Jensen has not demonstrated any real remorse or taking steps towards regaining the trust of the Nvidia board. What is fact is that he created a structural single point of failure in the management structure and then behaved in a way that put that structure at high risk, and ultimately caused it to fail. He may be an amazing businessman when it comes to sales and technical vision, but the personal liberties he took and behavior that enabled it does not just go away because he feels sorry.
Edit: if I think about it more, what he probably feels sorry about is the fact that he got caught.
The board has one job - maximizing shareholder value. I am ~100% sure that Jensen is the way to do that, and enforcing morality as per HN user Makeitmakesense is not.
You're making the right observation but drawing the wrong conclusion. The board obviously would not completely dismiss Jensen, the single biggest rainmaker out there today, if all this amounted to was infidelity, and probably not even if he was "just" a victim of a honeypot.
The fact that they are so unequivocally dismissing the possibility of his return, despite the obvious immediate financial risk to themselves, as well as pressure both internal and external to bring him back, ought to be a big indicator that there is, in fact, a lot of there there, vis-a-vis the Chinese smuggling. Possibly even Jensen's active role in it, and possibly concern that it's the thread that will be pulled to unravel the company's whole circular financing scheme.
And just because Milton Friedman said that in the 70s and everyone has repeated it a million times, that doesn’t make the “only maximize shareholder value” thing a truism.
Lawyer here. A subsequent opinion from a court (or a superior court) that supersedes a previous opinion makes it no longer valid law. That’s how U.S. law works.
Jensen gave speculators, bears and competitors exactly what they wanted, an Nvidia entangled in scandal that will impact share value even if he stayed. A CEO you have to police and second guess is not ideal for shareholders. Your premise assumes that Jensen will resolve his behaviors 100% and never be a risk again. Thats not how risk management works.
Maybe but as they say, their business isn't really in peril. They're not going to lose customers over it. Their product is the top tier resource everyone wants to feed their bid in the AI bubble.
Whoever is at the top job isn't going to stop them from buying. They're in a sellers market if there ever was one.
They might get lobbied into letting him come back but it's not a risk to their business.
Additionally, congress is about to be giving them metaphorical cavity searches for the next several years and they might hurt less if he is gone during that period.
I think we forget how tenacious Satya was during that time convincing the board to reinstate Sam. He openly offered positions to all employees at Microsoft.
Jensen has not demonstrated any real remorse or taking steps towards regaining the trust of the Nvidia board. What is fact is that he created a structural single point of failure in the management structure and then behaved in a way that put that structure at high risk, and ultimately caused it to fail. He may be an amazing businessman when it comes to sales and technical vision, but the personal liberties he took and behavior that enabled it does not just go away because he feels sorry.
Edit: if I think about it more, what he probably feels sorry about is the fact that he got caught.
The board has one job - maximizing shareholder value. I am ~100% sure that Jensen is the way to do that, and enforcing morality as per HN user Makeitmakesense is not.
You're making the right observation but drawing the wrong conclusion. The board obviously would not completely dismiss Jensen, the single biggest rainmaker out there today, if all this amounted to was infidelity, and probably not even if he was "just" a victim of a honeypot.
The fact that they are so unequivocally dismissing the possibility of his return, despite the obvious immediate financial risk to themselves, as well as pressure both internal and external to bring him back, ought to be a big indicator that there is, in fact, a lot of there there, vis-a-vis the Chinese smuggling. Possibly even Jensen's active role in it, and possibly concern that it's the thread that will be pulled to unravel the company's whole circular financing scheme.
And protect the company. Jensen is a risk.
And just because Milton Friedman said that in the 70s and everyone has repeated it a million times, that doesn’t make the “only maximize shareholder value” thing a truism.
I was referring to the United States Supreme Court case where they very clearly explained it actually. Dodge v. Ford Motor Co. from 1919
You should update your knowledge base. It's currently premised on myths. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1013744
I read it. It says the case was bad. Cool. That is an opinion. The case remains citable and has not been overruled.
Lawyer here. A subsequent opinion from a court (or a superior court) that supersedes a previous opinion makes it no longer valid law. That’s how U.S. law works.
You should look up the meaning of "dead letter law". Also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shlensky_v._Wrigley
commenting as a reminder to check back later and see if na is legally beholden to shareholder primacy
There is no such legal requirement. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50540884
In 2016 the Supreme Court said there is no requirement for corporations to pursue profit at the expense of everything else. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39643452
Jensen gave speculators, bears and competitors exactly what they wanted, an Nvidia entangled in scandal that will impact share value even if he stayed. A CEO you have to police and second guess is not ideal for shareholders. Your premise assumes that Jensen will resolve his behaviors 100% and never be a risk again. Thats not how risk management works.
Acting against shareholders interest
But they’ll change their minds later.
Maybe but as they say, their business isn't really in peril. They're not going to lose customers over it. Their product is the top tier resource everyone wants to feed their bid in the AI bubble.
Whoever is at the top job isn't going to stop them from buying. They're in a sellers market if there ever was one.
They might get lobbied into letting him come back but it's not a risk to their business.
Additionally, congress is about to be giving them metaphorical cavity searches for the next several years and they might hurt less if he is gone during that period.
is there a publicly available petition i and other shareholders can sign to reinstate him? or anything else we can do to help bring him back?
Shame that the Open AI board didn't have the same guts as the nvidia board does
I think we forget how tenacious Satya was during that time convincing the board to reinstate Sam. He openly offered positions to all employees at Microsoft.