There's a lot of focus on the US police force but once you've interacted with them often you get thrown into prisons where you deal with basically the same people, except you have even fewer avenues to fight back against abuses. And, unfortunately, a lot of people will fight tooth and nail to stop efforts to make things better, because by being there, obviously you "deserve" the situation :(
I think Zimbardo's Prison Experiment unearths a lot for understanding this phenomenon. When the very people who should be preventing this can be swayed to the other end both by system itself and human nature, fighting this thing becomes very hard.
My point is, possibly doubling down with the old ways we know as a society is not a solution here, we need to work, do research to find new ways to prevent this from happening, because it's not a technology problem, but a social problem, and has a different solution that we failed to discover so far.
Regardless of what they have done, preying on defenseless people, or even thinking about it is unthinkable from my perspective. I can't find words to express how I feel about it.
It may not generalize, sure, but it can act as a data point for a broader spectrum, and show one of the possible outcomes. I have seen similar dynamics play out in office dynamics as well, so I still believe it's a useful data point in research.
However, we know that power corrupts if the person who has the power has impunity or feels like they have impunity. Acting otherwise needs a strong ethical code and personal respect, which is not always abundant.
So, we have to find a better way to oversight things for a start, and also find other, novel ways. My point stands.
You misunderstand. The criticism of that experiment isn’t that it “does not generalize”. The criticism is that it was fake.
Actual proper evidence for your theory that people automatically become evil when given power over others is in fact rather hard to come by. Such people exist, yes, but plenty of counterexamples exist too.
But yeah “parole officer treats clients decently” doesn’t make headlines so it’s a pretty common bit of lore despite the lacking evidence.
I certainly agree that power can corrupt and that it'd be good to find better systems of oversight, but no, you should not consider Zimbardo's study a data point in research. The experiment was more a measure of how the "guards" would follow the roles assigned by Zimbardo, and should not be used to justify claims about human nature or the system the experiment was supposedly studying.
Your continued belief in the prison experiment is disheartening.
Not only is it sociology and thus very suspect, it has actually been shown false.
As someone else said it was theater.
One of the guards who allegedly abused the inmates said " we knew what they wanted to hear so we told them".
Much of what we have heard from sociologists and psychologists in the last 100 years has been garbage. And the more sensational the year, the more likely.
I have no strong opinions about the experiment in either way, and the discipline is not my strong suite. I have been clubbed to death with replies, so I'll rest alongside my case.
In case you think "who watches the watchmen" is a dry old aphorism, it's actually about why you can be raped by an authority in 2026. Surveillance will always be in tension with privacy. But privacy should defer to surveillance when anyone, and especially state actors, take people into custody. Bodycams ought to be mandatory when interacting with prisoners, with low tolerance for exceptions and edge cases.
I live near Dublin, CA and almost 99% of the residents of Tri-valley (Dublin, Pleasanton, San Ramon) or in the larger bay area are hardly aware of this. It is family friendly neighborhood. I am surprised that mainstream media or the local media did not bring the attention to this. I knew about this only through local wikipedia articles.
Somehow we have devolved into a nation that believes that people should obey laws, and police should not. We won't be a serious country until we can figure out that problem.
The american system of punitive incarceration is insane. This is so clearly not what justice looks like. Prison rape is understood to be so widespread in American prisons that it was a plot point in American History X and "don't drop the soap" is a hack joke that americans learn as children. And where are the incentives to fix these problems?
Prison privatization is big business in the U.S., and while cruel and unusual punishments are unconstitutional, as Milo Minderbinder reminds us, it's not against the law to make money, is it? No community can produce as much speech (as measured in dollars and cents given to political action committees) as the private prison industry, so the systemic degradation of human life will continue.
Sorry, some school districts have formal "summer reading" programs, where you pick from a list before the end of the year, then on return you'd do reports/presentations about the book. It was common to have a restricted list so that on return, you could break up into groups by book to do Socratic discussions.
My Catch-22 group was 3 people. I guess a lot of people saw the heft and opted for a lighter read.
i mean, it's so culturally impactful a book that even the phrase "catch-22" has entered the lexicon in the specific way that it's employed in the text, so maybe? But google exists and "minderbinder" isn't exactly a common name so I trust that anybody curious can expand their own horizons.
I didn't flag it but I assume that it might've gotten flagged by people who feel one or more of
- it doesn't fit with HN, it's "just news"
- it's a discussion we've seen thousands of times already on here
Basically, yes this is bad, but HN commenters never get a lot further than rants about the prison industrial complex, the failings of the US judicial system etc. Look through the comments here and tell me there's any you haven't read many times before.
Basically the point I'm trying to make is, don't mistake "I flagged this article" for "I support prison rape".
On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
Wouldn't this qualify as something that would likely be covered on TV news?
Yeah, but flagging an article makes it invisible on Hacker News; even if the discussion were the most hideous ever, there's a lot of value in people seeing the article itself.
I don't really thing this has been discussed a thousand times, by the way
Fair. I'm not trying to change your mind, I'm only trying to explain to you that people flagging this are not likely to be "pro rape" and much more likely to just be "pro nerdy content on HN".
If so, then people who would violate a position of trust to abuse someone like this, would have no reason to leave survivors.
If a person stands to lose everything, they'll do anything. You don't want to corner a wild animal. Leave the perpetrators an out, however small, and you'll save many victims' lives.
When calling for capital punishment it's important to remember that it's irreversible, and the same system that can unjustly put an innocent person in prison to be abused can also execute an innocent person.
There's a lot of focus on the US police force but once you've interacted with them often you get thrown into prisons where you deal with basically the same people, except you have even fewer avenues to fight back against abuses. And, unfortunately, a lot of people will fight tooth and nail to stop efforts to make things better, because by being there, obviously you "deserve" the situation :(
I think Zimbardo's Prison Experiment unearths a lot for understanding this phenomenon. When the very people who should be preventing this can be swayed to the other end both by system itself and human nature, fighting this thing becomes very hard.
My point is, possibly doubling down with the old ways we know as a society is not a solution here, we need to work, do research to find new ways to prevent this from happening, because it's not a technology problem, but a social problem, and has a different solution that we failed to discover so far.
Regardless of what they have done, preying on defenseless people, or even thinking about it is unthinkable from my perspective. I can't find words to express how I feel about it.
That experiment was a scam, a theater show.
It may not generalize, sure, but it can act as a data point for a broader spectrum, and show one of the possible outcomes. I have seen similar dynamics play out in office dynamics as well, so I still believe it's a useful data point in research.
However, we know that power corrupts if the person who has the power has impunity or feels like they have impunity. Acting otherwise needs a strong ethical code and personal respect, which is not always abundant.
So, we have to find a better way to oversight things for a start, and also find other, novel ways. My point stands.
You misunderstand. The criticism of that experiment isn’t that it “does not generalize”. The criticism is that it was fake.
Actual proper evidence for your theory that people automatically become evil when given power over others is in fact rather hard to come by. Such people exist, yes, but plenty of counterexamples exist too.
But yeah “parole officer treats clients decently” doesn’t make headlines so it’s a pretty common bit of lore despite the lacking evidence.
I certainly agree that power can corrupt and that it'd be good to find better systems of oversight, but no, you should not consider Zimbardo's study a data point in research. The experiment was more a measure of how the "guards" would follow the roles assigned by Zimbardo, and should not be used to justify claims about human nature or the system the experiment was supposedly studying.
I prefer Robert Caro's insight:
Power doesn't corrupt; it reveals.
To give some abstract force-like power, the ability to change people is superstitious at best and pardoning at worst.
But I'm a classical liberal who believes in personal responsibility and personal rights (which are mostly constraints on how I treat others)
nothing about the standford prison experiment was an experiment. there weren't even control groups.
Your continued belief in the prison experiment is disheartening.
Not only is it sociology and thus very suspect, it has actually been shown false.
As someone else said it was theater.
One of the guards who allegedly abused the inmates said " we knew what they wanted to hear so we told them".
Much of what we have heard from sociologists and psychologists in the last 100 years has been garbage. And the more sensational the year, the more likely.
Noted, thanks.
I have no strong opinions about the experiment in either way, and the discipline is not my strong suite. I have been clubbed to death with replies, so I'll rest alongside my case.
Thanks again.
In case you think "who watches the watchmen" is a dry old aphorism, it's actually about why you can be raped by an authority in 2026. Surveillance will always be in tension with privacy. But privacy should defer to surveillance when anyone, and especially state actors, take people into custody. Bodycams ought to be mandatory when interacting with prisoners, with low tolerance for exceptions and edge cases.
I live near Dublin, CA and almost 99% of the residents of Tri-valley (Dublin, Pleasanton, San Ramon) or in the larger bay area are hardly aware of this. It is family friendly neighborhood. I am surprised that mainstream media or the local media did not bring the attention to this. I knew about this only through local wikipedia articles.
Somehow we have devolved into a nation that believes that people should obey laws, and police should not. We won't be a serious country until we can figure out that problem.
[dead]
Based on how many people run red lights around me, I'm not sure that we the people believe we should obey laws.
I don't think they're doing it for civil disobedience reasons...
The american system of punitive incarceration is insane. This is so clearly not what justice looks like. Prison rape is understood to be so widespread in American prisons that it was a plot point in American History X and "don't drop the soap" is a hack joke that americans learn as children. And where are the incentives to fix these problems?
Prison privatization is big business in the U.S., and while cruel and unusual punishments are unconstitutional, as Milo Minderbinder reminds us, it's not against the law to make money, is it? No community can produce as much speech (as measured in dollars and cents given to political action committees) as the private prison industry, so the systemic degradation of human life will continue.
Private prisons are somewhat around 10% of prisons. The problem is much deeper.
I always wonder if prisons are really as depicted in movies where you basically can't avoid joining some gang.
From what you hear from former inmates American prisons are typically like that
Is catch-22 that well read that people will instantly get this reference?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catch-22#Rankings
I sure hope so. It was a summer reading option when I was in highschool ~15 years ago.
Aren't all books summer reading options? or did you have to do readings in the summer for school in the fall?
Sorry, some school districts have formal "summer reading" programs, where you pick from a list before the end of the year, then on return you'd do reports/presentations about the book. It was common to have a restricted list so that on return, you could break up into groups by book to do Socratic discussions.
My Catch-22 group was 3 people. I guess a lot of people saw the heft and opted for a lighter read.
heft? Isn't it like only 400 pages?
I've read that book in a sitting.
i mean, it's so culturally impactful a book that even the phrase "catch-22" has entered the lexicon in the specific way that it's employed in the text, so maybe? But google exists and "minderbinder" isn't exactly a common name so I trust that anybody curious can expand their own horizons.
most people don't realize that came from the book, and not that the book was named after the catch.
The violence in America is also quite literally insane.
At this point, though, the problem are intermeshed
Flagged, wtf...
It might be off-topic, but are you proud of having flagged something like this?
I didn't flag it but I assume that it might've gotten flagged by people who feel one or more of
Basically, yes this is bad, but HN commenters never get a lot further than rants about the prison industrial complex, the failings of the US judicial system etc. Look through the comments here and tell me there's any you haven't read many times before.Basically the point I'm trying to make is, don't mistake "I flagged this article" for "I support prison rape".
HN's posting guidance states:
On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
Wouldn't this qualify as something that would likely be covered on TV news?
Yeah, maybe.
But there's a ton of less important off-topic posts that one could flag
Yeah, but flagging an article makes it invisible on Hacker News; even if the discussion were the most hideous ever, there's a lot of value in people seeing the article itself.
I don't really thing this has been discussed a thousand times, by the way
Fair. I'm not trying to change your mind, I'm only trying to explain to you that people flagging this are not likely to be "pro rape" and much more likely to just be "pro nerdy content on HN".
Yeah, I did imagine that they were probably not pro rape
Despicable. These people need to be held to the highest standards and scrutiny.
Yeah we should put these people in prison, teach them a lesson.
There needs to be executions for anyone who violates a position of trust to abuse someone like this. It's despicable.
If so, then people who would violate a position of trust to abuse someone like this, would have no reason to leave survivors.
If a person stands to lose everything, they'll do anything. You don't want to corner a wild animal. Leave the perpetrators an out, however small, and you'll save many victims' lives.
Let's say that there need to be strong punishments...
When calling for capital punishment it's important to remember that it's irreversible, and the same system that can unjustly put an innocent person in prison to be abused can also execute an innocent person.
I think it's safe to say that the likelihood of executing innocent prison guards is very low.
Edit: what I mean is, it's a sort of categorical oxymoron.