> Money flowed like water without much regard for legal niceties. Speed was paramount.
>[0] [F]ormed in March 1941... The Truman Committee proved to be one of the most successful investigative efforts ever mounted by the U.S. government: an initial budget of $15,000 was expanded over three years to $360,000 to save an estimated $10–15 billion in military spending and thousands of lives of U.S. servicemen. For comparison, the entire cost of the simultaneous Manhattan Project, which created the first atomic bombs, was $2 billion.
Even after the war, influential people saw what was brewing, like in Dwight D. Eisenhower's 1961 farewell address:
> In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military-industrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist. We must never let the weight of this combination endanger our liberties or democratic processes. We should take nothing for granted. Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry can compel the proper meshing of the huge industrial and military machinery of defense with our peaceful methods and goals, so that security and liberty may prosper together.
Unfortunately people either didn't get it, didn't listen, or actively worked against it.
I agree with the general sentiment, but the McMahon appointment likely was due to cronyism and loyalty. This admin is too stupid and self-serving to do anything destructive with nuance, save for blindly following the orders given in Project 2025.
Now it's not even fast. Patriot supply cannot be replenished in time. Iran was should have taken a week, tops. Russia seems stronger than ever. Morale low. Budget high. Middle-East bases are ravaged (never going to get rebuilt).
We've known for twenty years that wargames and simulations of war with Iran were slow and costly. Why would anyone have thought it would be over in a week? Brash overconfidence like this is why we keep getting into issues.
> Patriots are complex. It’s the wrong tool for the job.
Patriots are the best tool for a part of the job, and the wrong tool for other parts. The cheap drones should have been countered by cheap drones - Ukraine has plenty of experience. However Iran has ballistic missiles that a cheap drone cannot intercept and there a patriot is the correct tool.
The only reason the Patriots are the wrong tool is cost. If they could get the cost of an intercept down to $500 they would be better than a drone since they are more automatic. Even at $5000 per intercept I'd still be willing to use them against a $500 drone because there are lots of other costs to a cheaper drone interceptor (well trained staff on duty 24x7 is not cheap) and so $5000 is cheaper in the long run.
The US cannot make enough patriots for Ukraine to intercept all the ballistic missiles coming at them, and that is unacceptable.
Each conflict listed was by an aggressor for empirical conquest. None of them should be quick because none of them should have started. Each one a catastrophic failure of leadership and loss of life for nothing but personal, individual manifest.
"The Pentagon is a vast bureaucracy that has struggled with some 149 financial management systems, many of which are inadequate and outdated. They include technology built on 50-year-old computer code."
"Among economic scholars, Friedman has no peer. His seminal contributions to economics are legion, including his development of the permanent-income theory of consumer spending, his paradigm-shifting research in monetary economics, and his stimulating and original essays on economic history and methodology.
...
Let me end my talk by abusing slightly my status as an official representative of the Federal Reserve. I would like to say to Milton and Anna: Regarding the Great Depression. You're right, we did it. We're very sorry. But thanks to you, we won't do it again." -Ben Bernanke
I love that so many people will acknowledge this, and turn around and complain that the government isn’t involved in some sector enough. Bonus points that the typical targets are already places the government is messing with actual free markets.
Spoiler: It's not the same people acknowledging this who also want the government involved in more sectors.
The people who "acknowledge" (or believe this falsehood, more precisely) this are exactly the ones who want the government less involved in most things.
That's why centralization of power is a problem. Pentagon get power from the federal level. Fedgovt makes money by taxing+quantativeEasing+debt (all have never been so high). And the duo-party system ensures nothing's going to change.
Murray Bookchin suggested a nice idea that allows bottom-up power structures that still allow complex modern societies with lots of specialization. This would decentralize power to some extend.
Which irresponsible citizens relying on the safety net are you referring to?
> Were the majority of Americans similarly fiscally responsible, irresponsible politicians would not win elections.
Ridiculous claim. Budgeting failures are not the result of some people voting for an unbalanced budget and some people voting against a balanced budget. It's the result of people voting for the services they believe a government should provide (and not the ones it shouldn't), and also voting for the taxes they believe a government should be collect (and not the ones it shouldn't).
You can get a perpetually fucked up budget with a grand total of zero people attempting to create a fucked up budget.
But in this case, we did have people who attempted and succeeded at creating a fucked up budget. Simply repealing the "Big Beautiful Bill" would halve the deficit.
It's not the whole truth tho, it works in a feedback loop, people who argued for more support for the "irresponsible" citizens almost trained new generations to be that, because there was no punishment, and more, it might be just optimal action to take.
So the people raised inept government who raised more inept people that get baited by people promising handouts and pick the next generation of inept government.
As usual, those who fashion themselves as temporarily embarrassed billionaires think being poor is more unethical than the endless corruption and greed of the wealthy.
I have neighbors who are paycheck-to-paycheck because they drive brand new cars and put vacations on credit cards, they eat out constantly, have streaming services, video games, etc. They have lots of money, but they are irresponsible with it. This statement describes the cultural and political zeitgeist.
It's a moral good to care for the helpless. It's a moral ill for capable people to dissipate their wealth on entertainment only to later stress the safety net that others genuinely depended on.
> The people always get the government they deserve.
This is an idealistic statement dressed up as cynicism. You assume an ethical electorate would perfectly discover the politicians who are most capable of whipping votes. You also assume those same politicians' campaigning skills are 1:1 with their governing skills.
This is the same logic as PGP zealots who thought we'd all be safe and secure if only we could teach the crummy users cryptography. They optimized out UX (at the least!) from their worldview. You seem to have optimized out the very practice of politics.
Explain how an 1 year old child born above the 40th parallel "deserves" to live under North Korean rule while a 1 year old child born below it "deserves" to live under South Korean rule?
Explain how a woman born with black skin in antebellum United States deserves to be raped and beaten daily, while the very same government, in the exact same time and place gives a man born in white skin the "right" to conduct such rape and beating with impunity?
It's gobsmackingly dumb on top of being transparently and despicably evil.
When we are conquered, which I don't desire, we will have deserved it.
I hope nobody here will be all po' faced when none of our expensive but corrupted systems actually perform, in a hot war. It'll be so embarrassing when that happens, but not even a little surprising. Bleh, what a world!
I can't find a video, but this reminds me of the news broadcast about how a toilet seat is $600 because of all the audit requirements. If they're paying $600 (and this was like in 1995 or something) for a toilet seat, then shouldn't they have offices full of people that know exactly how 1 trillion is spent? Isn't that the flex - that we're paying $600 for that so we know how much ALL of it costs?
Every once in a while (I last heard this in 1980) you hear of some scammer who sends invoices to companies for "service" just to see if it is paid. I'm told this is why I have to fill out an expense report - my company trusts me to buy a USB stick and it isn't worth auditing. What they don't trust is if they don't track everything somebody else won't start billing for USB sticks in the name of every employee - 500 USB sticks billed for [never delivered] is a nice income for a couple hours work by a scammer.
It's usually a tolerance window such as "within +/- x% of the forecast". For a large budget such as a trillion dollars, to pass a small threshold like 3% is akin to threading a needle with an elephant.
Discussion (129 points, 15 hours ago, 52 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50525658
I'm reminded of what happened to the US military in the transition between pre-WW2 and WW2.
Before the war, they were obsessed with paperwork and procedure. Messing that up could ruin a career.
After the war started? Money flowed like water without much regard for legal niceties. Speed was paramount.
> Money flowed like water without much regard for legal niceties. Speed was paramount.
>[0] [F]ormed in March 1941... The Truman Committee proved to be one of the most successful investigative efforts ever mounted by the U.S. government: an initial budget of $15,000 was expanded over three years to $360,000 to save an estimated $10–15 billion in military spending and thousands of lives of U.S. servicemen. For comparison, the entire cost of the simultaneous Manhattan Project, which created the first atomic bombs, was $2 billion.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truman_Committee
Even after the war, influential people saw what was brewing, like in Dwight D. Eisenhower's 1961 farewell address:
> In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military-industrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist. We must never let the weight of this combination endanger our liberties or democratic processes. We should take nothing for granted. Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry can compel the proper meshing of the huge industrial and military machinery of defense with our peaceful methods and goals, so that security and liberty may prosper together.
Unfortunately people either didn't get it, didn't listen, or actively worked against it.
> Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry
Thus ensuring the undermining of education. Linda (I think?) McMahon in charge of education? Tag me in so I can do a body slam.
I agree with the general sentiment, but the McMahon appointment likely was due to cronyism and loyalty. This admin is too stupid and self-serving to do anything destructive with nuance, save for blindly following the orders given in Project 2025.
Now it's not even fast. Patriot supply cannot be replenished in time. Iran was should have taken a week, tops. Russia seems stronger than ever. Morale low. Budget high. Middle-East bases are ravaged (never going to get rebuilt).
Only Venezuela was "quick".
I'd say: why even bother with audits?
We've known for twenty years that wargames and simulations of war with Iran were slow and costly. Why would anyone have thought it would be over in a week? Brash overconfidence like this is why we keep getting into issues.
Iran was never going to be quick.
Patriots are complex. It’s the wrong tool for the job.
> Patriots are complex. It’s the wrong tool for the job.
Patriots are the best tool for a part of the job, and the wrong tool for other parts. The cheap drones should have been countered by cheap drones - Ukraine has plenty of experience. However Iran has ballistic missiles that a cheap drone cannot intercept and there a patriot is the correct tool.
The only reason the Patriots are the wrong tool is cost. If they could get the cost of an intercept down to $500 they would be better than a drone since they are more automatic. Even at $5000 per intercept I'd still be willing to use them against a $500 drone because there are lots of other costs to a cheaper drone interceptor (well trained staff on duty 24x7 is not cheap) and so $5000 is cheaper in the long run.
The US cannot make enough patriots for Ukraine to intercept all the ballistic missiles coming at them, and that is unacceptable.
Each conflict listed was by an aggressor for empirical conquest. None of them should be quick because none of them should have started. Each one a catastrophic failure of leadership and loss of life for nothing but personal, individual manifest.
Why even bother with any of them.
"The Pentagon is a vast bureaucracy that has struggled with some 149 financial management systems, many of which are inadequate and outdated. They include technology built on 50-year-old computer code."
Didn't expect it to be this bad
It might work just fine. It has run for 50 years. Bugs are shaken out.
Emacs is 50 years old. TeX is 49. The famously rigorous Space Shuttle code was started 53 years ago.
It’s likely immune to bad PHP patches.
No?
"If you put the federal government in charge of the Sahara Desert, in five years, there’d be a shortage of sand." - Milton Friedman
Ah yes, the Chicago School of economics. The folks who brought us Reaganomics, who told us that monopoly was ok as long as it didn't raise prices.
By the way, there is a sand shortage. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20191108-why-the-world-is...
"Among economic scholars, Friedman has no peer. His seminal contributions to economics are legion, including his development of the permanent-income theory of consumer spending, his paradigm-shifting research in monetary economics, and his stimulating and original essays on economic history and methodology.
...
Let me end my talk by abusing slightly my status as an official representative of the Federal Reserve. I would like to say to Milton and Anna: Regarding the Great Depression. You're right, we did it. We're very sorry. But thanks to you, we won't do it again." -Ben Bernanke
https://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2002/20021...
"Oh, I thought you were trying to build a canal. If it's jobs you want, then you should give these workers spoons, not shovels." - Milton Friedman
can we get a third, even pithier quote, please?
I've got you!
"“Hell hath no fury like a bureaucrat scorned." - Milton Friedman
You never got past Milton Friedman quote slinging in your libertarian debate club, huh.
We'd probably all be better off if we collectively decided to do the opposite of whatever Milton Friedman would have done.
I love that so many people will acknowledge this, and turn around and complain that the government isn’t involved in some sector enough. Bonus points that the typical targets are already places the government is messing with actual free markets.
Spoiler: It's not the same people acknowledging this who also want the government involved in more sectors.
The people who "acknowledge" (or believe this falsehood, more precisely) this are exactly the ones who want the government less involved in most things.
Related:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33758150 The Pentagon fails its fifth audit in a row (responsiblestatecraft.org) 4 years ago | 136 comments
The people always get the government they deserve.
The Pentagon is so unethical because its people from which it derives power are unethical.
That's why centralization of power is a problem. Pentagon get power from the federal level. Fedgovt makes money by taxing+quantativeEasing+debt (all have never been so high). And the duo-party system ensures nothing's going to change.
Murray Bookchin suggested a nice idea that allows bottom-up power structures that still allow complex modern societies with lots of specialization. This would decentralize power to some extend.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Municipalism
Federal government makes money by printing it.
Taxes provide a mandatory reason for the dollar to have a value, and a way to control already released supply.
[dead]
Do North Koreans deserve to be enslaved and malnourished for... the luck of being born above a certain latitude?
What a pathetic comic book worldview.
Bullshit that only a keyboard warrior would write.
[flagged]
Which irresponsible citizens relying on the safety net are you referring to?
> Were the majority of Americans similarly fiscally responsible, irresponsible politicians would not win elections.
Ridiculous claim. Budgeting failures are not the result of some people voting for an unbalanced budget and some people voting against a balanced budget. It's the result of people voting for the services they believe a government should provide (and not the ones it shouldn't), and also voting for the taxes they believe a government should be collect (and not the ones it shouldn't).
You can get a perpetually fucked up budget with a grand total of zero people attempting to create a fucked up budget.
But in this case, we did have people who attempted and succeeded at creating a fucked up budget. Simply repealing the "Big Beautiful Bill" would halve the deficit.
It's not the whole truth tho, it works in a feedback loop, people who argued for more support for the "irresponsible" citizens almost trained new generations to be that, because there was no punishment, and more, it might be just optimal action to take.
So the people raised inept government who raised more inept people that get baited by people promising handouts and pick the next generation of inept government.
As usual, those who fashion themselves as temporarily embarrassed billionaires think being poor is more unethical than the endless corruption and greed of the wealthy.
I have neighbors who are paycheck-to-paycheck because they drive brand new cars and put vacations on credit cards, they eat out constantly, have streaming services, video games, etc. They have lots of money, but they are irresponsible with it. This statement describes the cultural and political zeitgeist.
It's a moral good to care for the helpless. It's a moral ill for capable people to dissipate their wealth on entertainment only to later stress the safety net that others genuinely depended on.
> The people always get the government they deserve.
This is an idealistic statement dressed up as cynicism. You assume an ethical electorate would perfectly discover the politicians who are most capable of whipping votes. You also assume those same politicians' campaigning skills are 1:1 with their governing skills.
This is the same logic as PGP zealots who thought we'd all be safe and secure if only we could teach the crummy users cryptography. They optimized out UX (at the least!) from their worldview. You seem to have optimized out the very practice of politics.
I think that the idea may have been that politics is the mechanism by which people get the government that they deserve.
Which is a beyond-retarded idea.
Explain how an 1 year old child born above the 40th parallel "deserves" to live under North Korean rule while a 1 year old child born below it "deserves" to live under South Korean rule?
Explain how a woman born with black skin in antebellum United States deserves to be raped and beaten daily, while the very same government, in the exact same time and place gives a man born in white skin the "right" to conduct such rape and beating with impunity?
It's gobsmackingly dumb on top of being transparently and despicably evil.
Since it's first ever audit failure, it's a shame how cybersecurity failures have persisted.
At some point, you have to question whether it is deliberate.
To be clear, it's never passed - the intention has been for a while to get to a passing grade by FY2028
Somehow this comment is always at the bottom of the discussion! I wish more people would engage in serious research and discussion.
Yeah people always act like these failing audits are embarrassing, but they’re making solid progress
[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50525658
Did they ever figure out what happened to those several trillion dollars from back in the day?
And for the ninth time, there will be zero accountability.
What is even the point of an audit, if no one is going to crack the whip?
When we are conquered, which I don't desire, we will have deserved it.
I hope nobody here will be all po' faced when none of our expensive but corrupted systems actually perform, in a hot war. It'll be so embarrassing when that happens, but not even a little surprising. Bleh, what a world!
its not our fault
part of the American propaganda machine is sort of a "stop hitting yourself" psychological campaign
you don't deserve it, friend, you deserve better.
[dead]
[dead]
These audits should never pass. The burden of accounting for every dollar spent on defense would cost way more than the defense budget itself.
I can't find a video, but this reminds me of the news broadcast about how a toilet seat is $600 because of all the audit requirements. If they're paying $600 (and this was like in 1995 or something) for a toilet seat, then shouldn't they have offices full of people that know exactly how 1 trillion is spent? Isn't that the flex - that we're paying $600 for that so we know how much ALL of it costs?
Every once in a while (I last heard this in 1980) you hear of some scammer who sends invoices to companies for "service" just to see if it is paid. I'm told this is why I have to fill out an expense report - my company trusts me to buy a USB stick and it isn't worth auditing. What they don't trust is if they don't track everything somebody else won't start billing for USB sticks in the name of every employee - 500 USB sticks billed for [never delivered] is a nice income for a couple hours work by a scammer.
What you are asking for is a complete accounting of what happens to every bullet. Think about it for a second.
Edit: And bullets aren't cheap. High-calibre rounds can easily cost $2-5 per round, sometimes double for calibrated rounds.
No they're saying we supposedly already have that.
All we need is faster barcode scanning built into every gun. Ez pz.
So now there's a cost of printing a barcode onto every bullet, plus redesigning every gun/magazine to include/support a barcode reader....
And they have trillions of dollars to burn, fuck it why not.
[dead]
Does a passing grade require every dollar accounted for or do they apply a more reasonable measure?
It's usually a tolerance window such as "within +/- x% of the forecast". For a large budget such as a trillion dollars, to pass a small threshold like 3% is akin to threading a needle with an elephant.
We can track almost all of the trillion!
A+
we better increase those taxes.