Unreal. It's an entire world being simulated. As someone that started with ye olde GTA as a kid, couldn't imagine seeing this in my lifetime, let alone this soon, and let alone on a console.
This opinion (not yours, it's shared with the majority) always strikes me as odd. This isn't directed at you, just commenting here as a relevant spot in the threads.
It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware. 30 FPS is perfectly servicable. Sort of like the Louis C.K. bit about people forgetting how magical flying really is.
> It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware.
Likewise, I find this take baffling. Yes it is impressive what they managed to do, but this is first and foremost a video game, not a tech demo. Frame rate is hugely important to how it feels as a video game.
It feels to me like they optimised the game for marketing, not for gameplay. Pretty screenshots sell games, and you don't experience how the game feels to play until they already have your money.
An even more cynical take is that they knew this and it was part of the reason to not sell the game on disc: you can't resell a digital copy. This prevents the 2nd hand market from being flooded with copies from people who are disappointed with the frame rates after the honeymoon period over the pretty graphics passes.
For anyone who bought the original No Man’s Sky, would know how unplayable and buggy it was at first (but it was indie studio). Same with Cyberpunk which was from a well-funded studio. Both were eventually able to patch things up and went on to become major hits.
I believe a similar situation might be in order for GTA VI. Already plagued by so many delays, someone probably foot their foot down and said we’re going to ship the best we can on so and so date and follow it up with patches.
I bought No Man's Sky on day one, and it was perfectly playable for me. But I disliked it because of the lies they told about it being multi-player, the extreme repetitiveness, and especially the nightmare scenario in which KarenBots are everywhere on every planet in every galaxy like a law of nature.
I'd rather a game that struggles to get to 30fps now and will be 60fps next console generation and have legs on PC to last for years (a-la crysis) than something with compromises needed to get to 60fps now and no way to scale further.
GTA comes out every decade or so, it's not like next year there will be GTA7. TBH rather than framerate I wish it focused on being less one-dimensional on playing the crime side of things, a true "sim everything" game should have allowed the two leads to become "reformed" and play on the cop side of things, if the user chose.
I'm interested if GTA6 can be played a bit more "lawfully" than GTA5, we'll see when more opinions come in. All the effort spent on racing hopefully points in that direction, would be nice if there was taxi/ambulance gameplay again as well as stunts/jumps and so on.
It could be, if it was consistent, but the parent comment was just saying how any interaction drops the rate to 20 (and likely below even that). The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second, so the idea that the "greatest game ever" is an interactive slideshow whenever game play gets intense is laughable.
>they can do it with existing console hardware
I don't think they can, and they should have lowered fidelity so people could actually play the game.
> The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second
I'm sure this means something, but I can certainly tell the difference between 60 and 100fps, or LEDs without capacitors. I'm by no means an aberration, and we are talking about the context of games on a screen.
I think they're trying to say that below 17 frames per second, you start to perceive the individual frames, and it no longer feels like a continuous animation.
But yeah, there's a huge difference between 30 and 60 frames per second in a video game.
You could do an A/B comparison of Breath of the Wild, which was locked at 30 frames per second, and the same game running on an emulator with a patch to bring it up to 60 frames per second, and anyone with reasonable visual acuity would instantly be able to tell the difference.
"the parent comment was just saying how any interaction drops the rate to 20 (and likely below even that)"
Digital Foundry says the PS5 Pro is "near flawless 30 FPS" and he played for 50 hours without seeing a single dip, but he was able to make it drop to 24 by trying to cause as much chaos as possible. The standard PS5 gets small dips to 26-28 doing normal things like driving, again falling to 24 during chaos. XBox Series X is similar to standard PS5 while XBox Series S seems a little worse dipping to 19 during chaos.
> The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second
What is noticeable depends on size of screen and how fast things are moving across the screen. Anything up to about 10,000 FPS can be noticeable for very fast movement.
I just watched a YouTube video about how a game like Red Dead Redemption 2 can never be made again because of the astounding, uneconomical level of detail. But it seems another one is being released tomorrow. I think the claim is backwards, and that this kind of detail will become table stakes for RPGs as leveraging AI becomes ubiquitous. And then some.
Didn't bother reading, but how many hours can they have played it for?
GTA3 is one of the few games I finished. I tried playing the subsequent ones, they were pretty much the same formula with better grapgics so I
couldn't be bothered with them. I'll not play this one as in my 40s I really don't have time.
So what do you do these days? I also do not play computer games anymore. However if I really want to play, I think I could find some time for playing. But you know what? I prefer watching YouTube movie while somebody was playing (without commentary), joined few hours of gameplay that looks like a real movie.
I've done it quite a lot, but that depends from game to game. For some it's just that I'm way too bad/not really interested in getting good at the game to really enjoy it, but watching someone playing can be fun (like watching a challenge run in Dark Souls or Elden Ring). For some other games, it's that the video has cut most of the tedious parts to keep the highlights, condensing part of the play experience. For some it's just that the commentary is insightful or funny. I haven't done that much, but watching a livestream with the interaction between the audience and the streamer can be fun.
Yeah and I would say it's less silly than watching sports, because most NFL fans never touch a football. Where most video game fans play the game they watch, in large part to learn how to play better.
I never did either, then my time became much more limited and now to get at least a glimpse into a game, I do not find the time fully diving into, I sometimes enjoy it nowdays.
Honestly I don't understand it either. Especially non-computer games, such as football/soccer — it's the stupidest thing ever.
Computer games though, especially professional matches or speedruns (and actual physical-world motor sports racing onboards, all in that same bucket) sometimes click with me, not sure why. It's monotonous but can be engaging in a "vibes" way.
But one of my biggest issues with the GTA games is the lack of any sort of challenge whatsoever. At each version two things change:
1. the game gets easier. I think I died twice (once due to a bug) in the whole main campaign of GTA 5
2. they keep shoving more and more story and dialogue and interruptions in the game. Honestly I hate it, RDR 2's first 4 hours felt like being a spectator of a film, and I hate it. If I'm interested in a story I read a book or play games with that specific focus.
I had similar feelings about the uncharted series, 1 & 2 I enjoyed, 3 I just stopped playing after a few hours, as I found myself spending more time making cups of tea while an unskipable cut scene plays, than actually playing the game itself.
Every version of Fifa (or whatever it's called now) has more and more cutscenes shoved in, and even though they're incredibly amateur and low res, they some how manage to make the fans go like a jet turbine. Cutscenes need to die.
On point 2, the article says this one is a bit different. Compared to RDR2 and GTA5, "there are plenty of slow, deliberate moments, but the game is often content to just be a game."
My problem with GTA franchise is that it doesn't try to say anything. Technically it is incredibly impressive, may be the last technically impressive game where details were made by human crafting. Stellar, even considering the 10 year dev time and $1bn+ budget.
But on the surface, the world building basically became Fast & Furious. The "witty" takes on society were reduced to "Fruit" phones and mocking recreation of daytime news. Nothing unsafe. Not wanting preachy storylines, just that there should be something to _experience_, something serious besides "oh this is realistic, let's try to land that jumbo on the beach". Maybe GTA4 was the last entry that had great overtones about migrant life.
I mean, it is a big sandbox and you can roleplay whatever, but the already thin GTA5 was diluted down to water with stupid mictrotransactions, Shark Cards, and the dumbest multiplayer experience there is, and they made a bank on that. I don't expect this to be different, and it just makes the taste sour, despite the otherwise brilliant execution.
>Maybe GTA4 was the last entry that had great overtones about migrant life.
I agree, but you could also argue that GTA4 was the only entry that took a swing at having a serious, overarching narrative theme. Most of which I still believe to be the influence of the Sopranos (it was at the height of its cultural influence and actively airing as GTA4 was being developed). What was San Andreas trying to say? Was Vice City really that much more than a playable Scarface homage? GTA3's protagonist didn't even speak. Love those games, btw. But in a sense, the franchise just returned to its (much more profitable) roots.
The bar for what is "unsafe" has been raised in general. Is even South Park considered that 'edgy' anymore? The last I heard about them was about mocking Trump which is hardly anything special.
It is true, GTA became from a sharp parody of American society to basically a part of it.
We should be thankful at this stage that all characters are not non binary or something.
Do you remember Vice City commercials ? They mocked everything that was wrong about the US. Now we have mainstream coachella celebrities making appearances in GTA.
"It all very much feels like RDR 2 as well. Similar to Arthur, Jason and Lucia feel a little heavier than the GTA 5 trio in a pleasing way that grounds them more in the world and gives them a more convincing sensation of inertia as they otherwise seamlessly transition from one action to another."
What a relief. The GTA5 characters were way too cartoonish for me, which hurt the immersion compared to RDR2.
We need a term for hype echo chambers where influencers all have FOMO for every slow drip detail released over the past 2 years and all try to out hype each other for clicks resulting in a recursively amplifying hype loop. Once the game is actually released and the hype bubble is over, watch these people never mention it again.
This is the reason why the Steam Machine will not sell.
As predicted, [0] the consumer will go as far as to buying a console (either Xbox or a PS5) to play GTA 6 as it is not available on PC and does not run on Linux.
Perhaps more relevant to hackernews crowd: "GTA6 Digital Foundry's Tech Review" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsBU0bcpONA
Unreal. It's an entire world being simulated. As someone that started with ye olde GTA as a kid, couldn't imagine seeing this in my lifetime, let alone this soon, and let alone on a console.
frame drops to low 20's when anything interesting happens on screen. OUCH.
Even on PS5 Pro it's not entirely stable but the situation seems much worse on base PS5 which is what the vast majority of players will be using.
Targeting a game at 30fps in 2026 is certainly a choice, but it not even being a locked 30 is hugely disappointing.
This opinion (not yours, it's shared with the majority) always strikes me as odd. This isn't directed at you, just commenting here as a relevant spot in the threads.
It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware. 30 FPS is perfectly servicable. Sort of like the Louis C.K. bit about people forgetting how magical flying really is.
> It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware.
Likewise, I find this take baffling. Yes it is impressive what they managed to do, but this is first and foremost a video game, not a tech demo. Frame rate is hugely important to how it feels as a video game.
It feels to me like they optimised the game for marketing, not for gameplay. Pretty screenshots sell games, and you don't experience how the game feels to play until they already have your money.
An even more cynical take is that they knew this and it was part of the reason to not sell the game on disc: you can't resell a digital copy. This prevents the 2nd hand market from being flooded with copies from people who are disappointed with the frame rates after the honeymoon period over the pretty graphics passes.
For anyone who bought the original No Man’s Sky, would know how unplayable and buggy it was at first (but it was indie studio). Same with Cyberpunk which was from a well-funded studio. Both were eventually able to patch things up and went on to become major hits.
I believe a similar situation might be in order for GTA VI. Already plagued by so many delays, someone probably foot their foot down and said we’re going to ship the best we can on so and so date and follow it up with patches.
That’s my honest opinion.
I bought No Man's Sky on day one, and it was perfectly playable for me. But I disliked it because of the lies they told about it being multi-player, the extreme repetitiveness, and especially the nightmare scenario in which KarenBots are everywhere on every planet in every galaxy like a law of nature.
I'd rather a game that struggles to get to 30fps now and will be 60fps next console generation and have legs on PC to last for years (a-la crysis) than something with compromises needed to get to 60fps now and no way to scale further.
GTA comes out every decade or so, it's not like next year there will be GTA7. TBH rather than framerate I wish it focused on being less one-dimensional on playing the crime side of things, a true "sim everything" game should have allowed the two leads to become "reformed" and play on the cop side of things, if the user chose.
I'm interested if GTA6 can be played a bit more "lawfully" than GTA5, we'll see when more opinions come in. All the effort spent on racing hopefully points in that direction, would be nice if there was taxi/ambulance gameplay again as well as stunts/jumps and so on.
[dead]
>30 FPS is perfectly servicable.
It could be, if it was consistent, but the parent comment was just saying how any interaction drops the rate to 20 (and likely below even that). The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second, so the idea that the "greatest game ever" is an interactive slideshow whenever game play gets intense is laughable.
>they can do it with existing console hardware
I don't think they can, and they should have lowered fidelity so people could actually play the game.
(edited for formatting)
> The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second
I'm sure this means something, but I can certainly tell the difference between 60 and 100fps, or LEDs without capacitors. I'm by no means an aberration, and we are talking about the context of games on a screen.
I think they're trying to say that below 17 frames per second, you start to perceive the individual frames, and it no longer feels like a continuous animation.
But yeah, there's a huge difference between 30 and 60 frames per second in a video game.
You could do an A/B comparison of Breath of the Wild, which was locked at 30 frames per second, and the same game running on an emulator with a patch to bring it up to 60 frames per second, and anyone with reasonable visual acuity would instantly be able to tell the difference.
"the parent comment was just saying how any interaction drops the rate to 20 (and likely below even that)"
Digital Foundry says the PS5 Pro is "near flawless 30 FPS" and he played for 50 hours without seeing a single dip, but he was able to make it drop to 24 by trying to cause as much chaos as possible. The standard PS5 gets small dips to 26-28 doing normal things like driving, again falling to 24 during chaos. XBox Series X is similar to standard PS5 while XBox Series S seems a little worse dipping to 19 during chaos.
https://youtu.be/qsBU0bcpONA?t=2839
> The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second
What is noticeable depends on size of screen and how fast things are moving across the screen. Anything up to about 10,000 FPS can be noticeable for very fast movement.
Relying on early game reviews from major media sites for hyped up AAA games is always a bad idea.
This game is going to sell regardless of reviews.
It's already pre-sold over 14 million, and will likely go to sell at least 200 million over the course of its life.
Billions within the first week, apparently. With $1.5B in pre-orders
https://www.nytimes.com/video/arts/100000011289557/grand-the...
nobody is "relying" on anything. The people who are going to buy it are going to buy it regardless.
[dead]
https://wallhop.io/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2...
I just watched a YouTube video about how a game like Red Dead Redemption 2 can never be made again because of the astounding, uneconomical level of detail. But it seems another one is being released tomorrow. I think the claim is backwards, and that this kind of detail will become table stakes for RPGs as leveraging AI becomes ubiquitous. And then some.
Also, not that everyone cares, but GTA 6 might be the last game of this scale created mostly without AI.
This is an advert.
Didn't bother reading, but how many hours can they have played it for?
GTA3 is one of the few games I finished. I tried playing the subsequent ones, they were pretty much the same formula with better grapgics so I couldn't be bothered with them. I'll not play this one as in my 40s I really don't have time.
Article says he played for 45 hours
So what do you do these days? I also do not play computer games anymore. However if I really want to play, I think I could find some time for playing. But you know what? I prefer watching YouTube movie while somebody was playing (without commentary), joined few hours of gameplay that looks like a real movie.
I never understood people who watch other people playing games.
I've done it quite a lot, but that depends from game to game. For some it's just that I'm way too bad/not really interested in getting good at the game to really enjoy it, but watching someone playing can be fun (like watching a challenge run in Dark Souls or Elden Ring). For some other games, it's that the video has cut most of the tedious parts to keep the highlights, condensing part of the play experience. For some it's just that the commentary is insightful or funny. I haven't done that much, but watching a livestream with the interaction between the audience and the streamer can be fun.
And educational, given the right streamer (i.e., someone who both plays a game well and is good at explaining how they're playing well).
It's a natural evolution of watching sports.
Yeah and I would say it's less silly than watching sports, because most NFL fans never touch a football. Where most video game fans play the game they watch, in large part to learn how to play better.
I never did either, then my time became much more limited and now to get at least a glimpse into a game, I do not find the time fully diving into, I sometimes enjoy it nowdays.
Is that something you want to change?
Honestly I don't understand it either. Especially non-computer games, such as football/soccer — it's the stupidest thing ever.
Computer games though, especially professional matches or speedruns (and actual physical-world motor sports racing onboards, all in that same bucket) sometimes click with me, not sure why. It's monotonous but can be engaging in a "vibes" way.
> but how many hours can they have played it for?
I heard on Twitter that reviewers had access to preview copies like 2 weeks ago.
Really? San Andreas is probably the pinnacle of the PS2 engine games. From the controls to the amount of things you can do, it’s just better than 3.
Hell, from a gameplay perspective, San Andreas is probably my favorite. It’s the only one I’ve played through multiple times
Yeah, he either did not play San Andreas (which was just 1 release over after VC) or does not really remember.
Sometimes the same formula is okay.
But one of my biggest issues with the GTA games is the lack of any sort of challenge whatsoever. At each version two things change:
1. the game gets easier. I think I died twice (once due to a bug) in the whole main campaign of GTA 5
2. they keep shoving more and more story and dialogue and interruptions in the game. Honestly I hate it, RDR 2's first 4 hours felt like being a spectator of a film, and I hate it. If I'm interested in a story I read a book or play games with that specific focus.
Yeah, I've never found either the stories or the gameplay in GTA games engaging.
I'm okay with extensive story sequences mixed with gameplay, so long as the stories are interesting and the gameplay is fun.
For example, I'm a big fan of the Yakuza series, both the beat-em-ups and the turn-based RPGs.
I had similar feelings about the uncharted series, 1 & 2 I enjoyed, 3 I just stopped playing after a few hours, as I found myself spending more time making cups of tea while an unskipable cut scene plays, than actually playing the game itself.
Every version of Fifa (or whatever it's called now) has more and more cutscenes shoved in, and even though they're incredibly amateur and low res, they some how manage to make the fans go like a jet turbine. Cutscenes need to die.
On point 2, the article says this one is a bit different. Compared to RDR2 and GTA5, "there are plenty of slow, deliberate moments, but the game is often content to just be a game."
The main character not speaking in GTA 3 was a feature, much like Gordon freeman in half life.
I had similar issues with metal gear solid 2. I gave up due to cut scenes.
My problem with GTA franchise is that it doesn't try to say anything. Technically it is incredibly impressive, may be the last technically impressive game where details were made by human crafting. Stellar, even considering the 10 year dev time and $1bn+ budget.
But on the surface, the world building basically became Fast & Furious. The "witty" takes on society were reduced to "Fruit" phones and mocking recreation of daytime news. Nothing unsafe. Not wanting preachy storylines, just that there should be something to _experience_, something serious besides "oh this is realistic, let's try to land that jumbo on the beach". Maybe GTA4 was the last entry that had great overtones about migrant life.
I mean, it is a big sandbox and you can roleplay whatever, but the already thin GTA5 was diluted down to water with stupid mictrotransactions, Shark Cards, and the dumbest multiplayer experience there is, and they made a bank on that. I don't expect this to be different, and it just makes the taste sour, despite the otherwise brilliant execution.
>Maybe GTA4 was the last entry that had great overtones about migrant life.
I agree, but you could also argue that GTA4 was the only entry that took a swing at having a serious, overarching narrative theme. Most of which I still believe to be the influence of the Sopranos (it was at the height of its cultural influence and actively airing as GTA4 was being developed). What was San Andreas trying to say? Was Vice City really that much more than a playable Scarface homage? GTA3's protagonist didn't even speak. Love those games, btw. But in a sense, the franchise just returned to its (much more profitable) roots.
Reminds me of the fourth Matrix movie and Baudrillard.
The bar for what is "unsafe" has been raised in general. Is even South Park considered that 'edgy' anymore? The last I heard about them was about mocking Trump which is hardly anything special.
It is true, GTA became from a sharp parody of American society to basically a part of it.
We should be thankful at this stage that all characters are not non binary or something.
Do you remember Vice City commercials ? They mocked everything that was wrong about the US. Now we have mainstream coachella celebrities making appearances in GTA.
Wish I could play it but getting a PS5 just for one game… ehh
Also gets you Marvel’s Spider-Man 2. It has since been ported to PC but I find the PC version somewhat challenging to run well.
Saros and ghost of yotei are really great games that are only on ps5 as well
also maybe relevant: https://www.ign.com/articles/grand-theft-auto-vi-review
"It all very much feels like RDR 2 as well. Similar to Arthur, Jason and Lucia feel a little heavier than the GTA 5 trio in a pleasing way that grounds them more in the world and gives them a more convincing sensation of inertia as they otherwise seamlessly transition from one action to another."
What a relief. The GTA5 characters were way too cartoonish for me, which hurt the immersion compared to RDR2.
I feel almost forced to buy a PS5 so I can play this... since there is zero chance I can afford a new gaming rig with the current hardware prices.
The bad news is that PS5s are about as expensive as entry gaming rigs. Used PS5 Pros are going for ~$1400 these days
The game isn’t out on PC yet anyway
Can't believe I read this as GPT 6
Bloomberg is maybe one of the last publications I would trust on a video game review.
I'd say that Jason Schreier is the relevant brand here, rather than Bloomberg.
Probably the intention of the OP is to show that even such publications are in the GTA craziness
It got 99 on Metacritic though, which is extremely high.
Nobody is going to give a bad pre-release review to such a big company or they'll lose a lot of views from being blacklisted
Im sure young hunans can learn a lot in GTA6
the age of hunans is over, now is the age of orcs!
Bloomberg reviews games now?
Very glad I held my TTWO
We need a term for hype echo chambers where influencers all have FOMO for every slow drip detail released over the past 2 years and all try to out hype each other for clicks resulting in a recursively amplifying hype loop. Once the game is actually released and the hype bubble is over, watch these people never mention it again.
Hot take: the last good gta was gta 2. Top down ftw!
try chinatown wars. It's top down and amazing. Quite possibly the most fun mobile game I've ever played. Can emulate the psp version quite easily
paywalled
This is the reason why the Steam Machine will not sell.
As predicted, [0] the consumer will go as far as to buying a console (either Xbox or a PS5) to play GTA 6 as it is not available on PC and does not run on Linux.
To Downvoters: That is the truth.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48890623
Won't run on linux? Based on what. GTA 5 runs fine on linux for single player.
[flagged]
[dead]