froget what the issue it fixed was, but it wasn't totally dead. but the logic was static discharge.

    • varispeed 3 hours ago ago

      That was the standard way to power up my Dell XPS as otherwise it wouldn't. Such a chore. So many stand ups missed because it would often take half an hour for it to "click" and power on.

  • jwrallie 2 hours ago ago

    It works even for non-ThinkPads. My coworker was looking clueless at his open Asus laptop. I said the first thing I’d try is unplugging the battery and holding the power button. He still thinks I’m a wizard.

    • Trlog 2 hours ago ago

      A lot of laptops reset the EC if you hold the power button long enough, so it's always worth trying. I've had to do this on my MSI gaming laptop because Linux wasn't able to set power states on the Nvidia GPU, which was magically resolved with an EC reset.

  • mugsie 42 minutes ago ago

    Back in the old days of working the PC Clinic in a PC World this basic thing was the go to for all laptops. You wouldn't believe the amount of broken laptops I brought back to live with this.

  • brody_hamer 2 hours ago ago

    This sounds very similar to “do the prongs on your power cable have holes in them?”

    Which, of course, doesn’t matter. It just forces you to actually unplug your device and plug it back in.

    This mostly sounds like a way to get the user to wait a solid minute before plugging the battery back in for capacitors to dissipate. There’s no way the number or duration of power button presses matters.

  • post_break 2 hours ago ago

    I love how this is so typical for windows laptops. You put them in your bag and they decide now would be a good time to turn into a nuclear meltdown. I have had this happen with a few laptops, thinkpad included, yet macs never seem to turn on when asleep in a bag.

    • jeroenhd 23 minutes ago ago

      It's a driver thing. Windows itself can do this kind of quick sleep perfectly fine, but manufacturer drivers (and sometimes ACPI bytecode) will block that process or even wake the laptop. Supposedly this has been improved at some point, but I haven't daily driven Windows in ages so I can't say for sure.

      On Mac I have the opposite problem: it's impossible to notice whether it's on or not, leading to my Bluetooth headphones often connecting to the laptop stowed away in my work bag two rooms over, preventing me from connecting it to the device I'm actually using without turning on the laptop.

  • ogig 2 hours ago ago

    I did this last week on a dead P52. It worked once, then it died again a few days later, sadly. The procedure I follow is slightly different tho, 60 seconds button press instead of the 10+30s combo. Ill try again tomorrow just in case.

  • throw839389 an hour ago ago

    I have fairly premium machine, where bios froze in idle and would not respond to power button. Disconnecting battery and leaving it over night, did the trick. I would be screwed with macbook or surface laptops!

  • ddtaylor 3 hours ago ago

    I'm currently using an Omen that "died" because I opened and cleaned it without properly discharging and slightly buzzed a random chip, which happened to be the embedded controller that operates before the BIOS does. This is basically the reason you can use USB and do some other stuff before your laptop is actually on. The problem is that when I touched that chip I scrambled some bits that stay powered via a separate internal battery that cannot be disconnected.

    At the time I did not know the secret power trick for this laptop, which is a similar way of holding the power button while inserting the charger. Instead I tried a few things and gave up because the behavior was inconsistent and frustrating. I stuffed it in a drawer and moved on with other things for a few months.

    Randomly probably two months later I opened that drawer and went "oh yeah", then proceeded to kind of just get back into the same mindset of the problem and make sure I remember it correctly, since I'm too lazy to keep notes sometimes. To my rekindled frustration I pressed the power button and it came on normally - minus a BIOS battery CMOS time thing. Sure, I was happy it worked, but I now randomly think about the fucking hours of dedicated and methodical attempts at isolating hardware components that had potentially failed in vain because this piece of shit was now running some scrambled undefined behavior code on a shadow chip.

  • attila-lendvai 2 hours ago ago

    same for my X1 Carbon Gen6, except that you need to unscrew the backplate, and disconnect the battery wiring inside. and of course no need to keep pressing the power button, just hold it down long enough to discharge the capacitors.

    happens about once a year; i.e. rare enough to scare me each time...

    i used to have an LG screen that had to be unplugged once every year or two. it acted completely dead until unplugged.

  • piltdownman 3 hours ago ago

    Same as it ever was. Who here is old enough to remember the four key boot combo for clearing the PRAM contents stored on the logic board in New World PPC Macintoshes?

    • lproven 2 hours ago ago

      Cmd + Opt + P + R

  • gambiting 2 hours ago ago

    >>Then I noticed that even though the machine had been asleep, it was really really hot.

    Oh you mean the classic windows laptop behaviour of waking up in your bag and cooking itself. Yeah, I've had that on several Dells and even a Razer windows laptop. Now I don't actually dare to put one to sleep, I just have them set to hibernate when the lid is closed - takes a few seconds longer but at least the laptop doesn't randomly turn itself into an air fryer when I'm travelling.

  • functionmouse 3 hours ago ago

    Many a computer has been saved by unplugging it and holding the power button, and then clicking it over and over again, and flicking the switch back and forth etc before plugging it back in. :)

  • aa-jv 3 hours ago ago

    My washing machine has a 'secret reset' code .. unplug it for 30 seconds, plug it back in, open and close the door 10 times, wait .. reboots.

    I kind of wonder, every time, whether this is a uboot thing.

    What a world we live in that our washing machines have a magic-sysreq thing going on ..

    • nticompass 2 hours ago ago

      My washing machine has a "debug mode" you can get to by turning the dial left/right a specific number of clicks. In this debug mode, you turn the dial to access different "options" which are shown by specific patterns on the lights. I did it once when my machine was having issues, then I realized that I didn't know what I was doing and used my warranty to have someone come and fix it (they had to replace the "control board").

    • dezgeg 27 minutes ago ago

      That's what we get when microcontrollers (which have software) are put in everything.

      My dishwasher has some button combination which entered right after power up enters factory test / diagnostic mode. It could tell the water temperature, which was useful in diagnosing whether my fix to the heater worked.

    • xattt 2 hours ago ago

      I’m sure you could skip the door opening thing by depressing the door sensor “peg”.

  • bertonvv 2 hours ago ago

    This technique is known as a CMOS reset

    • mb_thd 2 hours ago ago

      It's not. For a CMOS reset you either have to pull out the CMOS battery or press the reset button on the mainboard. (If you have either, that is)

  • pryanshu89 3 hours ago ago

    At this point, the power button is less of a switch and more of a prayer button.