US charges Irishman with destroying a $60M Air Force C-130

(taskandpurpose.com)

32 points | by ilamont 4 hours ago ago

41 comments

  • aziaziazi 4 hours ago ago

    > Shannon Airport is a major gateway for U.S. aircraft heading to and from the Middle East and Europe, which has angered some Irish who oppose the U.S. and Israeli war with Iran.

    > It’s a contentious issue in Ireland; many people are furious in terms of the U.S.’s use of the airport and they want the Irish government to stop the U.S. from using that airport

  • AngryData 4 hours ago ago

    Damn what a badass! Pulls out an axe and starts chopping it up in front of them. The world would be a better place if we saw more of this kind of protest.

    • TFNA 4 hours ago ago

      Some of these protests by people believing they were striking a blow for Gaza, ended up destroying equipment bound for Ukraine, Poland, or the Baltics to defend themselves, unknowingly working on instructions from a suspected Russian handler. The general public is not necessarily in a position to know what military stuff is used for what, and whether the world is made a better place or not is likely to be scattershot.

      • AngryData 3 hours ago ago

        A C-130 or most any other aircraft is not going to Ukraine because flying around Ukraine will get you blown up.

        But even if that wasn't true it still wouldn't matter because the majority of US hardware is used for suppressing weak governments and killing poor people. Stop doing that and there would be plenty left for Ukraine.

        • TFNA 3 hours ago ago

          Equipment bound for Ukraine is typically flown to e.g. Rzeszów airport in Poland, then moved overland. This has been a pretty commonly known fact for nearly five years now.

          With munition-consuming US military action against Iran particularly in the news right now, it doesn't feel accurate to speak of the US picking on "weak governments". The IRGC regime in Iran has proven remarkably strong and resilient, to the exasperation of the majority of the country's own population, and of many of Iran's neighbors.

          • bigyabai 3 hours ago ago

            I don't think the US is contributing enough materiel to Ukraine that losing a single C-130 would meaningfully disrupt their logistics.

            • skew-aberration 2 hours ago ago

              Same could be said of Gaza, though probably not Iran.

      • cicko 3 hours ago ago

        What are Poland and the Baltics defending themselves from?

        • TFNA 3 hours ago ago

          From the same country Ukraine is, by deploying e.g. new radar equipment (one of the planned deliveries destroyed by a Gaza-minded protestor) to reduce the risk they'll meet the same fate. Obviously most of any country's defense policy is carried out while it is not at war, with the very purpose of discouraging war.

      • MiroslavPokorny 3 hours ago ago

        The greatest partner of Russia has been America. The number of restrictions the US government has and continues to place and demand on Ukraine demonstrates they are actively helping Putin. Nobody needs friends who help the enemy this way, who seem to be more willing to deny intelligence, equipment and more.

      • BigTTYGothGF 3 hours ago ago

        > unknowingly working on instructions from a suspected Russian handler

        Seems a little far-fetched.

        • TFNA 3 hours ago ago

          This has been extensively covered in the news, and is something you could easily inform yourself about with an elementary web search.

      • gherkinnn 3 hours ago ago

        Imagine if all the resources and attention the US spent on predictably losing the Iran war went to Ukraine instead. All of those sweet, sweet interceptors.

    • aziaziazi 4 hours ago ago

      Seems he’s not alone. I wonder if they’re organised.

      > The indictment cited three other individuals who were arrested on May 1, 2025, after driving a van through the perimeter fence. About two weeks later, another three people spray-painted a U.S. military aircraft, while three more people were detained in November after driving onto a restricted area where a U.S. military C-40 transport was parked.

    • defrost 3 hours ago ago

      He methodically disabled and destroyed multiple aspects of the aircraft's integrity, instrumentation, and control over the course of many hours ...

        After about five hours, the flight crew showed up at about 9:40 a.m., when they spotted O’Corrain through the cockpit window. 
      
      This is some distance from bad ass axe wielding maniac ... the craft was toast before the US military was even aware they had been breached.

      But yes, a dramatic finish to carefully thought out and researched plan.

    • cowlevel an hour ago ago

      If you do this, it will be the last thing you ever do. That is why more people don't.

  • hitekker 4 hours ago ago

    His organization’s fundraiser calls him an “Independent Peace Activist” at a protest. It's a safe label; I think the unsafe one is that he was a violent activist in a violent protest.

    Not saying "violence is wrong"; my observation is that people like to hide their violence. Many seem to want violence against their political targets but won’t say it directly. I think because their self-image is nonviolent, good people pushed to an extreme and because they want to cover for those who use violence against others, to win for their side.

    • 8note 3 hours ago ago

      did he actually do violence?

      seems like he made some property damage, but who actually bled or was injured?

      if "damage happened to the surroundings" shouldnt say, google be imprisoned for enacting violence against those trees they chopped down in finland?

    • AngryData 3 hours ago ago

      How is destroying an airplane as safely as possible and without harming anybody violent? Destructive yes. But I would probably consider this a non-violent protest because the only person at risk was himself.

    • Computer0 an hour ago ago

      Usually it is because it is illegal to outwardly express an intent to cause violence and then do it whereas otherwise you'd have some level of plausible deniability. As a signal of support I will call them what they'd like to be called.

    • defrost 3 hours ago ago

      He hurt no one, he worked alone for five hours to disable a military craft.

      What violence against another took place?

  • moralestapia 4 hours ago ago

    Honest question, how could they charge him if he's in Ireland?

    • eugenekay 4 hours ago ago

      The linked indictment document was filed in a US Federal Court, “Southern District of New York” (aka New York City). They generally handle cases dealing with international matters because of the overlap with Embassies, United Nations, Global financial institution headquarters, etc. It has the entire COUNTRY of the United States of America listed as a Plaintiff, versus a single person. The referenced incident occurred on a military base of a NATO ally country. Establishing jurisdiction and obtaining an extradition warrant seems fairly straightforward.

      https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/media/1472641/dl

      • eugenekay an hour ago ago

        Addendum: D’oh, Ireland is not NATO. But there are multiple reciprocal extradition treaties in effect since 1983 - as well as EU agreements in 2003.

      • MiroslavPokorny 3 hours ago ago

        > Establishing jurisdiction and obtaining an extradition warrant seems fairly straightforward.

        Until that is done, the US cannot charge him or anyone in Ireland. Only the Irish government can charge people under its jurisdiction.

        A country is only a country because it create and enforces its own laws in its own lands.

        • Sabinus an hour ago ago

          I don't think that's correct. The USA, and all countries, can charge people outside it's territory for offences against its assets and citizens. International law recognises that right. What it can't do is arrest them without cooperation with the territory the alleged perpetrators are in.

        • eugenekay 2 hours ago ago

          It appears the Charges were filed correctly: US Code Title 18 Section 3238 is specifically referenced in the indictment. :-)

          This is the same Court which prosecuted Nicolas Maduro; I do not doubt their efficacy at enforcing the law as they understand it.

        • unrented7977 3 hours ago ago

          Tell that to the UK

    • advisedwang an hour ago ago

      Countries laws don't always end at their borders, ESPECIALLY the USAs. The question then becomes whether a country can enforce them. The USA had a good network of extradition treaties and also is willing to kidnap people even from the territory of allies with extradition treaties. So the USA can often enforce whatever laws they wish to apply anywhere in the world.

    • cowlevel an hour ago ago

      The US is the only country with tendrils long enough to get you anywhere in the world. Some time ago thatt were caught kidnapping a Muslim religious leader (forget the word sorry) in Italy, and that story made it to DEF CON, which means a lot more times it doesn't

    • encrypted_bird 4 hours ago ago

      I don't know for sure, but I suspect it's because when a country lets another nation use a plot ofnits land for a military base, that becomes, at least jurisdictionally, sovereign territory of that military's country.

  • ljsprague an hour ago ago

    Misplaced priorities; Ireland won't be Irish in a couple generations.

  • tt_dev 4 hours ago ago

    Irishman wins protest against US military presence

  • mindslight an hour ago ago

    I'd say contributory negligence on the part of the US military should bring the damages down to $60. You're prosecuting an extremist's holy war and shamelessly killing children, and you're running logistics through a country known for their tempers? Not the best idea.

  • MiroslavPokorny 3 hours ago ago

    When did Ireland become a part of the US ?

    • bombcar 2 hours ago ago

      It’s the other way around if you dig into it.

  • mvlipwig 2 hours ago ago

    I, for one, think that breaking into an airport in order to destroy an allied country's military assets is bad and that laws are a good way to discourage military sabotage.

    • defrost 2 hours ago ago

      Despite your thoughts on that, and despite existing laws in Ireland making breaking, entering, and property damage illegal this event still occurred.

      If you're familiar with the past 100 years, and more, of Irish history, the troubles, etc. you might notice also that laws did little to deter various factions senses of justice or to prevent various types of action.

      The US and England were allies during the Cold War, anti nuclear protestors often took actions against allied bases that were illegal.

  • postsantum 2 hours ago ago

    That's called decolonization. They would charge Patrice Lulumba too