My 5 year old daughter saw a guy in a suit walking through our neighborhood recently and asked “why is he dressed like a mayor?” Not common to see people in non-casual clothes these days.
I wasn't allowed to wear jeans to work in the late 90s. Never wore a suit, but I definitely had a pile of khakis. On the other hand, I had an office with a door that I could close.
In 2015 my boss hated shorts. Apparently he didn't want to see our hairy man legs. I'm sure he was mostly kidding. We respected that boundary by only wearing shorts while he was away.
Really didn't bother me since navy blue khakis and a golf shirt are my standard.
In a teacher orientation in rural school, the principle told us that they would prefer that teachers don't wear jeans, but so many of us don't have anything else that they don't make an issue out of it. He could have required that we buy suitable clothes, but didn't care enough.
It's absurd that it doesn't exist anymore especially when you consider the money being dropped on AI just to make developers more productive. Now it matters?
Worst seating I ever had was a corner desk half the company had to walk past to get to the kitchen and alongside a table tennis table for the yapping sales staff to enjoy between phone calls.
The less performative posturing, the better. The motivation behind formal dress/"corporate uniforms" is the same core motivation behind anti-WFH mindsets that think people need to have a manager looking over their shoulder at an office to get good work done.
I've told this story before, but once upon a time, I was the interviewer at an inbound call centre, interviewing a guy for a position on the phones. He turned up in a sleeveless T-shirt and torn jeans.
I asked him if he thought that he had come to the interview dressed professionally and he complained to HR after the interview that I was 'stifling his individuality'.
He answered angrily that yes he was and anyway it didn't matter because the job was just on the phones and customers would never see him and so on. He reacted so negatively to the question that I just moved on, but if he'd actually taken a few minutes to say 'no, I came dressed in what I would normally wear for a day on the job', I would have told him that that's perfectly fine, but sometimes, we have client visits and so on, and it's important that he understands the difference, and accepts that when there's a reason, we do need at least business casual dress, even for folks who spend all day answering the phone.
In the end, I rejected him for other reasons completely unrelated to how he was dressed, but I'm sure if he ever thinks back to that day, he remembers me unkindly.
The question wasn't loaded. There was no presupposition based on the structure of the question. A loaded question would be more like: "When did you decide to stop dressing professionally?"
The question definitely exposed a poor choice. But it was not loaded.
Ever watch the AMC TV series Madmen. Men used to wear dinner jackets to eat dinner, and never left home without some kind of hat. Women wore dresses everywhere. When I started working in a office 20+ years ago everyone wore business attire, ties were common. After some time you could only wear jeans and a nice shirt on Friday. More time passes, people were coming to work in hocky jerseys, jeans and sandals. Now after working from home for over 10 years my "work" outfits are probably out of date fashion wise. Everything changes. The best part was listening to all the boomers complain and realizing there was nothing they could do about it. "I can't wait to retire" was usually their next sentence.
If you spend a bit you can get comfortable clothes. I didn't wear jeans for 20 years because as a child my parents made me wear inflexible heavy-weight denim and I loathed it; as it turns out Japanese selvedge 4-way stretch denim is cool and comfortable. The same applies to dress clothes. After I found a few brands that fit better than department store garbage I actually started enjoying dressing up.
And everyday on the news we see too many of them proudly, bravely acting like toddlers throwing a tantrum. Boomers mostly learned early that this doesn't work. Many millennials learned that it does work, which is the boomers' fault.
With all due respect, old folks don't get a choice who is going to inherit the current operating system of society. An opinion without power or authority is of little value. Does it matter what Boomers think? Does it matter if younger cohorts care? Important questions imho. Provide an attempt at a solid hand off, or cry about it from the retirement home, at scale is my take.
Recent example was Brexit that was driven by pensioners, and now folks have decided, "Right, back we go because the old folks fucked us with their choice, [1] [2]" old folks who are long gone. "The living should not be ruled by the dead." (Jefferson)
Personally, I see this with elderly folks I provide support and care for. "You are making poor choices, choices that will lead to these suboptimal downstream outcomes. I cannot stop you from making these choices. I will do my best to ensure your survival and comfort until death (death which is 100% assured and comes for us all) while maintaining legal and organizational bulkheads and firewalls to insulate myself from any impact of your suboptimal choices, but have planned and am prepared to execute a series of actions to recover once you depart." Same idea, at various societal scales.
It does, insofar as it might help the current generation introspect about their attitudes and behavior.
I’m in the oldest cohort of millennials, and I’m not looking forward to millennials taking over running nuclear power plants and the FAA when they die off. The boomers were not a disciplined generation, but they benefited from a carryover effect from being raised by the last disciplined generation. Now your power grid is going to be run by the kids the boomers themselves raised.
They did get a choice, and in this case, luckily, we can reverse it, because enough of them have finally died. Not all choices are reversible (climate change is looking that way). I do believe that one's vote value should decay as your time remaining decreases (as you're no longer voting for you, but for those with much longer time horizons of exposure to the consequences), but it will never happen, so I don't think it's an argument worth having.
When we can prevent them from making harmful choices, we absolutely should.
Why does the concept and process of a conservatorship exist? Should your vote be something considered for it? How much harm are you willing to tolerate from a generation with little to lose? I think we'll disagree on this, but I appreciate the discourse. Freedom sure sounds great when it's "I deserve to do whatever I want and everyone else cleans up the harm and externalities from it," so I can appreciate the allure of the concept and emotional foundation behind it.
You'll want a different criteria than "too little to lose" or you'll be arguing for taking voting rights away from the poor. Or in favor of the old belief that voting should be limited to property owners. It's common for conservatives to argue that poor people make poor decisions on government, especially around property rights, because they have too little to lose.
Why should someone avoid following their own logic to its conclusions because they might inadvertently agree with the other side? That’s a very odd argument!
If you accept with the moral premise that some people’s votes should count less because they have they are more likely to make short-sighted decisions, then you’re just dealing with the factual question of who is likely to make short-sighted decisions. Perhaps old people are. But so are other people! That’s a question you can answer objectively! There is scientific evidence that poverty, for example, is correlated with impulsive, short-sighted decisions. You can debate about whether poverty causes bad decision making or bad decision making causes poverty. But either way, if poor people weren’t allowed to vote, the result would likely be an electorate that engages in better decision making.
Dressing for comfort over status and signaling is self centered? Please explain how. Seems like it's going great as the 55+ age out of the workforce and young folks filter in, with different ideas (as recent midterms has shown, as this poll shows). Time is a forcing function for turnover in this regard, which is objectively good imho.
Very happy with how things are changing, condolences for those who are not. My best work comes just as easily in pajamas as it would business casual or formal. No one is stopping those who want to continue their fanciness for fun. I will measure your authority and competency by what you can do, not what you wear or how you present ("office larpers"). If I want to dress up for theater, I will find a theater role to act in.
(~4M Boomers retire a year, ~11k/day, ~2M people 55+ die every year, about half of which are in the labor force; that means ~13k-14k workers leave the labor force every day in the US, ~400k/month, ~4.8M/year, and with them goes their mental models and belief systems, as my root comment from Planck's principle communicates)
> Americans are far more likely to say it is acceptable for women to wear leggings to the office for work than to say it’s acceptable for men to do this (41% vs. 16%).
I have to wonder that if the survey doesn't take itself seriously, neither do the respondents necessarily?
My 5 year old daughter saw a guy in a suit walking through our neighborhood recently and asked “why is he dressed like a mayor?” Not common to see people in non-casual clothes these days.
Do you live in the west coast USA by any chance? Just my own experience but people seem to dress really casually for work there.
Suits and business casual are definitely still the norm in my area of the east coast.
Colorado. It’s very casual and outdoors oriented here away from the metro areas
I wasn't allowed to wear jeans to work in the late 90s. Never wore a suit, but I definitely had a pile of khakis. On the other hand, I had an office with a door that I could close.
In 2015 my boss hated shorts. Apparently he didn't want to see our hairy man legs. I'm sure he was mostly kidding. We respected that boundary by only wearing shorts while he was away.
Really didn't bother me since navy blue khakis and a golf shirt are my standard.
In a teacher orientation in rural school, the principle told us that they would prefer that teachers don't wear jeans, but so many of us don't have anything else that they don't make an issue out of it. He could have required that we buy suitable clothes, but didn't care enough.
> On the other hand, I had an office with a door that I could close. reply
It's kind of crazy that this doesn't exist anymore.
It was replaced by working from home.
Cube farms and open floor plans felt like what they always were: overflow for situational/temporary employees.
I'm a millennial and always had a door to my office once I committed to the career for more than 5 years. The people complaining were never serious.
It's absurd that it doesn't exist anymore especially when you consider the money being dropped on AI just to make developers more productive. Now it matters?
Worst seating I ever had was a corner desk half the company had to walk past to get to the kitchen and alongside a table tennis table for the yapping sales staff to enjoy between phone calls.
Dress formally to stay stuck in a cubicle where no one sees you. Only one of those things should have changed.
The less performative posturing, the better. The motivation behind formal dress/"corporate uniforms" is the same core motivation behind anti-WFH mindsets that think people need to have a manager looking over their shoulder at an office to get good work done.
I've told this story before, but once upon a time, I was the interviewer at an inbound call centre, interviewing a guy for a position on the phones. He turned up in a sleeveless T-shirt and torn jeans.
I asked him if he thought that he had come to the interview dressed professionally and he complained to HR after the interview that I was 'stifling his individuality'.
He answered angrily that yes he was and anyway it didn't matter because the job was just on the phones and customers would never see him and so on. He reacted so negatively to the question that I just moved on, but if he'd actually taken a few minutes to say 'no, I came dressed in what I would normally wear for a day on the job', I would have told him that that's perfectly fine, but sometimes, we have client visits and so on, and it's important that he understands the difference, and accepts that when there's a reason, we do need at least business casual dress, even for folks who spend all day answering the phone.
In the end, I rejected him for other reasons completely unrelated to how he was dressed, but I'm sure if he ever thinks back to that day, he remembers me unkindly.
To be fair that was quite a loaded question, even if you might not have actively intended it to be that way.
The question wasn't loaded. There was no presupposition based on the structure of the question. A loaded question would be more like: "When did you decide to stop dressing professionally?"
The question definitely exposed a poor choice. But it was not loaded.
It can be a factual question or a loaded one depending on whether the answerer is relaxed or feeling guilty about his attire.
To be fair to OP, an inbound call center worker probably should be good at diffusing that sort of thing
Ever watch the AMC TV series Madmen. Men used to wear dinner jackets to eat dinner, and never left home without some kind of hat. Women wore dresses everywhere. When I started working in a office 20+ years ago everyone wore business attire, ties were common. After some time you could only wear jeans and a nice shirt on Friday. More time passes, people were coming to work in hocky jerseys, jeans and sandals. Now after working from home for over 10 years my "work" outfits are probably out of date fashion wise. Everything changes. The best part was listening to all the boomers complain and realizing there was nothing they could do about it. "I can't wait to retire" was usually their next sentence.
It was bound to happen.
"Progress occurs one funeral at a time."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%27s_principle
Progress towards where?
Not having to waste money on uncomfortable clothes.
If you spend a bit you can get comfortable clothes. I didn't wear jeans for 20 years because as a child my parents made me wear inflexible heavy-weight denim and I loathed it; as it turns out Japanese selvedge 4-way stretch denim is cool and comfortable. The same applies to dress clothes. After I found a few brands that fit better than department store garbage I actually started enjoying dressing up.
So anything other than pajamas could is potentially uncomfortable
In this case, wearing what you find comfortable instead of what's traditional.
Progress is a loaded word. “Change” is more fitting. Sometimes change isn’t good.
> comfort and sensory needs above all else
Sounds like typical Millennial self-centeredness. How's that working out?
> Millennial
The youngest Millennials are pushing 40 these days.
Yeah and how are things running these days?
You mean with the 60-80 year olds in power? Not great. Maybe the millenials will fix things when it's their turn.
And everyday on the news we see too many of them proudly, bravely acting like toddlers throwing a tantrum. Boomers mostly learned early that this doesn't work. Many millennials learned that it does work, which is the boomers' fault.
> Boomers mostly learned early that this doesn't work
Really? Because as a genxer I remember growing up hearing all about the big protests in the 60s and 70s.
> And everyday on the news we see too many of them proudly, bravely acting like toddlers throwing a tantrum.
Do we? This sounds like either a bias in the media you're watching, or a bias in what you tend to notice.
With all due respect, old folks don't get a choice who is going to inherit the current operating system of society. An opinion without power or authority is of little value. Does it matter what Boomers think? Does it matter if younger cohorts care? Important questions imho. Provide an attempt at a solid hand off, or cry about it from the retirement home, at scale is my take.
Recent example was Brexit that was driven by pensioners, and now folks have decided, "Right, back we go because the old folks fucked us with their choice, [1] [2]" old folks who are long gone. "The living should not be ruled by the dead." (Jefferson)
Personally, I see this with elderly folks I provide support and care for. "You are making poor choices, choices that will lead to these suboptimal downstream outcomes. I cannot stop you from making these choices. I will do my best to ensure your survival and comfort until death (death which is 100% assured and comes for us all) while maintaining legal and organizational bulkheads and firewalls to insulate myself from any impact of your suboptimal choices, but have planned and am prepared to execute a series of actions to recover once you depart." Same idea, at various societal scales.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50521418 (citations)
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50520475 (thread)
> Does it matter what Boomers think?
It does, insofar as it might help the current generation introspect about their attitudes and behavior.
I’m in the oldest cohort of millennials, and I’m not looking forward to millennials taking over running nuclear power plants and the FAA when they die off. The boomers were not a disciplined generation, but they benefited from a carryover effect from being raised by the last disciplined generation. Now your power grid is going to be run by the kids the boomers themselves raised.
> old folks don't get a choice who is going to inherit the current operating system of society
And then:
> Recent example was Brexit that was driven by pensioners
So apparently they do get a choice. Do you mean they shouldn't? At what age should their franchise be revoked?
They did get a choice, and in this case, luckily, we can reverse it, because enough of them have finally died. Not all choices are reversible (climate change is looking that way). I do believe that one's vote value should decay as your time remaining decreases (as you're no longer voting for you, but for those with much longer time horizons of exposure to the consequences), but it will never happen, so I don't think it's an argument worth having.
When we can prevent them from making harmful choices, we absolutely should.
> I do think that your vote should decay as your time remaining decreases
Was the three-fifths person compromise in the Constitution not wrong, just applied to the wrong group, and should be sliding scale?
Why does the concept and process of a conservatorship exist? Should your vote be something considered for it? How much harm are you willing to tolerate from a generation with little to lose? I think we'll disagree on this, but I appreciate the discourse. Freedom sure sounds great when it's "I deserve to do whatever I want and everyone else cleans up the harm and externalities from it," so I can appreciate the allure of the concept and emotional foundation behind it.
You'll want a different criteria than "too little to lose" or you'll be arguing for taking voting rights away from the poor. Or in favor of the old belief that voting should be limited to property owners. It's common for conservatives to argue that poor people make poor decisions on government, especially around property rights, because they have too little to lose.
Why should someone avoid following their own logic to its conclusions because they might inadvertently agree with the other side? That’s a very odd argument!
If you accept with the moral premise that some people’s votes should count less because they have they are more likely to make short-sighted decisions, then you’re just dealing with the factual question of who is likely to make short-sighted decisions. Perhaps old people are. But so are other people! That’s a question you can answer objectively! There is scientific evidence that poverty, for example, is correlated with impulsive, short-sighted decisions. You can debate about whether poverty causes bad decision making or bad decision making causes poverty. But either way, if poor people weren’t allowed to vote, the result would likely be an electorate that engages in better decision making.
Agreed!
Millennials seem to be "working out" pretty well as a generation.
Dressing for comfort over status and signaling is self centered? Please explain how. Seems like it's going great as the 55+ age out of the workforce and young folks filter in, with different ideas (as recent midterms has shown, as this poll shows). Time is a forcing function for turnover in this regard, which is objectively good imho.
Very happy with how things are changing, condolences for those who are not. My best work comes just as easily in pajamas as it would business casual or formal. No one is stopping those who want to continue their fanciness for fun. I will measure your authority and competency by what you can do, not what you wear or how you present ("office larpers"). If I want to dress up for theater, I will find a theater role to act in.
Perceptions of Ethicality: The Role of Attire Style, Attire Appropriateness, and Context - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9918841/
Business Attire as Conformity Signaling - https://www.afterecon.com/posts/2017-09-25-business-attire-a... - September 25th, 2017
(~4M Boomers retire a year, ~11k/day, ~2M people 55+ die every year, about half of which are in the labor force; that means ~13k-14k workers leave the labor force every day in the US, ~400k/month, ~4.8M/year, and with them goes their mental models and belief systems, as my root comment from Planck's principle communicates)
> Dressing for comfort over status and signaling is self centered
There is a reason militaries wear uniforms and emphasize overt displays of coordinated behavior, and it’s not “signaling.”
better then self centered boomer bs. let's hope you let go of the reins of government too, before you take us all over a cliff.
[flagged]
[flagged]
The most successful CEOs have been signaling status by wearing street clothes since Steve Jobs paved the way. It was bound to trickle down.
Ok why not just wear pajamas then?
Dress for the job you want, not for the one you have, they say.
Me? Aspiring mattress tester.
I agree, but for more important stuff I wear my formal sweatpants.
Captain obvious checking in. I'm glad it's backed by data though...
lol only larpers use suits even when they're not even close to C level
who cares even?
how is this even a topic
)))
> Americans are far more likely to say it is acceptable for women to wear leggings to the office for work than to say it’s acceptable for men to do this (41% vs. 16%).
I have to wonder that if the survey doesn't take itself seriously, neither do the respondents necessarily?