I've been thinking a car is a perfect analogy for a long time.
* Much faster to get from A to B
* Bad for the environment
* Doesn't exercise you
* Formerly pedestrian spaces redesigned to be car/AI first
* Hard to go back
* Despite most people needing a simple Corolla (open weight or cheap model) many people want to drive a more expensive F150 (Opus) because it's better in edge cases
The cognitive decline which results from using AI is more similar to the effects on your health of trading walking in for an automobile rather than a bike.
Sometimes you need to use it as a motorized vehicle, other times you just need a little bit of assistance but, and sometimes it's just there to exist as a bike.
I would presume future AI would be a bit more included to recognized when the user has gaps in their knowledge that need to be addressed rather than just predicting the next token
The harness is the X-Wing, the LLM is R2-D2, the pilot is Luke Skywalker, and the force is that spark which some engineers can tap into, disciplined mental, physical, and emotional training. Nobody says R2-D2 blew up the Death Star!!
I've been thinking a car is a perfect analogy for a long time.
* Much faster to get from A to B
* Bad for the environment
* Doesn't exercise you
* Formerly pedestrian spaces redesigned to be car/AI first
* Hard to go back
* Despite most people needing a simple Corolla (open weight or cheap model) many people want to drive a more expensive F150 (Opus) because it's better in edge cases
* Reckless users cause accidents (huggingface)
The cognitive decline which results from using AI is more similar to the effects on your health of trading walking in for an automobile rather than a bike.
That's coming from someone who uses AI heavily.
It's more like a e-Bike than either one thing.
Sometimes you need to use it as a motorized vehicle, other times you just need a little bit of assistance but, and sometimes it's just there to exist as a bike.
Future AIs will solve the cognitive decline:
they will become some sort of "optimal bike". But right now it's more of a car with its downsides.
Why would future models be more like bikes? I’d think they’d be more like teleports
I would presume future AI would be a bit more included to recognized when the user has gaps in their knowledge that need to be addressed rather than just predicting the next token
It's a car in that heavy users ignore the negative externalities and risks of their own actions while complaining about everyone else.
Isn't it a bicycle for a pelican?
The harness is the X-Wing, the LLM is R2-D2, the pilot is Luke Skywalker, and the force is that spark which some engineers can tap into, disciplined mental, physical, and emotional training. Nobody says R2-D2 blew up the Death Star!!
A car with buggy autopilot that will happily drive you into the oncoming traffic at 70 mph.
AI is a mind for the car and potentially also the bicycle, although no one to my knowledge has built very good minds for bicycles.
A car is a mind for an AI.
The mind of humanity is the automobile for the AI.