Effects of a Nuclear Detonation in Low Earth Orbit

(arxiv.org)

74 points | by PaulHoule 5 hours ago ago

43 comments

  • beloch 3 hours ago ago

    This is one reason why weaponizing space is a bad idea. Even hardened orbital weapon platforms will be easy to destroy with imprecise detonations, as shown here, so space-based weapon capabilities will be short-lived in any meaningful conflict. However, their mere presence in orbit makes it far more likely that all other satellites will be destroyed, possibly even in minor conflicts. A strike against offensive military satellites (with all civilian satellites in the area as collateral damage) would likely be viewed as less of a taboo than a strike against cities.

    This is a bad path to go down.

    • rbanffy 3 hours ago ago

      > This is one reason why weaponizing space is a bad idea.

      It's a bad idea for anyone who depends on orbital infrastructure. For anyone who doesn't, has no orbital assets of relevance, has a small orbital launcher, and a compact nuke, it levels the playfield by ruining the party for everyone else.

      • PaulHoule 3 hours ago ago

        You don't even need the orbital launcher, you just need a suborbital launcher which can loft the bomb high enough without attaining orbital insertion speed. For instance, this anti-satellite weapon

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASM-135_ASAT

        wasn't bigger than other missiles you could fire from an F-15 but could take down a satellite.

        • echoangle an hour ago ago

          > wasn't bigger than other missiles you could fire from an F-15

          Technically not quite true for the version of the F-15 that was used.

          The ASM-135 was 1180 kg.

          The heaviest missile the base eagle is carrying is an AIM-120 with 160 kg or so.

          The strike eagle (which was developed from the eagle but wasn’t introduced until 1988, the same year the ASM-135 project ended) can carry heavier stuff like the AGM-130 with around 1300 kg though.

          • dopa42365 18 minutes ago ago

            Anything that can carry a 1180kg bomb load (not that impressive, any fighter from the last 50+ years can do much more than that) can also carry a 1180kg bomb with engine at one end (missile).

            As it turns out, advanced missiles that require the most smartest secretive military grade integration in only the bestest finest aircraft can be controlled just fine from a tablet in a garbage ancient analog MiG-29 if shit hits the fan.

    • taurath an hour ago ago

      > This is a bad path to go down.

      We're there - the people our system has put in charge are the people who care the least for humanity.

    • rexskimmer 2 hours ago ago

      Although LEO would be a widespread scorched-Earth style attack, a capable military would probably consider more strategic attacks targeting GPS satellites in MEO and communications satellites in GEO.

    • PowerElectronix 3 hours ago ago

      I guess the next best place for a weapons system in space is orbiting the moon. You can detect threats from earth with enough time to intercept and your presence there is don't threaten (indirectly, that is) the earth orbiying satellites.

      • nancyminusone 2 hours ago ago

        Intercept what now? Being at the moon will take 10s of hours to get to earth.

      • zzril 3 hours ago ago

        Makes me think of Stanislaw Lem, Peace on Earth.

  • orbital-decay 2 hours ago ago

    Actual detonation of a 300kt device at 290km, just to give some intuition of what it would cause on the ground. Disabling LEO satellites seems benign compared to that:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_Project_K_nuclear_tests

    >The electromagnetic pulse (EMP) fused all of the 570-kilometer monitored overhead telephone line with measured currents of 1500 to 3400 amperes during the 22 October 1962 test. [...] The EMP from the same test caused the destruction of the Karaganda power plant, and shut down 1,000 km (620 mi) of shallow-buried power cables between Astana (then called Aqmola) and Almaty (then called Alma-Ata).[3]

  • consumer451 4 hours ago ago

    This is even worse than I had imagined. I always thought that "the good news" is that no country with on-orbit assets would do this, as it would take out their satellites as well.

    Aside from the last thing you do before deciding on a nuclear assault on land targets, that's a fair assumption, isn't it?

    • OgsyedIE 4 hours ago ago

      Nuclear exchanges are, in theory, the last resort used when the low probability of the state partially surviving in bunkers is less small than the low probability of winning whatever current big-picture conflict is considered existential through conventional military means. It is not practical for states to differentiate each kind of exchange as not "all-or-nothing", they can only safely assume that they are all "all-or-nothing" and plan within that framework.

      This is the kind of topic that necessitates a visualization of what the stakes are. If you haven't seen Threads and have two hours free, go watch it.

      If you haven't got two hours but at least have half an hour, some Qwen agents comparing many YouTube transcripts to the film script have suggested to me that the summary-type video essay about Threads by the YouTube creator Pugsr is the summary-type video essay that most preserves the thematic content and chronological ordering of the events depicted in Threads, which I canaried by skimming the transcript now and endorse.

      The nuclear planners in states and relevant executive actors (at least in the majority of cases) grapple with sober acknowledgement of the kind of downsides depicted in Threads and which, if any, non-exchange outcomes are even worse off for themselves. There aren't many, but most people would falsely assume there aren't any at all.

      • fhdkweig 3 hours ago ago
      • PowerElectronix 3 hours ago ago

        As a fun fact, France has a first nuclear strike doctrine, this is, if you invade France, the first thing France will do is to nuke a small village in your country, as a warning to stop.

        • devmor 32 minutes ago ago

          That seems like a bad idea given how many countries have a “if someone launches a nuke, obliterate everything that’s looked at us funny” doctrine.

        • vkou an hour ago ago

          Will it do that over someone invading French Guiana?

      • phainopepla2 3 hours ago ago

        > If you haven't got two hours but at least have half an hour, some Qwen agents comparing many YouTube transcripts to the film script have suggested to me that the summary-type video essay about Threads by the YouTube creator Pugsr is the summary-type video essay that most preserves the thematic content and chronological ordering of the events depicted in Threads, which I canaried by skimming the transcript now and endorse.

        This sentence is giving me a headache.

        • order-matters 3 hours ago ago

          I, on the other hand, greatly appreciate the transparency given here. I think its a bit unnecessary if it was going to lead to a personal endorsement anyway though

        • DeluluDon 35 minutes ago ago

          Reading comprehension gives you headaches?

    • PowerElectronix 3 hours ago ago

      A nuke in space would most likely be viewed more as a conventional attack than a nuclear strike. You are just taking stuff off space, not causing a any direct deaths and not irradiating soil on any country.

      I would be surprised if a space nuclear strike isn't carried in the very first stages of a US-China armed conflict. There's just too much to be gained and very little to lose (nobody will retaliate with a nuke over a population to that)

      • pixl97 44 minutes ago ago

        Um... depends where the nuke goes off at and how high. In LEO over the US would put us in the dark age. So yea, it's a great way to get flash fried.

    • lumost 4 hours ago ago

      It depends a bit on whether you can hurt the opponent more than yourself in the strike. e.g. If you have a small satellite network or can survive without it, then why not pull the trigger? There are few methods of using Nuclear weapons which only target viable military/hardware targets.

  • gxd 3 hours ago ago

    Two days in a row with nuclear weapons posts! I don't remember the last time this happened...

    If you are interested in nuclear weapons like me, you may enjoy the free nuclear war simulator I released a couple of weeks ago:

    https://galantrixgames.itch.io/thousand-suns

    • Chamix 2 hours ago ago

      How does it compare to nuclear war simulator (https://store.steampowered.com/app/1603940)? I felt it was decent enough, but it got a little lazy in actually modeling what an actual realpolitik etc modern countervalue/force nuclear exchange would look like - it at least included https://github.com/davidteter/OPEN-RISOP as a loadable scenario but didn't actually model individual launch points (among other fidelity omissions) or attempt to model any NATO/US response.

      I get it is hard to augment (let alone recreate) the work of an actual strategic target planner, but I feel with LLM-schlepping the RISOP database could be somewhat reasonably updated/inferred for modern targets and then, more ambitiously, ported to China->US, and perhaps ultimately, full NATO v BRICS.

      • gxd an hour ago ago

        NWS has a more accurate fallout model, but it's not real-time like Thousand Suns. I can't speak of their general damage model because I couldn't find many details on that. Its scenario editor appears to be very flexible but, to be honest, I don't understand that product very well because of the UI.

        I made Thousand Suns for basically one thing: simulate the impact of an all out war with a civilian focus. I modeled many aspects of this problem in much detail (the page has more info, as well as the scenario creation guide). Optimal trajectories, MIRVs, interceptions, radar modeling... It's all there.

        This all out scenario isn't super plausible but I was interested in showing how destructive even a single submarine could be, and how alternative strategies make some difference but not that much!

        I made the configuration file LLM friendly so you could get external sources and create different scenarios. The data model has allowance for power plants, ports, etc but they are not exposed yet. That would make the RISOP more interesting for inclusion but right now the counterforce is focused on nuclear threats and countervalue solely on civilian deaths (using the RISOP would allow more economic destruction with fewer deaths in theory).

  • hammock 4 hours ago ago

    This is based on declassified info, of which the last real-world data we got is over 60 years old (Starfish Prime).

    What can be done today is certainly very different.

    • lukan 4 hours ago ago

      This is partly based on declassified info and laws of physics did not change so much.

      • hammock 4 hours ago ago

        No so much for the scenario studied. More so that it’s probable (and undisclosed) that there now exist nuclear weapons 30x smaller than known, with more controllable effects (EMP, neutron, blast radius, fusion ratio, etc)

        • rbanffy 3 hours ago ago

          I don't think this makes the result any better. While the destruction can be a little more tailored to a specific target, it still results in a massive infrastructure collapse.

          • ASalazarMX an hour ago ago

            I thought the holy grail of nuclear weapons during the Cold War was the neutron bomb, because they thought it would erase life while preserving most of the infrastructure. I don’t know if such weapon was achieved, or even if it’s possible, but declassified tech is usually decades behind.

        • LorenPechtel an hour ago ago

          Probably not.

          The problem is there is a minimum amount of material to make a bomb. To some extent you can substitute higher pressure for less material but mostly you make a very small bomb by a lower multiplication factor causing less of the material to fission. But that is inherently a random thing, the closer you get to not working the bigger the effect of a very minor difference early in the detonation. Thus, while you can make a very small bomb you can't predict it's yield.

  • Luke2642 3 hours ago ago

    This is actually kinda comforting. If we do need to go back to a simpler time for some technological apocalypse reason, it won't actually be too hard to organise. An ICBMs apogee is easily high enough, even 4500km is possible.

    • LorenPechtel an hour ago ago

      That would probably be an extinction event.

  • 0xWTF 2 hours ago ago

    So, I'm back to going full off grid, well water and HAM radio? Any pointers to good venison recipes?

  • fifici375wu 2 hours ago ago

    Which of the technology leaders of today would you believe would follow through on their scorched earth ultimatums and how many of them have bunkers

  • wolvoleo an hour ago ago

    Um yeah but this will affect everyone's sats equally so any party that does this will hurt themselves too.

    Edit: Except maybe North Korea which doesn't have any sats worth mentioning. But they exist at the convenience of China and Russia and that would become a lot less convenient in that case.

  • stymaar 3 hours ago ago

    Here's North Korea own Hormuz Straight.

  • ck2 3 hours ago ago

    PBS Space Time has an awesome explainer on the actual physics of EMP

    * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMjo_UY8vEM

  • ck2 3 hours ago ago

    other than the super-powers, North Korea could/would do it

    it's not just what's in LEO that would be taken out

    everything within line-of-sight like continental USA would have an EMP that would fry everything

    Starfish Prime took out Hawaii streetlights and that's before today's extremely dense chips

    Probably would take out a bunch of neocloud datacenters, all GPUs fried

    Just like the clean skies after 9/11 grounding, planet would be peaceful for a little while until wars break out

    • thrance 2 hours ago ago

      Why would North Korea do it? That would bring much undesired attention to their little insular kingdom. Their strategy has been to talk big while doing nothing for a while now, and it's worked pretty well in leaving them alone.

  • knotruby671 4 hours ago ago

    had to model EMP coupling for a sat com board once, the margins you need for hardening are brutal even for small yields

    • PaulHoule 4 hours ago ago

      What I understand is that EMP hardening is a bear. Like if there is the slightest crack or imperfection it will get through. Also the effects are said to be a bit unpredictable. Poorly protected hardware might survive if you get lucky, well protected hardware might fail if you get unlucky.

      Of course that's an entirely different phenomenon: X-Rays from an exoatmospheric explosion are absorbed in the atmosphere and cause a plasma explosion with widespread ionization and charge moving around... with a huge RF electromagnetic effect.

      The main effect that this paper is talking about is beta particles from decaying fission products get trapped in the magnetosphere and damage electronics for a sustained time.