14 comments

  • davesque 7 hours ago ago

    Isn't kernel development one of their banned topics in their public facing models? The ethics of this are just so inherently dirty. They can enjoy the benefits--the sum value of all that compiled knowledge--but not us. If open models don't succeed, the future is looking pretty bleak. Really. This normally feels like such a tin hat thing to say, but damn if it doesn't feel true right now.

    • mrinf1nity 7 hours ago ago

      That's because that's how it is, and not only that, they can use whatever un-used compute to do it. If they're at 30% capacity they can have 70% of max data center resources do all the things we can't do, with the things we can't and don't have (because of price fixing and circular economies).

      Honestly it's probably just a matter of time before we all have a tiny little Rasp-Pi looking thing that powers AI locally, bring back self-hosting IMO after seeing the Office 365 stuff down.

      You know damn well they have teams working on some crazy stuff behind the scenes. We're just here to fund them by buying tokens.

    • blargey 7 hours ago ago

      > Isn't kernel development one of their banned topics in their public facing models?

      I see various fable/opus-vibecoded "kernels" (and even benchmarks) of various flavors just searching for "fable kernel" or "fable kernel gpu".

      The barrier to trying this sort of thing yourself is prob more the token consumption * API prices (and expert oversight?) required for a serious project than the security/CYA restrictions.

      • lisplist 6 hours ago ago

        People constantly hit security guardrails doing kernel and inference engine development. Not too hard to work around them, but its very frustrating. Not to mention the publicly released Fable 5.2 intentionally nerfs its kernel optimization knowledge. Meanwhile, Mythos can write Anthropic engineers whatever kernels they'd like.

    • mrheosuper 4 hours ago ago

      Not sure about their policy, but i see LLM-gen PR to opensource RTOS all the time.

  • AMDAnon 4 hours ago ago

    AMD doesn't get access to Fable or Mythos. Big problem now that non-Mythos is locked out of doing GPU development work.

    Nvidia has access to everything at huge discounts, including unreleased models.

    The "moat" is that anyone who isn't a $1+ trillion company or an AI lab is going to be locked out of the cartel going forward because they don't want you competing in their space as they consume more of the economy.

    So yes, Mythos can one-shot CUDA, but only Anthropic/OpenAI are allowed to use it.

  • catigula 7 hours ago ago

    This will happen to any easily verifiable domain.

    • epylar 5 hours ago ago

      So the question becomes - how do we ease verification in hard-to-verify domains?

  • jraph 5 hours ago ago

    Just before Anthropic's IPO, just after it looks like nvidia may be struggling. How convenient!

    How do we know it's not another lie, or full of conveniently hidden limitations? But I guess that works, investors will be appeased enough either way.

    AMD is not AI's bank though, so their cards are the wrong cards to run AI on (and that might be the reason we've not seen a "we can run on AMD too!" announcement earlier)

  • nsoonhui 7 hours ago ago

    I doubt whether this will eventually be the undoing of Nvidia -- no, Jensen's affair doesn't even count.

    If Claude, which is trained on Nvidia chip, becomes so powerful that it allows developers to get onboard with ecosystems other than CUDA easily, what moat does Nvidia still have?

    Remember, CUDA is widely viewed as the greatest -- some even say only -- moat Nvidia has. You can duplicate the hardware, the software, but you can't duplicate the developer ecosystem. Developers are reluctant to change because it really takes time and they don't want to ditch existing, mature toolsets and ecosystem.

    But with Claude being so powerful, it becomes vastly easier to learn new skills and to duplicate the toolsets. The switching cost drops significantly, so what is there to prevent China or anyone else to switch to Huawei or AMD or other ecosystem?

    • nolroz 6 hours ago ago

      I think anthropic mentioned a lot of work on multi vendor chips, so they might have filled the moat already?

  • Creamsicle47 8 hours ago ago

    Ironic this is the same company trying to prevent people from modding Skate 3 inside of Minecraft

  • cromka 8 hours ago ago

    "Not like that!"

    - NVIDIA, probably.

  • troymc 7 hours ago ago

    "Anthropic Fills NVIDIA's Metaphorical Moat with Metaphorical Gravel"