63 comments

  • xrd 3 minutes ago ago

    I can't help but think of the all-drug Olympics.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAdG-iTilWU

    It feels like there will be a new class of companies that will revel in hiring people who are the best at what is currently described as cheating.

    This is an arms race that won't be won by teachers who are already overwhelmed themselves by testing requirements. They are fighting tech companies who are forcing solutions to those requirements down the teachers' throats.

    You could make a good sci-fi story about a counter insurgency teacher who assists students in cheating and then goes underground as a revolutionary.

  • nomilk 2 hours ago ago

    > Glasses and shirt buttons will be examined to stop cheating in South Korea’s college entrance exams

    I think until ~6 months ago you'd have needed an accomplice to pull off any meaningful remote cheating (e.g. accomplice would see via camera and send you answers via vibration or voice, depending on the exam format and hardware). But I suspect an agentic setup could be used now, probably trivially?

    • montroser 2 hours ago ago

      Yes, and even with a purely local setup. You could pretty easily sew into your clothes a CM5 with all of Wikipedia and a 4B reasoning model with a search tool and access to a python interpreter.

      In the future, we will have smart contact lenses and the CM5 will be the size of a grain of rice, embedded not in our clothes, but in our bodies!

  • adrianN 2 hours ago ago

    When AI agents can pass large parts of university exams we will soon need to examine the value of university education.

    • mminer237 42 minutes ago ago

      The same with Wolfram|Alpha invalidating math education? Even just having access to Google or just a text book during the exam would let a ton of people pass a ton of knowledge-based exams. I don't think this substantially devalues knowledge still.

      People have been advocating for application-based exams for a long time, but that's really hard and intensive and as a result almost very narrowing. School teaches you chemistry or physics or history or English or whatever, but there are so many fields where you need to specifically learn the applications of the knowledge afterwards. Plus many things just don't have a direct application. You just have to learn X, in order to learn Y, in order to learn Z, etc. Or just because it's good knowledge for a functional adult to know. Saying "I can look this up" doesn't replace the value of actually knowing it yourself and able to recall and apply it as needed.

      Programs which can easily move beyond just testing knowledge, like education, medical, law, art, generally do have pretty heavy application-based grading already.

    • stackedinserter a minute ago ago

      > examine the value of university education

      It's long overdue, as well as 1/2 of school "education" program.

    • fidotron 2 hours ago ago

      It does depend on the subject.

      This whole evolution of AI agents really is bringing into question which parts of the human experience are most valuable, and it's likely to become deeply uncomfortable.

      • 10111001 23 minutes ago ago

        > This whole evolution of AI agents really is bringing into question which parts of the human experience are most valuable, and it's likely to become deeply uncomfortable.

        The answer: private property ownership. It's the only part of human experience that's valuable. Everything else: labor, knowledge, skill, even art will be replaced by automation.

      • SAI_Peregrinus 29 minutes ago ago

        A big part of that discomfort is due to the inherent differences between our economic systems' values and our social and ethical values. The former is not aligned with the latter.

      • SketchySeaBeast an hour ago ago

        Valuable, or easiest to monetize? I'm not sure what LLMs are telling us about human experience.

        • bilbo0s an hour ago ago

          To be fair, the commenter did say the questions would become "deeply uncomfortable".

    • lukan 2 hours ago ago

      Or we need to examine the way we do tests.

    • steve1977 2 hours ago ago

      We should have done that a while ago already, even before AI.

    • atleastoptimal 2 hours ago ago

      AI, once it supersedes humans in all intellectual faculties, will herald the "intelligence curse", where human intelligence no longer has any societal return on investment.

      https://intelligence-curse.ai/

      • nisegami an hour ago ago

        I am amenable to viewpoints like that, but the opening being "We will soon live in the intelligence age. What you do with that information will determine your place in history." just makes it seem like the site is trying to instill a sense of urgency to sell me something. Plus, anyone who genuinely believes in a coming "intelligence age" should well understand that their place in history is already decided.

        • atleastoptimal 32 minutes ago ago

          It makes sense to have a sense of urgency when a sense of urgency is sensible.

          >anyone who genuinely believes in a coming "intelligence age" should well understand that their place in history is already decided.

          No there are a lot of things you can do now to change your place in history.

    • mschuster91 2 hours ago ago

      Agreed. Whenever something becomes a KPI, there will be someone gaming the system.

      And the last decades have shifted from universities being for those academically interested only to universities being yet another checklist on people's life plans, a mandatory hurdle to jump over, and on top of that a perfect way for (large) companies to shift education costs from them (i.e. the classic apprenticeship/trainee model) to the candidates themselves by way of (non-dischargeable!) student debt.

      • bluGill 2 hours ago ago

        Universities have always been for those looking for a checklist - the rich noble kids needed that checkmark in Shakespeare's day. They let commoners (which itself was rarely merit based) interested in academics go as well to provide the next generation of professors.

    • lenerdenator 2 hours ago ago

      I'd much rather deal with a human with the ability to navigate 4 years of an undergraduate degree than an AI agent that just happens to have the right weights for answering a question.

      • Lucasoato 2 hours ago ago

        Or both, an human that knows his things and knows when and how to use AI agents.

    • reducesuffering 38 minutes ago ago

      When AI agents are better at knowledge tests than 99% of college students, we will soon need to start calling things like they are:

      Artificial General Intelligence

    • tester756 an hour ago ago

      Why would we?

    • ldoughty an hour ago ago

      I work university-adjacent in education and I'm really curious to see where AI-assisted education and AI-assisted work goes. I've personally been learning a lot from AI using it as a tool to further my education in a field I'm interested in -- and as a personal interest topic (not a forced education topic) I'm not cheating any system or just copy/pasting responses. I'm having actual socratic learning dialogue with an AI agent (fully understanding the limitations of AI as a teacher here).

      We do still need to press for critical thinking skills but we need to properly teach what AI can and can't do... How to ask follow-up questions with AI to hunt for hallucinations. We should be rethinking how people live/work alongside AI like it's the new "power tools" technology.

    • free_bip 2 hours ago ago

      When AI agents can pass large parts of Kindergarten exams we will soon need to examine the value of Kindergarten education.

      • soco 2 hours ago ago

        When cars can go long distances we will soon need to examine the value of walking (long distances).

    • scarecrowbob 9 minutes ago ago

      It's been really nice that recently, because of the invention of the fork lift, I no longer go to the gym to work out. Saves me a lot of time.

    • pupppet 2 hours ago ago

      Only if you believe the reason we go to school is to be able to regurgitate information.

      • pier25 2 hours ago ago

        Exactly. A big part of education is learning and developing cognitive skills. And in many careers (eg medical) students need to spend years training on the job.

    • 10111001 26 minutes ago ago

      > When AI agents can pass large parts of university exams we will soon need to examine the value of university education.

      You're not going far enough. We will soon need to examine the value of human beings (or at least human beings who are not rich). Market economics is the true measure of all things, and frankly, soon humans will be unable to compete.

      Personally, I propose that, for the masses, we replace university education with TikTok and ads, to take advantage of the last monetization opportunities before disposal.

      • warkdarrior 16 minutes ago ago

        Insurance already does that.

    • c16 2 hours ago ago

      You mean regurgitating information already readily available to anyone beyond the confines of an exam hall? Much more valuable to see someone apply the available knowledge (coursework + defend in person).

    • bagacrap 2 hours ago ago

      Yes, just as we should question the value of exercise given that we have motorcycles.

    • dallen33 2 hours ago ago

      > examine the value of university education

      What a stupid thing to say.

    • loloquwowndueo 2 hours ago ago

      But AIs are just a tool, right? Right?!

    • gosub100 2 hours ago ago

      (for the US) It's a great regulatory-captured, gate-kept racket for overpaid administrators and athletic do-nothings while enjoying built-in profit margins each year. I can't think of a more profitable enterprise and can't imagine them dissolving it.

    • 3asu5z 2 hours ago ago

      If universities were independently funded and refrained from using AI, the traditional checks and balances system would remain. You need both a functioning academia and journalism to keep the oligarchy in check.

      But many big name professors sell out as we speak, so the future truth will be dictated by ClosedAI and Misanthropic.

      Any university taking AI money or allowing AI use should be defunded by the public immediately.

    • threethirtytwo 2 hours ago ago

      Tons of people hate university education and call the whole thing useless. I agree with this notion slightly in the sense that you can actually learn all this shit yourself for free. That is not to say university education is completely useless though.

      What I hate about this comment is how it’s redirecting AI to promote their political desire to end university education.

      Bro. AI is bigger than that. We will soon need to examine the value of education itself.

      • glitchc 2 hours ago ago

        Most people don't learn anything on their own. Without incentives, the vast majority of the population would be terrible at reading, writing and math. Without those core skills, other subjects become largely inaccessible.

      • nradov an hour ago ago

        It's tough to learn anything involving laboratory science on your own. Certainly not for free.

      • rexpop an hour ago ago

        Having a place to go where everyone is disciplined, and sacrificing opportunity elsewhere to focus on learning (especially overlapping subjects) for a few years is immensely valuable—more so than solely sitting by oneself to cram.

      • mjr00 2 hours ago ago

        > Bro. AI is bigger than that. We will soon need to examine the value of education itself.

        What is the implication here, that because of AI people no longer need to be educated?

        • techdmn 2 hours ago ago

          Because of AI, they'll no longer need people. Workers have always caused problems.

        • threethirtytwo 2 hours ago ago

          My company hired some programmers based on how liked she was during the interview. Her technical skill was largely ignored and dismissed.

          Why? Because ai does it all now.

          • mjr00 2 hours ago ago

            You seriously think that companies hiring people because they are personable and attractive instead of skillful is a new thing? That this didn't happen before AI? And now we need to dismantle the education system?

            The proverb "It's not what you know, it's who you know" has been around for a very long time.

      • vel0city 2 hours ago ago

        > I agree with this notion slightly in the sense that you can actually learn all this shit yourself for free.

        I both 100% agree with this in theory and 90% disagree with this in practice. Its like saying you can go become a pro athlete without ever having a single coach in your life. Sure, its possible. Lots of drills and workouts are all written down, just go do them. But having a well-skilled coach who is able to direct you, keep you on task, point out things you're missing, and more is incredibly valuable. In that same vein good educators are your educational coaches. There are tons of topics I would have never chosen to go down, have my original assumptions challenged, and more by having good educators in my life. Both in traditional school and elsewhere.

        For sure, once you cross the hurdle of knowing how to read then its all there, just go read the book. The challenging part is having people build you up, point you to the next attainable challenge, and help you when you're struggling.

  • imglorp 2 hours ago ago
    • warkdarrior 11 minutes ago ago

      How will an RF detector fight AI? And what about AI over Ethernet?

    • andai an hour ago ago

      I noticed my $5 AM/FM pocket radio can do the same thing. Picks up all sorts of bizarre noise around the house, even from tiny devices.

      This thing definitely looks cooler though.

  • piker 2 hours ago ago

    Shouldn’t have announced the alert. It will be subverted by the most willing to cheat and could have been used to terrify future test cheats by making an example of this crop of cheaters.

    • Macha 2 hours ago ago

      I mean, there’s literally everyone else with a phone to think of.

      • piker an hour ago ago

        Honestly seems a price worth that society paying. If academic dishonesty is rampant in your youth, is that not a national emergency?

  • dpkirchner an hour ago ago

    A ten year ban seems disproportionate to the "crime". I bet they'll see a spike in youth suicides.

    • stronglikedan 37 minutes ago ago

      > A ten year ban seems disproportionate to the "crime".

      I agree. A lifetime ban would be more proportionate. People who think it's acceptable to cheat don't change their stripes. They just cheat upwards unless/until they are caught.

  • voidhorse an hour ago ago

    S.K. uses the emergency phone alert system extensively. When we visited they were going off constantly for situations ranging from excessive heat warnings to missing elderly people.

  • turtleyacht 2 hours ago ago

    Remember, just do a little better than average:

    Korea Tax Accountant Top Scorer Confesses AI Cheating - 2 days ago - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50503069

  • eunos 2 hours ago ago

    Ask Fable to create a miniatuized camera and audio signal equipment next. Anyway I heard in China during Gaokao they have signal jammer used

  • metalman an hour ago ago

    simple way to fix it is to anounce that henceforth all GRADUTION exams will be held in farady caged buildings while wearing monastic robes handed to you ,standing there naked, or very close to it, after bieng scanned. AI is just other peoples work, is often wrong enough to fail a real world project, but as we know, perfectly capable of passing a generic information quiz, and nobody needs hundreds of thousands(millions?) of newly minted cheaters a year.

  • mschuster91 2 hours ago ago

    > South Korea is known for its intense academic competition, where job opportunities, social standing and even marriage prospects often hinge on which school a person attends.

    To me, the solution rather is to get rid of this utterly deranged bullshit of a system...

    • DanielHB 2 hours ago ago

      Brazil has a similar system and although it is brutal it is also one of the few things keeping rampant nepotism and elitism in check. Think about how it works in the Ivy league in the US, but 10x worse.

      Only a big economics study can really analyze what system is better for society overall.

      Truly the only way to actually solve this issue is to have a relatively low bar to get into the unis, but a high bar to graduate (so people filter out over the years). Sweden works a bit like this, but this is quite more expensive and the more prestigious unis still have to filter a lot.

      • ch4s3 2 hours ago ago

        South Korea has shockingly low labor productivity per hour given the the much higher level of education vs the rest of the OECD. They are also the 5th highest in hours worked in the OECD. So they work more at lower levels of productivity Moreover the South Korean government reports that nearly 40% of teens experience severe depression in any given year, which is a shockingly high number. And to top this off the country has very low social mobility, so there is immense pressure to not get filtered down the economic ladder based on a few tests. It's pretty clear that their system isn't good for society.

      • Macha 2 hours ago ago

        Also you know, South Korea’s birth rate of 0.8 children per woman.

    • dguest an hour ago ago

      I know it's all a spectrum but the US also technically hits all these:

      - I know companies where "attended an Ivy" got your application into the right pile.

      - I felt a new warmth from a few of my friend's parents when I told them I'd ended up in a "better" school.

      - Marriage prospects (for some) have always hinged on social standing.

      I guess people who have experience in both countries could comment: is S. Korea that much more extreme?

    • diegolas an hour ago ago

      pretty much