Article willfully neglects to mention that most of these deaths occurred within Amish communities, who weren’t getting MMR vaccines regardless of who the health secretary is/was.
Amish communities didn't appear out of nowhere in early 2025. They are pretty much a fixed entity for decades and if there is a noticeable uptick in the epidemic stats, I highly doubt it's only because Amish exist.
Clickbait headline implies someone in government said they are comfortable with child deaths from measles. No one did. In someone's opinion the US gov is comfortable with it.
While not wrong, the professor being quoted was serving in government on the CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices until the committee was disbanded by RFK Jr. last year.
I think the point is Actions speak louder than words. You can't appoint incompetent antivax leadership without consequences, and it says a lot about you. See the last paragraph of the article.
Firstly its a small proportion of vaccine prevented deaths in total. If everyone in the US stopped giving kids all vaccines it would cause over a million deaths according to that table, whereas just measles would be "only" 85,000. It could be more than an order of magnitude worse.
Its also worth bearing in mind its held down to just 10 because of a level of herd immunity because most people are vaccinated. This would be even more of a problem with vaccines that are not as effective.
It's tiny...for now. And every single one of those deaths was preventable. Not one of those children had to die except for the plague demons with human skins that are in power right now.
We had a solution. It was working. And as herd immunity goes to hell the toll will continue rising.
Unfortunately the picture is a bit more nuanced. Some of these deaths are deep in the heart of Amish and Mennonite country. You are not going to get the Old World to take a vaccine willingly, and they're the ones that are actively contributing to the issue at hand.
The other thing about preventing deaths is that it's stupid not to take "free" options that are on the table.
Getting a vaccine is nearly zero effort and cost. Wouldn't it be amazing if we could prevent things like cancer that way? We literally have that with diseases like Measles, but people just choose not to take it.
Imagine refusing a cancer or heart disease vaccine, if those existed.
> Imagine refusing a cancer or heart disease vaccine, if those existed.
Sadly, plenty of people refuse the anti-cancer HPV vaccine, or at least their parents refuse or neglect treatment. Less than 80% of eligible children have received their first shot, and less than 66% are up-to-date on their course of 3 shots.
The difference between 0 and 10 is way bigger than the difference between 10 and 100, or 1000, or whatever it ends up being. The difference between 0 and 10 represents the seed of death, and a failure on our part as a civilization.
Yeah but the Brady Campaign pulled back their bribing and Vision Zero turned theirs up so it's cars now. Give it a year or three for pharma to decide they need to invest more in politics and disease will be top dog again.
The U.S. is not comfortable with child deaths, Antivaxxers are ok with their children dying. Not vaccinating you children should at the very least be considered child neglect.
The real scary part is how measles wipes out prior immunities. Even if you survive a measles infection, you're now again susceptible to every disease you once built an immunity to through vaccination or exposure for at least the next several years.
I have been vaccinated for MMR and show absolutely no immunity response for anything but rubeola, there's a good reason for this one in particular that we need herd immunity because it's not particularly effective on an individual level.
Yea, I was surprised to learn this too when I was researching it. It's completely ridiculous we've arrived in this situation. Not only is this administration and the right-wing extremists causing all sorts of new problems, they are also resurfacing old problems that were already solved!
The waste of time, effort, and peoples' lives is absolutely ridiculous.
Apparently for some people, the vaccine is not effective - but that is ok if >90% (or whatever the figure is) are vaccinated and you achieve herd immunity. So yes, penalties and restrictions.
Several cities used COVID regulations to favor certain constituencies (protests) and disfavor others (religious gatherings) regardless of and at times in spite of what mitigations each took. Several of these ended up before SCOTUS and the outcomes were no surprise to anyone paying attention.
Between those shenanigans, and the games WHO et al played in telling "noble lies" about things like "who the masks protect" it is absolutely no wonder that certain parts of the political spectrum developed a deep mistrust of "health experts".
Whether specific fears materialized is irrelevant. If the question is "might those in power use disease fears for aims misaligned with my own welfare", the answer is clearly yes. Crying that vaccination is proven to be highly effective is to utterly miss the point of dissension.
One would've hoped that this lesson was learned when the CIA funded vaccinations in Pakistan as a cover for gathering intel on Bin Laden-- which led to mistrust of such programs, undervaccinations, and spiking disease rates later. But no, this seems like a lesson that needs to be continually relearned.
My mother would beg to differ with you. She is terrified of any possible potential side-effect of practically any drug or vaccine at all (and thinks everyone else is dumb and reckless for using them). She wastes her time hunting for anyone that has had negative side-effects (of which supposedly there are "a lot" according to her) to stroke her confirmation bias and give her ammo for when people bring it up, disagree with her, or even barely brush the subject to where she has a moment to inject this "knowledge" to the conversation.
The decline of American literacy has accelerated quite a bit in the last decade or so. There's a good chance the next generations won't learn about the 2020s, so accountability needs to be brought as soon as possible.
Call me old-fashioned but I feel like quotes in a headline are usually supposed to mean that the subject of the headline ever actually made such a statement.
I'm not sure why you're accusing me of being a part of any movement. My commentary was strictly about the use of language in the comments on the article, which, while probably off topic, did not express support for one side or the other. I was merely making an observation on the vitriol surrounding the word "antivaxxer" and comparing it to the emotional use of a different word from a few generations ago.
pffft, the U. S. has been "comfortable" with child deaths since at least Sandy Hook. A death toll that accumulates over months isn't going to get action if we don't even do anything about death tolls that take mere minutes.
Where is the pressure for change? Individuals cannot do much directly, but they can vote and campaign. You could build more public transport. You do not even need to build much infrastructure to have a good bus network. There is a lot you can do to make cars safer. Take a look at what happened in the UK (and many countries are similar): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reported_Road_Casualties_Great...
and the end result is a much lower rate than the US, even per mile travelled.
Article willfully neglects to mention that most of these deaths occurred within Amish communities, who weren’t getting MMR vaccines regardless of who the health secretary is/was.
Amish communities didn't appear out of nowhere in early 2025. They are pretty much a fixed entity for decades and if there is a noticeable uptick in the epidemic stats, I highly doubt it's only because Amish exist.
Do they not benefit from herd immunity?
Clickbait headline implies someone in government said they are comfortable with child deaths from measles. No one did. In someone's opinion the US gov is comfortable with it.
While not wrong, the professor being quoted was serving in government on the CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices until the committee was disbanded by RFK Jr. last year.
I think the point is Actions speak louder than words. You can't appoint incompetent antivax leadership without consequences, and it says a lot about you. See the last paragraph of the article.
Its tiny compared to the other causes of childhood deaths.
https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/child-health.htm
It could get much, much worse if people stop giving children other vaccinations.
> It could get much, much worse if people stop giving children other vaccinations.
Not sure what this means. Are you trying to minimize the current situation by putting it in context of hypotheticals?
In any case, diptheria yes, but otherwise Measles is up there with the worst of them:
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/73/wr/mm7331a2.htm#T1_down
Firstly its a small proportion of vaccine prevented deaths in total. If everyone in the US stopped giving kids all vaccines it would cause over a million deaths according to that table, whereas just measles would be "only" 85,000. It could be more than an order of magnitude worse.
Its also worth bearing in mind its held down to just 10 because of a level of herd immunity because most people are vaccinated. This would be even more of a problem with vaccines that are not as effective.
It's tiny...for now. And every single one of those deaths was preventable. Not one of those children had to die except for the plague demons with human skins that are in power right now.
We had a solution. It was working. And as herd immunity goes to hell the toll will continue rising.
Unfortunately the picture is a bit more nuanced. Some of these deaths are deep in the heart of Amish and Mennonite country. You are not going to get the Old World to take a vaccine willingly, and they're the ones that are actively contributing to the issue at hand.
In 1923 over 10,000 people died of measles.
The other thing about preventing deaths is that it's stupid not to take "free" options that are on the table.
Getting a vaccine is nearly zero effort and cost. Wouldn't it be amazing if we could prevent things like cancer that way? We literally have that with diseases like Measles, but people just choose not to take it.
Imagine refusing a cancer or heart disease vaccine, if those existed.
> Imagine refusing a cancer or heart disease vaccine, if those existed.
Sadly, plenty of people refuse the anti-cancer HPV vaccine, or at least their parents refuse or neglect treatment. Less than 80% of eligible children have received their first shot, and less than 66% are up-to-date on their course of 3 shots.
I agree. My kids got a full set of childhood vaccines for both the countries we lived in.
The difference between 0 and 10 is way bigger than the difference between 10 and 100, or 1000, or whatever it ends up being. The difference between 0 and 10 represents the seed of death, and a failure on our part as a civilization.
Didn't the CDC used to list guns as a leading cause of death for children?
Yeah but the Brady Campaign pulled back their bribing and Vision Zero turned theirs up so it's cars now. Give it a year or three for pharma to decide they need to invest more in politics and disease will be top dog again.
No, I'm not jaded at all. /s.
Yeah, but it used to be 0.
it's tiny until it happens to you - then it's a tragedy
That is true for every cause of death though.
The U.S. is not comfortable with child deaths, Antivaxxers are ok with their children dying. Not vaccinating you children should at the very least be considered child neglect.
It's my understanding that even if you are vaccinated, you are susceptible to measles when herd immunity is lost due to unvaccinated people.
Antivaxxers are the most selfish people around and should receive strict penalties and restrictions.
I thought this was wrong but Google says you are correct:
About 3% of fully vaccinated people never develop a strong enough immune response to the shot. These individuals remain susceptible if exposed.
Scary.
The real scary part is how measles wipes out prior immunities. Even if you survive a measles infection, you're now again susceptible to every disease you once built an immunity to through vaccination or exposure for at least the next several years.
See: https://asm.org/articles/2019/may/measles-and-immune-amnesia
It takes a pretty significant level of ignorance and/or evil to antivaxx for measles in particular.
I have been vaccinated for MMR and show absolutely no immunity response for anything but rubeola, there's a good reason for this one in particular that we need herd immunity because it's not particularly effective on an individual level.
Yea, I was surprised to learn this too when I was researching it. It's completely ridiculous we've arrived in this situation. Not only is this administration and the right-wing extremists causing all sorts of new problems, they are also resurfacing old problems that were already solved!
The waste of time, effort, and peoples' lives is absolutely ridiculous.
Apparently for some people, the vaccine is not effective - but that is ok if >90% (or whatever the figure is) are vaccinated and you achieve herd immunity. So yes, penalties and restrictions.
[flagged]
i don't know, after covid I think we can all understand antivaxxers a bit more
After covid I can understand them even _less_
I can understand them less. Their behavior killed millions of people.
(Downvoting this won't erase your guilt.)
Literally none of the fear of antivaxxers happened. All their predictions failed to realize
Several cities used COVID regulations to favor certain constituencies (protests) and disfavor others (religious gatherings) regardless of and at times in spite of what mitigations each took. Several of these ended up before SCOTUS and the outcomes were no surprise to anyone paying attention.
Between those shenanigans, and the games WHO et al played in telling "noble lies" about things like "who the masks protect" it is absolutely no wonder that certain parts of the political spectrum developed a deep mistrust of "health experts".
Whether specific fears materialized is irrelevant. If the question is "might those in power use disease fears for aims misaligned with my own welfare", the answer is clearly yes. Crying that vaccination is proven to be highly effective is to utterly miss the point of dissension.
One would've hoped that this lesson was learned when the CIA funded vaccinations in Pakistan as a cover for gathering intel on Bin Laden-- which led to mistrust of such programs, undervaccinations, and spiking disease rates later. But no, this seems like a lesson that needs to be continually relearned.
My mother would beg to differ with you. She is terrified of any possible potential side-effect of practically any drug or vaccine at all (and thinks everyone else is dumb and reckless for using them). She wastes her time hunting for anyone that has had negative side-effects (of which supposedly there are "a lot" according to her) to stroke her confirmation bias and give her ammo for when people bring it up, disagree with her, or even barely brush the subject to where she has a moment to inject this "knowledge" to the conversation.
[dead]
You mean we can understand their stupidity even better?
Move the antivaxxers into leper colonies.
The bar lowers a little bit each day this is the natural result.
At the current rate the US is going to need Nuremberg-style trials in a couple of years.
The US has suffered from a lack of accountability for the last 40 years.
The decline of American literacy has accelerated quite a bit in the last decade or so. There's a good chance the next generations won't learn about the 2020s, so accountability needs to be brought as soon as possible.
I'd say more like 60yr. Johnson declining to seek reelection over 'nam isn't the exact end of it but it's a pretty good landmark.
Call me old-fashioned but I feel like quotes in a headline are usually supposed to mean that the subject of the headline ever actually made such a statement.
I can't define the rule, but headlines worded like this make me irrationally angry, which is probably the point.
I'm in the US and I'm not comfortable with children dying... Better click and figure out what those idiots on the other side are saying!
[dead]
[dead]
The way most of y'all throw around the term "antivaxxer" bears a striking resemblance to the way people almost a century ago used the word "Juden."
No. It bears a striking resemblance to the way people almost a century ago used the word "antivaccinationism".
As in the literal "Anti-vaccination Society of America", founded in 1879, and the "Anti-vaccination League of America", founded in 1908.
Yes, you're part of very proud, very dumb, almost 150-years-old anti-truth movement. The more things change...
I'm not sure why you're accusing me of being a part of any movement. My commentary was strictly about the use of language in the comments on the article, which, while probably off topic, did not express support for one side or the other. I was merely making an observation on the vitriol surrounding the word "antivaxxer" and comparing it to the emotional use of a different word from a few generations ago.
pffft, the U. S. has been "comfortable" with child deaths since at least Sandy Hook. A death toll that accumulates over months isn't going to get action if we don't even do anything about death tolls that take mere minutes.
Car deaths are another big one. It's fascinating how accepting we are of them.
I wouldn't say fascinating... perhaps horrific.
But what other choice do the majority of people have, who (in the US) mostly live in (maybe not even by choice) a car-centric no-mass-transit city?
Where is the pressure for change? Individuals cannot do much directly, but they can vote and campaign. You could build more public transport. You do not even need to build much infrastructure to have a good bus network. There is a lot you can do to make cars safer. Take a look at what happened in the UK (and many countries are similar): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reported_Road_Casualties_Great...
and the end result is a much lower rate than the US, even per mile travelled.
over 1 per 100 million
https://fatalroads.com/
compared to 4 per billion.
https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/reported-road-casua...