All civilizational wealth comes from invention

(youtube.com)

9 points | by NarcisMirandes 4 hours ago ago

11 comments

  • NarcisMirandes 4 hours ago ago

    "All civilizational wealth comes from invention. 6,000 years ago somebody invented the plow and we all got wealthier. Much later somebody invented the steam engine and we all got wealthier. Without these inventions we would all be hunter gatherers today"

    Jeff Bezos

    Simple concept, but we usually forget and so important to make a better world.

    • genxy 4 hours ago ago

      It doesn't mean at the same time that invention is a universal good. Over the long term, new capabilities diffuse. Trains reached mass adoption around 1830, 170+ years later the railways are privately owned monopolies. Part of the spoils of invention is the power imbalance they create. The farmer with the plow can sell their food at a lower price, or feed a larger army.

      What were the knock on effects of the telegraph?

      Invention doesn't have to be material, pure abstract ideas can be just as powerful.

      • NarcisMirandes an hour ago ago

        If you "invent" something will you be able to control those uses and consequences? If you "invent" a new app that solve a problem can you control the uses that it will have, are you responsible for those?

    • ticulatedspline 4 hours ago ago

      a simple quote that largely mischaracterizes everything important. One that draws no distinctions between discovery, innovation, or invention. What good is a plow if you have no seeds to plant, or even know that planting seeds is a thing you can do?

      It's also rather tautological since civilization is a byproduct of those things. There are great herds of animals, tribes of primates, massive colonies of ants. None of these things we would characterize as "civilizations" despite their vast numbers or organization.

      It's not just "Wealth", Civilization itself is emergent from creating the knowledge, innovation, and inventions that serve needs of people. If you strip artifice from civilization you end up with a colony of ants.

    • Fricken 3 hours ago ago

      If you're the ruling class civilization is pretty cool. People care most about having the freedom to act in accordance with their nature.

      Civilization building is the art of keeping people in bondage. Simple concept but we usually forget and so important to make a better world.

      The early agricultural era was a pretty bad time for the vast majority of people. It was only up until very recently and only in limited parts of the world that the human experience has become sufficiently meaningless to be comfortable.

      • RetroTechie 2 hours ago ago

        > Civilization building is the art of keeping people in bondage.

        What a dim view of humanity. Sure, most civilizations were/are built around coercion in various forms. Does that mean civilization-building requires (threat of) force?

        Grassroots movements, flat, self-organizing ehm.. organizations are a thing. It should at least be possible to build civilizations that way.

        • Fricken 10 minutes ago ago

          It's not a dim view of humanity. The coolest thing I have ever known anybody to do is survive for hundreds of generations north of the arctic circle using only what they can find laying around.

  • astrodust an hour ago ago

    It comes from the ability to harness energy and put it to work. That's it. Everything transformative comes from being able to harness more energy, or to do different tasks with it.

    • NarcisMirandes an hour ago ago

      When we create an app are harnessing energy also?

  • fwlr an hour ago ago

    “All wealth comes from invention” does not imply “All that comes from invention is wealth”. The atomic bomb also came from invention.

  • upboundspiral an hour ago ago

    "Civilizational wealth comes from invention". Big if true.

    However, there is a corollary: civilizational destruction happens when wealth inequality reaches an advanced enough state.

    The Roman republic failed to meet the problems of the times (conquest leading to the senatorial class to enrich themselves and replace waged labor with slave labor). This led to the breakdown of old customs and laws, ending in the death of Tiberius Gracchus. Eventually, this gave space for Caesar to seize power (the populace wanted someone to kick in the senator's teeth).

    In the now empire, there was a struggle between the emperors and the senators. As long as this battle waged, things stabilized. Once the emperors won the war, the power they collected was so absolute it drove them insane - to have one person wield that much power means that they have infinitely corrupting effects on the rest of the system.

    In post WW1 Germany it was not the weakness of the Weimar Republic that allowed Hitler to gain power. It was the ridiculous war reparations and inflation inflicted upon Germany by the European nations that made the capitalist and manufacturing classes support someone as crazy as Hitler.

    The pattern of history is always that wealth inequality and extractive economic policy that leads to revolts, destruction, and war - the people at the top go mad with lack of consequences, the people at the bottom bristle with resentment.

    If we compare what Amazon and Big Tech is doing today, they are killing capitalism as well as the populace. It is incredible that top execs are not in straighjackets for how they treat their delivery workers. It is incredible how monopolies have been able to extract ever greater rents from every single seller and creator.

    At some point if you innovate too far into rent extraction you destroy yourself, your country, and your people.