Education is one of these topics that everyone seems to have an opinion on and that everyone grossly underestimates the complexities of. Whatever idea you have for reforming education has likely already been tried and failed due to lack of funding, poor test results, disgruntled parents, ulterior motives, or what have you. The history of education is littered with incredibly interesting and failed experiments. This isn't to say there aren't problems and that we shouldn't try to improve, but if we're going to get there people need to first respect the real difficulties, complexities, and history involved.
yes! though i would prefer current way of people having bold opinions and underestimate complexities rather than them thinking it is too complex to critique and staying silent.
> Education is one of these topics that everyone seems to have an opinion on and that everyone grossly underestimates the complexities of.
Everyone overestimates what is required for humans to learn. It is not complex, but is made complicated by scammers trying to take credit for the phenomenon of human learning. "Lecturing birds how to fly" as they say. Some of this is true ignorance, but most of it is the special kind of ignorance that comes from having one's income depend on not understanding.
Learning what? The education is massively multi-layered and learning the facts or skills is almost a side effect of the rest. You learn to put the work in to your improvement. You learn to meditate through repetitive tasks. You learn to overcome your lack of willingness to do things. And I’m but talking about things I was taught at school, not things an actual specialist could list.
I think the biggest starting point is understanding that "Education" is an overloaded term to start with. In most of these claims of gross complexity, it's not actually the "teach a kid a thing" that's hard. It's the "managing a classroom of 25-30 neglected ipad kids while also trying to teach them all a thing".
While the latter is hard, it's also begging the question as to why there are a few untouchable tenants, some of them conflicting. If you are willing to compromise on some of the tenants, then you'll find that "Education" is pretty easily solvable for the median child.
As an example some from the top of my head,
1) We could perform strict "3-strikes and you're out" behavior policy in schools. Three suspensions and you're gone for good. This would be better for the vast majority of students but would have politically unacceptable statistics attached.
2) We could start tracking kids in early teen years and weed out the non-college bound from the studious. This would objectively be better for all students involved, but would be frowned upon in the current (capital E) Education system.
3) We could accept that students must perform up to their standards and not allow for IEPs or other instructional accommodations. This would be found to be unacceptable due to putting accountability on students and parents for underperforming.
4) We could put strict performance standards in place for students which ensure that a diploma and qualifications mean something and aren't reduced to simple age checks.
5) We could put strict performance standards in place for teachers which weed out those who are unable to motivate and bring children up to standards.
There are a huge list of things that would work to improve outcomes but for one reason or another are either politically/socially unacceptable in the current environment, negatively impact teacher's unions, or would result in lower funding for the school system.
Consider that coaches, Sunday school leaders, Scout leaders all get _way_ fewer hours per kid and have no formal education training; yet most are able to teach them effectively and efficiently.
I am not dismissing traditional education because it is traditional. I am dismissing it because I see big issues with it. For example, traditional restaurants are actually really good and totally make sense.
The whole US Education system was developed by the Rockefellers to train workers instead of educating us with logic and reason. Those skills can still be taught with Critical Thinking: https://www.criticalthinking.org/ instead of being told what to believe the student questions everything like science is supposed to teach and arrive at their own conclusions.
The framing of the review first goes over different models of teaching (including the kind you’re pushing here) and compares it with other models (including the kind[s] you’re supposedly criticizing). I found this framing helpful in asking the fundamental questions: what is the point of school, and how can a government tasked with educating the masses deliver.
This is another one of those cases where I’m simply tired of hearing the same arguments from people who either didn’t have a good time in school and/or were smarter than average and were bored/stilted as a result. The system is designed (not perfectly!) to serve the masses. If it didn’t serve you, it doesn’t mean it was broken (or designed to produce worker drones).
Always thought it was weird how low the bar is for US public education. Like AP classes [0] are a joke compared to UK A-levels [1] and college entrance exams in SEA [2] [3]. I realize these tests aren't exactly teaching "how to arrive at your own conclusions" but having an expansive knowledge base seems like a somewhat important prerequisite to drawing conclusions.
> Those skills can still be taught with Critical Thinking
"Critical thinking" isn't a general purpose skill. The foundation of an education where you can reason and question to reach one's own conclusions is knowledge (as in actual facts that become interconnected as you learn more). ED Hirsch's work details how American and French schools replaced a knowledge-based curriculum with a "skills" based (including critical thinking skills) where you learn things like "find the main idea." This was likely a mistake. For example, there's a famous paper where reading comprehension on a passage about baseball depended more on whether you knew facts about baseball than on how "strong" a reader you were. So if we want students who think critically, the most reliable route is teaching them a lot of knowledge, not drilling "thinking skills" in isolation.
This is true of a lot of things. Logical thinking is a skill that can be honed and is broadly applicable. But for lots of fields (eg medicine) you just need to learn a lot of foundational things before you can reasonably get to the meat of understanding the “system”. You just need to memorize terms, concepts, and the relationships between them.
mostly that it is fine to let kid explore and do different things. i am working on actual paper with proofs, tests with people and everything though, and not expecting this single paragraph to be a guide for someone's education. a bit more substance is available here, though still shallow: https://keycybermonk.com/rlt
The US public school system is controlled to benefit bureaucrats, teachers and teachers' unions. Plus the system is designed so all students have to learn at the pace of the slowest.
The money in the schools goes almost entirely to instructing children. Teachers in the United States are generally poorly-paid compared to peer nations.
The schools work hard to make sure that students who are struggling get support. They also work hard to make sure that students who are ahead of the class have enrichment activities to support their learning. Often kids struggle in some classes and excel in others. If you had kids in school you would know that.
I love the shot at the unions. That really shows where you're getting your information. Teachers' unions have almost no power in nearly any state as they're not allowed to strike or really engage in any work stoppage. Often the most they'll do is "work to the rule" where they refuse to work long hours after school.
If you had any familiarity with how public schools in the United States actually operate you would be making commentary about how funding public schools through property taxes leads to poor outcomes because poor areas cannot spend the money to fully support kids.
I watched my mom teach in one of the richest counties in the country and in one of the poorest areas of DC. The differences between her schools were almost entirely about investment. Maybe it is wrong for teachers to seek the best pay for their work but if that's the case it is wrong for all of us.
My kids are in an excellent school system with strong support for every learner. I just wish that was true for every single child in this country. Instead propaganda like what you are pushing is used to push funding from public schools that accept all students to private schools that discriminate.
Thank You! This is a large part of what I wanted to say.
I would add that the author again exposes their lack of familiarity by complaining about having to learn history.
One of the main factors that allows the most uneducated demographic in the US to be manipulated by bullshiters, is a lack of understanding of how we reached this point.
Understanding history is something every citizen of a democracy is critically in need of.
I was living and studying in Ukraine and in the whole curriculum there was no topic about US education history. And I am not against studying history, I am against forcing people to study it.
Education is one of these topics that everyone seems to have an opinion on and that everyone grossly underestimates the complexities of. Whatever idea you have for reforming education has likely already been tried and failed due to lack of funding, poor test results, disgruntled parents, ulterior motives, or what have you. The history of education is littered with incredibly interesting and failed experiments. This isn't to say there aren't problems and that we shouldn't try to improve, but if we're going to get there people need to first respect the real difficulties, complexities, and history involved.
yes! though i would prefer current way of people having bold opinions and underestimate complexities rather than them thinking it is too complex to critique and staying silent.
> Education is one of these topics that everyone seems to have an opinion on and that everyone grossly underestimates the complexities of.
Everyone overestimates what is required for humans to learn. It is not complex, but is made complicated by scammers trying to take credit for the phenomenon of human learning. "Lecturing birds how to fly" as they say. Some of this is true ignorance, but most of it is the special kind of ignorance that comes from having one's income depend on not understanding.
Learning what? The education is massively multi-layered and learning the facts or skills is almost a side effect of the rest. You learn to put the work in to your improvement. You learn to meditate through repetitive tasks. You learn to overcome your lack of willingness to do things. And I’m but talking about things I was taught at school, not things an actual specialist could list.
I think the biggest starting point is understanding that "Education" is an overloaded term to start with. In most of these claims of gross complexity, it's not actually the "teach a kid a thing" that's hard. It's the "managing a classroom of 25-30 neglected ipad kids while also trying to teach them all a thing".
While the latter is hard, it's also begging the question as to why there are a few untouchable tenants, some of them conflicting. If you are willing to compromise on some of the tenants, then you'll find that "Education" is pretty easily solvable for the median child.
As an example some from the top of my head,
1) We could perform strict "3-strikes and you're out" behavior policy in schools. Three suspensions and you're gone for good. This would be better for the vast majority of students but would have politically unacceptable statistics attached.
2) We could start tracking kids in early teen years and weed out the non-college bound from the studious. This would objectively be better for all students involved, but would be frowned upon in the current (capital E) Education system.
3) We could accept that students must perform up to their standards and not allow for IEPs or other instructional accommodations. This would be found to be unacceptable due to putting accountability on students and parents for underperforming.
4) We could put strict performance standards in place for students which ensure that a diploma and qualifications mean something and aren't reduced to simple age checks.
5) We could put strict performance standards in place for teachers which weed out those who are unable to motivate and bring children up to standards.
There are a huge list of things that would work to improve outcomes but for one reason or another are either politically/socially unacceptable in the current environment, negatively impact teacher's unions, or would result in lower funding for the school system.
Consider that coaches, Sunday school leaders, Scout leaders all get _way_ fewer hours per kid and have no formal education training; yet most are able to teach them effectively and efficiently.
Tag: bulverism fallacy
I am not dismissing traditional education because it is traditional. I am dismissing it because I see big issues with it. For example, traditional restaurants are actually really good and totally make sense.
The internet has disintermediated everything.
Let the government set standards and monitor student progress.
Gamify all the things and let people work at their own pace.
Public education seems to amount to so much day care anymore.
The whole US Education system was developed by the Rockefellers to train workers instead of educating us with logic and reason. Those skills can still be taught with Critical Thinking: https://www.criticalthinking.org/ instead of being told what to believe the student questions everything like science is supposed to teach and arrive at their own conclusions.
I read the book review on ACX of The Educated Mind a few years back.
https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/your-book-review-the-educat...
The framing of the review first goes over different models of teaching (including the kind you’re pushing here) and compares it with other models (including the kind[s] you’re supposedly criticizing). I found this framing helpful in asking the fundamental questions: what is the point of school, and how can a government tasked with educating the masses deliver.
This is another one of those cases where I’m simply tired of hearing the same arguments from people who either didn’t have a good time in school and/or were smarter than average and were bored/stilted as a result. The system is designed (not perfectly!) to serve the masses. If it didn’t serve you, it doesn’t mean it was broken (or designed to produce worker drones).
Always thought it was weird how low the bar is for US public education. Like AP classes [0] are a joke compared to UK A-levels [1] and college entrance exams in SEA [2] [3]. I realize these tests aren't exactly teaching "how to arrive at your own conclusions" but having an expansive knowledge base seems like a somewhat important prerequisite to drawing conclusions.
[0] https://secure-media.collegeboard.org/digitalServices/pdf/ap...
[1] https://www.scribd.com/document/828528451/A-star-training-qu...
[2] https://mathpowergen.com/2026-%ec%88%98%eb%8a%a5-%ec%88%98%e...
[3] https://www.densu.jp/tokyo/26tokyospass.pdf
> Those skills can still be taught with Critical Thinking
"Critical thinking" isn't a general purpose skill. The foundation of an education where you can reason and question to reach one's own conclusions is knowledge (as in actual facts that become interconnected as you learn more). ED Hirsch's work details how American and French schools replaced a knowledge-based curriculum with a "skills" based (including critical thinking skills) where you learn things like "find the main idea." This was likely a mistake. For example, there's a famous paper where reading comprehension on a passage about baseball depended more on whether you knew facts about baseball than on how "strong" a reader you were. So if we want students who think critically, the most reliable route is teaching them a lot of knowledge, not drilling "thinking skills" in isolation.
This is true of a lot of things. Logical thinking is a skill that can be honed and is broadly applicable. But for lots of fields (eg medicine) you just need to learn a lot of foundational things before you can reasonably get to the meat of understanding the “system”. You just need to memorize terms, concepts, and the relationships between them.
My US born wife took a critical thinking course at community college and it changed her life. It was like installing anti-virus software.
im questioning why i have to register for a course on how to think instead of having it just spelled out on the page ;P
Cant let just anyone learn how to think
Iirc, John Rockefeller only promulgated the system Horace Mann stole from the prussians
And there's not even a Prussia anymore, yet much of the world still has their society's education system.
This is extremely light on substance (and that's a generous reading). What is anyone supposed to get out of reading this single-paragraph-sized post?
mostly that it is fine to let kid explore and do different things. i am working on actual paper with proofs, tests with people and everything though, and not expecting this single paragraph to be a guide for someone's education. a bit more substance is available here, though still shallow: https://keycybermonk.com/rlt
I think if the author was well educated they could write a post without significant grammatical errors.
I skipped college, I am clearly not well-educated
Stop commenting on education policy if you aren't going to try to learn shit.
I am learning a lot, just not through "education"
I read the author’s other blog posts. I hope they’re doing better now, and I wish them a happy and stable life.
This post in question seemed a bit delusional, but it succeeded in getting eyeballs!
thank you!
The US public school system is controlled to benefit bureaucrats, teachers and teachers' unions. Plus the system is designed so all students have to learn at the pace of the slowest.
What do you expect to be the results?
The money in the schools goes almost entirely to instructing children. Teachers in the United States are generally poorly-paid compared to peer nations.
The schools work hard to make sure that students who are struggling get support. They also work hard to make sure that students who are ahead of the class have enrichment activities to support their learning. Often kids struggle in some classes and excel in others. If you had kids in school you would know that.
I love the shot at the unions. That really shows where you're getting your information. Teachers' unions have almost no power in nearly any state as they're not allowed to strike or really engage in any work stoppage. Often the most they'll do is "work to the rule" where they refuse to work long hours after school.
If you had any familiarity with how public schools in the United States actually operate you would be making commentary about how funding public schools through property taxes leads to poor outcomes because poor areas cannot spend the money to fully support kids.
I watched my mom teach in one of the richest counties in the country and in one of the poorest areas of DC. The differences between her schools were almost entirely about investment. Maybe it is wrong for teachers to seek the best pay for their work but if that's the case it is wrong for all of us.
My kids are in an excellent school system with strong support for every learner. I just wish that was true for every single child in this country. Instead propaganda like what you are pushing is used to push funding from public schools that accept all students to private schools that discriminate.
Thank You! This is a large part of what I wanted to say.
I would add that the author again exposes their lack of familiarity by complaining about having to learn history.
One of the main factors that allows the most uneducated demographic in the US to be manipulated by bullshiters, is a lack of understanding of how we reached this point.
Understanding history is something every citizen of a democracy is critically in need of.
I was living and studying in Ukraine and in the whole curriculum there was no topic about US education history. And I am not against studying history, I am against forcing people to study it.
Those who do not learn history are destined to repeat it.
> Teachers' unions have almost no power in nearly any state as they're not allowed to strike or really engage in any work stoppage
What?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Chicago_Public_Schools_st...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Portland_Association_of_T...
Unfortunately it became a "good standard" that other countries where education is not controlled by benefit bureaucrats, are just copying mindlessly