Engineering Vitals in the Age of AI

(octopus.com)

10 points | by paulstovell 9 hours ago ago

5 comments

  • motahir_alam 7 hours ago ago

    [flagged]

  • undefined 7 hours ago ago
    [deleted]
  • devmor 7 hours ago ago

    One problem I have with some of these measurements of value is that there's little talk of alternative tools.

    I see a value add from AI, but I also believe that value could have already been there - and potentially much more reliably and less expensive, if the right people cared to implement it before this point.

    My own observation is that a lot of engineering orgs have been neglectful in good practices and/or tooling, and AI being the hot new thing is filling in where those things were missing. Kind of like measuring the productivity of a starving laborer vs a laborer on cocaine and never thinking to measure what happens if you give him 3 meals a day.

    I would like to see more of these posts discussing exactly what the value they are seeing from AI is, and evaluating if AI is even the correct tool for that value-add.

    • moltar 5 hours ago ago

      What do you think engineers are generally starved from?

      • devmor 4 hours ago ago

        The two biggest factors are documentation and tooling, in my experience. There’s never enough time, no buy-in, etc.

        So far, the greatest actual time savings I’ve seen from AI usage has been using it as a search engine to connect data silos and parse through functions, and using it to solve problems code coverage and analysis tools could solve (in fact, the agents often use these tools themselves).

        Of course this is all going to be different per organization, hence my desire to see the benefits that AI has brought actually broken down and examined.