53 comments

  • dbvn 2 hours ago ago
  • Waterluvian 2 hours ago ago

    I don't know anything about anything. But I'm noticing how they were protecting against terrorism-like attacks such as car bombs, but not against aerial attacks by a competent enemy. It reminds me of all the times I've read history and thought, "how could they have been so confidently wrong about what world they thought they were in?"

    I also think that Maj. Ramsbottom is probably walking into a world of pain in order to do the right thing, particularly for those who serve under him.

    • ex1fm3ta 2 hours ago ago

      It's quite normal. It only few months since US army realized that 2000$ drones could be as harmful as a tomahawk. They would surely come with A COST EFFECTIVE protection.

      • esseph 25 minutes ago ago

        Although a $2000 drone is a good tool, it is not a 1000lb tomahawk warhead payload worth of penetration and high explosives.

        Very different use cases.

    • 27183 2 hours ago ago

      It's very difficult to get institutions to anticipate threats. Investing in such activity is easily cast as chicken little type behavior. Unless you actually get hit by something, defending against it is just throwing gobs of money at a hypothetical. You see this in cyber security all the time.

      I hope Maj. Ramsbottom's efforts pay off, but this is definitely swimming upstream.

      • alistairSH 2 hours ago ago

        Ukraine and Russia have been trading drone attacks for a few years now, if not longer.

        It should have been easily foreseeable that Iran would launch drones, missiles, and everything else they have in their arsenal.

        • mandevil 11 minutes ago ago

          The US literally used reverse-engineered Iranian Shahed 136 drones in the strikes against Iran (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-cost_Uncrewed_Combat_Attac...). If they weren't anticipating being hit back by them, its because of a failure of leadership- we certainly knew they had them!

        • godwinson__4-8 2 hours ago ago

          Doubly so given Iranian drones are well known to the Ukrainians, as they have been employed widely in that conflict by the Russian side.

          When the response to the Iranian drone attacks on the United States and allies in the Gulf was first assessed some of the best commentary came from Ukraine, which was rightfully shocked by the profligate ways in which the United States attempted to defend itself given Ukraine has been forced to adopt a shoe string approach.

          Now Ukraine's leaders advise Gulf countries on how to defend themselves should there be another wave.

          The United States clearly (once again) operated from a place of extreme hubris and incompetence. Despite having senior leaders observing the battlefield in Ukraine for years. Hegseth notably does not care about that conflict and has purged the senior ranks of anyone who isn't willing to act in his image of a chest beating animal.

          Iran is a poverty state. The United States is supposed to be a hegemon. The fact it has taken months to settle into a stalemate is an embarrassment. It seems mandatory every American president in the 21st century must disgrace themselves with their own version of the Middle Eastern misadventure.

        • rasz 31 minutes ago ago

          Dec 20, 2024 https://www.twz.com/news-features/ukrainian-m1-abrams-comman...

          "American instructors AND military were completely unaware of the modern battlefield threats. And still are unaware (I communicate with some of the American tankers and try to share information with them)."

          "his trainers “are shocked that Russians can see us at night with thermal-vision recon drones (we were taught that we would be haunting the Russians who are blind at night), they do not understand at all the threat posed by the FPVs, etc.”"

          around 2024 I Found another comment about "Bradley commander who said he was taught in Germany to ride with the hatches open and they did that for about 2 days"

        • random_ind_dude 2 hours ago ago

          I think the idea was that if you kill half of the senior leadership, including the Ayatollah, in a huge bombing campaign, the rest would fold easily since the regime wasn't well-liked by the Iranian people. What they didn't anticipate was an even more competent and brutal second-rung of leaders stepping in, and the subsequent counterattacks by any means possible, that took Trump and his allies in the Gulf by surprise.

          • chuckadams 2 hours ago ago

            It turns out that even though they don't like the leadership, the average Iranian doesn't want their country to end up like Iraq.

            • dnautics 38 minutes ago ago

              If you believe the NYT, there was a plan to install ahmedinejad that went pear shaped, so in principle the administration planned for that?

          • pbhjpbhj an hour ago ago

            People appraised of the leadership structure in Iran knew that taking out the top tier wouldn't work.

            Evil people trying to make money from insider stock trading, at the cost of USA & Iranian lives didn't care to do their homework, nor even crib off the people they already paid to do the homework.

            Doing it right would include going to Congress and not issuing unlawful orders, and making far less money for the USA regime.

            They look like idiots but they're not that stupid. They weren't surprised, Trump got the 'win' he wanted.

            • jimmydddd an hour ago ago

              Retired military guys have said they have been gaming out an Iran war for twenty years. President ignored their advice and listened to our friends in the middle east instead.

              • quesera 8 minutes ago ago

                Surely, DoD has been gaming out Iran war scenarios in every cycle since 1979.

          • thisislife2 an hour ago ago

            It isn't as simple as that - most Westerners have this idea that the Iran government is a repressive regime run by a dictator. But it is actually a hybrid democratic-authoritarian-theocratic system by design. This system allowed the Iranian people to exercise some choice on who governs them. Thus, many Iranians also admired and supported it as they see it something very "Iranian", unique and specific to their culture. (Remember that Iranians, unlike the individualistic West, are a collective / cooperative society, and thus some authoritarianism is part of their culture). Indeed, talk with any foreign diplomat or politicians, and they will tell you that among the Islamic states in the middle-east, Iran is the most democratic one. Western experts on the middle-east (and even Israeli ones) are well aware of this. And so they knew that the most desirable outcome of killing the current ruler was that it trigger a civil war (remember that the Ayatollah was also a religious leader, and has a great following amongst Shia Muslims around the world). A civil war would give them an excuse to send the troops to Iran, and divide their country by occupying parts of it, while Iranians themselves would provide the cannon-fodder for the whole conflict. Americans would also be more likely to support this. It would have allowed the invaders to chip away any resistance and slowly occupy the whole country. (Remember, the ultimate goal was always colonialism and resource grab. And of course, for the Israeli religious fundamentalists, their dream of annexing Iranian territory to forge the "Greater Israel").

            Sure, the authoritarians remain in power with brute force. But we would be lying to ourselves if we don't acknowledge that there is still a substantial support for their current form of governance in the population.

            An economic blockade, or attempts to starve them is again, something foolish, as it will only strengthen the hands of the religious leaders in Iran - martyrdom is a core part of Shia Islam and Iranian culture. (But sadly, yes, it may yet allow the Americans to subjugate and colonise the Iranians in time, if they are willing to overlook the war crimes and Iranian human cost of doing so, which is quite likely - the Iranians shouldn't forget that they are fighting a superpower who is quite comfortable with genocide. In such a case, it may actually be a better strategy, in the long-term to let them occupy you and then fight them).

            • torginus 3 minutes ago ago

              I think it's some sort of Western blindness, to take something obviously sanctimonious and take it at face value. I'm sure many (most?) Christian kings of the European middle ages have claimed that their rule was necessary to worship the one true Christian god correctly, and not even the most devout Christians of today would buy this argument, and wouldn't really link their religion and feudalism together.

              It's the same with Iranians and muslims in general - some power hungry people are using religion to usurp and hold on to power. Like the Christian kings of old, some of these people might be competent and otherwise benevolent, but I don't think either the common folk or the leadership of Iran is different to the rest of us.

          • rurp an hour ago ago

            Turns out most people don't like seeing their cities hammered with thousands of bombs and tend to not side with the foreign aggressor who is murdering their children and threatening to obliterate their civilization. Who could have known?!

          • bad_haircut72 2 hours ago ago

            As Napolean himself remarked, if a general didn't anticipate something, then it isn't his fault and he's still qualified to run the war. /obvious sarcasm

            These bases got really smashed, people died! It's unbeleivable incompetence at the highest level to fail to plan like this. Look at how much planning went into Desert Storm, vs the Iran war which seems basically a back of the napkin "lets blow 'em up!!!! what are they gona even do about it??? :fistbump: :screaming_eagle_emoji:

          • ImPostingOnHN 5 minutes ago ago

            Who could have anticipated that removing a leader by force would leave a power vacuum filled by a strongman?

            Like, has that ever happened anywhere in the world? Maybe around iran?

          • anon84873628 an hour ago ago

            They also waited to attack the regime until it had a chance to kill all those protesters who were rising up against them.

            • mrguyorama 32 minutes ago ago

              They literally couldn't attack faster, because they had pulled the primary strike assets out of the middle east to go kidnap the leader of Venezuela.

          • alfiedotwtf 2 hours ago ago

            > What they didn't anticipate..

            Actually they did. Every president has been advised an air campaign in Iran is futile. Donald Rumsfeld was proven wrong that you can’t win on air superiority alone.

            .. it’s just too bad Trump fired anyone who wasn’t a yes man

            • thisislife2 42 minutes ago ago

              We've known this since World War 2 - bombing cities and people is a poor strategy to win / end any war.

        • motbus3 2 hours ago ago

          This is not the same situation as Ukraine and Iran. Iran did not suddenly relocated itself causing the need for a threat response.

          • alistairSH 2 hours ago ago

            I'm not sure what point your making?

            We attacked Iran, it should have been foreseeable that they'd retaliate and hit many of the small military installations the US has dotted all over the ME. That we didn't bother to harden those sites, failed to install early warning systems, and, if the whistleblower is correct, left soldiers to die, should be criminally negligent on the part of SecDef and the rest of senior leadership.

            • motbus3 29 minutes ago ago

              It seems we agree a 100% on the topic. I am even saying that there was no reason for such mistakes. Again, as I said, it is not like Iran moved to the border and attacked the US.

              Well, I don't even know what was the whole point of this action. Maybe give mr Poochie a bite on the allies?

          • MadrasThorn 2 hours ago ago

            Which is shocking that nobody has hardened facilities

            • dylan604 an hour ago ago

              When those facilities were built, drones didn't really exist. As for aerial threats at that time, the US clearly had superiority of the skies and fell complacent. I've seen many reports from various war games from think tanks showing how the modern US navy is susceptible to attacks from cheaper forces in superior numbers from things like speed boats to drones. Anyone from this administration claiming they had no idea of Iranian retaliation is either a) an clueless idiot out of their depth, b) lying, c) both.

      • simonh 2 hours ago ago

        To be fair to the institution, prior to March 2026 it was quite reasonable not to expect an imminent full scale air war with Iran with no warning.

        The US military doesn't get to decide for itself what conflicts it is or isn't going to get into, and must be prepared for. If the politicians suddenly decide to start a conflict, it's on them to make sure the military is capable of it.

        • flossly an hour ago ago

          If you do this in feb'26:

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Minab_school_attack

          You can expect anything by march'26.

          The US can do some regime change operation, or topple some banana republic's govt; but they cannot win a real war. Not in Vietnam, not in Ukraine, not in Iran, not in Korea. The US controlled Afghanistan to some extend, only to give control back to the Talibs they took it from. Japan capitulated to the west at the end of ww2, not because of the a-bombs, but because they preferred to capitulate to the west over losing a war with the Soviets/China (they were hated by the Chinese following several large scale massacres). Arguably the US/west/allies did not win in Europe during ww2 (the Soviets were responsible for most of Germany's losses, and D-day was started when a Soviet win was imminent).

          The US' hegemony is largely a PR campaign. Their military industry is so expensive (relatively high production cost and too much money for the middle men) that they cannot out produce even Russia.

          • dylan604 an hour ago ago

            > You can expect anything by march'26.

            To be fair, while being able to expect something does not mean you are prepared for it. As the GP stated, the politicians made this decision without expecting the reactions. Even if the military knew what was happening in feb'26, would there have been time to move things around to better defend in mar'26 given the location?

            All of this is 100% at the feet of the Trump admin. There's less of an end game here than there was under Bush.

        • rayiner an hour ago ago

          > To be fair to the institution, prior to March 2026 it was quite reasonable not to expect an imminent full scale air war with Iran with no warning.

          The military has had plans to attack Iran since the 1980s. Trump waving around a classified plan to attack Iran in 2021 was one of the key facts in the classified documents prosecution.

          • simonh 16 minutes ago ago

            I’m sure the USA has had plans for attacks on Iran since the 70s. I’m sure they have plans for military interventions in lots of places. That doesn’t mean they are always fully prepared and resourced for implementing all of them all the time.

        • rurp 2 hours ago ago

          This really shows how utterly incompetent the current administration is. The Iran war was a complete war of choice with no urgency. In a sane administration basic preparations would have been in place months before launching a major conflict. Instead they bumbled into a quagmire and got caught off guard by retaliation (Hormuz, drones, etc) so obvious that most inexperienced students would have seen coming.

        • Waterluvian 2 hours ago ago

          This feels like the "we're all trying to find the guy who did this" meme.

      • vlyan 2 hours ago ago

        >It's very difficult to get institutions to anticipate threats.

        there's no way they didn't know that Iran has missiles and drones tho.

        they just thought Iran would collapse after the opening salvo, mirroring Putin's hubris from 4 years before.

    • ripvanwinkle 7 minutes ago ago

      Generals fighting the last war

    • rayiner an hour ago ago

      The U.S. military thought that Iran would be disorganized like ISIS and Al Qaeda and didn’t realize that it is a real country.

  • dhx 2 hours ago ago

    Vantor WV02 imagery of the site at 2024-12-19: https://livingatlas.arcgis.com/wayback/#mapCenter=48.13598%2...

    It doesn't look immediately obvious from satellite imagery that the compound is important but it's got a large communications tower and is adjacent to a parking lot for what appears to be 50 tanks (at 2024-12-19), so perhaps got targeted because the tanks give away a military purpose and the mast is an obvious giveaway of something more important, as are all the barriers for stopping vehicles that you'd only bother installing if there were people working in the buildings.

    Scrolling about there is (or was) also an air/missile defence battery nearby at: https://livingatlas.arcgis.com/wayback/#mapCenter=48.14840%2...

    Seemingly the battery is there to protect the Mina Abdullah Refinery and Mina Al-Ahmadi Refinery which adjoin these sites, which Wikipedia indicates are together just a bit short of 1 million barrels per day capacity. The Kuwaiti government (probably?) has also more recently got the likes of Google, Esri, Vantor, whoever else to blur the refineries in more recent imagery, including the adjoining US military sites.

    • SV_BubbleTime 2 hours ago ago

      Maybe you are right, but that is nonstop speculation. I don’t think your public scan of photos is anything even remotely comparable to military intelligence, to the point of it being a silly exercise.

      • dhx 2 hours ago ago

        The coordinates are not speculation. You can confirm with the images provided in the related CNN article from March[2]. They've also been attached to the relevant Wikipedia article since it was created on 11th March (+10 days after the attack).[1] The air/missile defence battery nearby is extremely obvious--all of them share approximately the same layout.

        What perhaps may forever be speculation is why Iran chose to target this small compound. Maybe they called up Russia and borrowed an ELINT satellite and detected US military transmissions of interest from the communications tower next to this compound. Maybe they hacked the phone of some US military service member or followed them around. Or maybe they just saw in their own imagery that this compound was used over time for storing tanks and other equipment and therefore it was added to their list for this reason alone. My earlier comment just aims to highlight the fact the compound _could_ have been discovered to have a military purpose without fancy ELINT satellites, spies on the ground, etc. I doubt it was advertised. But it also wasn't particularly well hidden.

        [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Port_Shuaiba_drone_attack

        [2] https://edition.cnn.com/2026/03/02/politics/six-soldiers-kil...

        • sroussey an hour ago ago

          Why hack a phone when you can just buy info from US data brokers?

      • esseph 24 minutes ago ago

        OSINT is amazingly good these days, often coordinating with various state and company intelligence arms.

    • dylan604 43 minutes ago ago

      > It doesn't look immediately obvious from satellite imagery

      I think you are underplaying the assists from Russia. If you think that the targeting is being done solely based on Iranian intelligence, then you are just not using clean crystal ball. Of course Russia is sharing intel. They get to watch US capabilities be destroyed without using one piece of ordinance. It's payback for US helping Afghanistan's fight against the Russians.

  • nico 2 hours ago ago

    I’m a bit suspicious of this. It seems like it might just get used as justification to put even more money into the war

    Most of the issues in the article are complaints about not having the proper equipment or preparation for the operations they were conducting. But there’s no real criticism of the war itself

    • O3marchnative 2 hours ago ago

      In general, starting a war without proper equipment, preparation, etc. can and should be viewed as a criticism of the war itself.

      If the U.S. didn't have an "all-volunteer" military, the issues in the article would certainly be viewed as criticism of the war.

    • panzagl an hour ago ago

      A serving member of the US military cannot/will not criticize the political aspects of the operations. The military is subordinate to the civilian in political matters, and the Major is enough of a professional to recognize that.

      Whether military professionals still have a place in Hegseth's DoW is another question altogether.

      • dufgent an hour ago ago

        I'd have to say it's more professional now. Morale is waaay up, recruitment is way above levels seen with the previous CiC & SecWar. There ARE lingering issues that need to be resolved, but there always are.

        And we never have the exact mix we need to fight a war when we start the war.

        • quesera 38 minutes ago ago

          There hasn't been a previous SecWar since 1949. And there is no current SecWar.

          Your agenda is obviously on the wrong side of accuracy, so your assertions of improvement are suspect at best.

    • adrian_b 2 hours ago ago

      True.

      But at least this exposes the shamelessness of declarations like how the US government commented the loss of the US soldiers:

      > after the attack in March, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said that the US has “incredible air defenders,” but acknowledged that “one” projectile had made it through in the attack.