25 comments

  • barbariangrunge 8 hours ago ago

    Sometimes it can be fun to buy a share or two of something and just hold it to see where it goes. I have a tiny bit of ETH for example that I mined one weekend like 10 years ago. But at a 1.5T valuation, it's hard to convince yourself it could 10x or even 2x in a few years so it doesn't sound as fun in this case

    • oska 7 hours ago ago

      IOW, it might not be that attractive to gamblers

  • ncd 9 hours ago ago

    For those in the know, is there a realistic path to long-term upside at this price? I think Anthropic is a fascinating business, but I'm trying to understand—given competitive pressures—how much people think the buying action at the IPO will be FOMO vs value investing.

    • barbariangrunge 8 hours ago ago

      I don't understand their moat. I see a number of other big ai companies arising over the next decade that could all be extremely valuable. The usefulness of smaller models over the same timeframe should probably increase dramatically too. The 1.5T feels to me like there is some assumption of holding an oligopoly or semi-monopoly position long term, or that they expect some runaway development to skyrocket them forward.

      ie: for the price, I'd rather invest in a smaller lab that doesn't need to conquer the world to justify it's share price

      • donmcronald 7 hours ago ago

        I think part of the moat, for all of them, is how much of your memories and context they can usurp. I’ve been testing Claude Code recently and, even though I care about it, I don’t know if or how much of that stuff is getting done in a non-portable way.

        So the big thing IMO is that normal people don’t understand the risk of getting dependent on an AI company that has all your “memories” and that remembers every conversation perfectly. Imagine 20 years of context locked behind a subscription.

      • OkayPhysicist 7 hours ago ago

        The pitch is that having better models lets you develop even better models faster, and that there'll be some sort of takeoff. I don't buy it, either.

    • 6thbit 8 hours ago ago

      They will be the first and thus for now super-scarce frontier lab "AI pure play" stock and many people that are mouth watering for that will buy despite their fundamentals. But Value opportunity isn't really there right now. (It was there for early investors in private equity)

      They also market themselves as a public benefit company and safety driven, which are not priorities for growth maximization. Their main page says "Anthropic is a public benefit corporation dedicated to securing (AI's) benefits and mitigating its risks."

      Then there's cost pressure from the competition, like oAI's cost per task being quite cheaper with only marginally less intelligence than ant's models.

      So there doesn't seem to be a clear path to long term upside. But short to mid term and before OAI's own IPO it's likely to attract more money than it should.

    • debrisontrack 9 hours ago ago

      I was basically going to ask the same thing: in which scenario(s) would the price not fall?

    • CamperBob2 8 hours ago ago

      I don't know enough about the business to say if Kevin Bass's recent post is tinfoil-hattery or not, but it's thought-provoking: https://nitter.cf/kevinnbass/status/2099621874279817638

      Success at pulling off what he claims they are trying to pull off -- owning all aspects of AI regulation, basically -- will indeed position them for growth, albeit at everyone else's expense.

      • CrimsonCape 8 hours ago ago

        We don't see what the internal models have the capability of. They are bounded by the obvious limits of compute and less obvious limits like theoretical knowledge, engineer talent, etc.

        So you get to see a public model but have no concept of how much better the internal model is than the public model. But more critically, how much the internal models push beyond each prior generation. My guess is that eventually they will internally see diminishing feedback at some point, suggesting they have hit the cap of the limits of the current frontier architecture.

        That feels like the logical pivot point.

        My guess is that the keep-up game is only going to last throughout the IPOs, and then the big names will settle (or collude...) on dropping new models every 6 months or a year. The only thing I can imagine keeping that from happening is the deepseek competition.

        • neodymiumphish 5 hours ago ago

          Chinese models are nipping at their heels to the tune of maybe 6-12 months. Any settling or collusion by the US frontier AI orgs would kill their advantage.

      • NBJack 8 hours ago ago

        There are some big incumbents in the tech political game. Google has been playing it since the early days of the internet.

      • estearum 7 hours ago ago

        Kevin Bass is a globally renowned retard lol

        > China is keeping messaging tight. That is why optimism for AI is so high in China.

        Nah, China is positive on AI because China's living memory is waves of technological advancement pulling a billion people out of destitute poverty. Meanwhile, America's living memory is technology destroying the fabric of our society and reptilian CEOs dancing on the shreds.

        > Anthropic's business model, models itself after the very thing it claims to fear.

        This feedback loop is itself what Anthropic (and other AI doomers) have been drawing attention to for decades now. It's hilarious seeing dummies like Kevin "realize" this and think that it's some big secret that their big brain investigations uncovered and not literally the entire problem.

        The question is, if you believe this feedback loop exists or is inevitable (today we have empirical validation), then what to do about it? Anthropic's answer is "be first and be better," which self-referentially is the problematic dynamic to begin with, but merely identifying it as a problematic dynamic does not eliminate it or create a way to disrupt it by simply opting out. That's why, in fact, it's a problem at all.

  • 6thbit 8 hours ago ago

    They now published officially:

      Today Anthropic, PBC priced its initial public offering of its Class A common stock at $83.00 per share. The offering consists of 980,000,000 shares of Class A common stock, 956,351,354 of which are being sold by Anthropic and 23,648,646 of which are being sold by certain selling stockholders. Anthropic will not receive any proceeds from the sale of shares by the selling stockholders.
    
    https://www.anthropic.com/news/anthropic-prices-initial-publ...
    • duderific 8 hours ago ago

      For those "certain selling stockholders," what does that mean exactly? Do those sellers just keep the proceeds for themselves?

      • OkayPhysicist 7 hours ago ago

        That's the early investors cashing out. If my buddy starting a business selling dog toys, and I invested 10 grand in it to get it off the ground, in exchange I would receive some fraction of his company. If that dog toy business took off to the point that he's going public, I'd still own that fraction of the company, and I'd probably put some of my shares up for sale.

      • 6thbit 8 hours ago ago

        Exactly that. 23,648,646 shares at 83 come up to ~1.9B that anthropic won't get themselves. But they still get ~105B cash.

  • Sohcahtoa82 8 hours ago ago

    People arguing about whether or not the valuation is justified, talking about fundamentals like P/E, have forgotten something:

    The current modern market doesn't actually care about fundamentals when it comes to certain hype stocks. It's all vibes, memes, and cult following.

    People will defend buying Tesla stock despite car sales slipping and their P/E being an absolutely ridiculous 422.

    So the question is...can Anthropic get people to buy their stock and ignore fundamentals? If so, the number goes up.

    • lbourdages 7 hours ago ago

      Is economics able to describe this, to be used to predict behaviour?

    • PeeMcGee 4 hours ago ago

      Also worth considering is whether yet another "trillion dollar" company will disillusion the market that puts money into these promise factories?

  • cookiengineer 7 hours ago ago

    And here is me, self hosting and self training Chinese models, thinking that Claude and Fable were useless since February against them...

    I don't understand this, to be honest. Claude is such a stupid model compared to DeepSeek v4.1 or GLM 5.3 or even Qwen3.8 flash next, especially in cyber security related tasks.

    I get their marketing strategy, but it's just that. And they don't deliver on their promise and haven't done so since November anymore. They had the lead with Opus 4.6 but it got gradually so much worse that pretty much all people working in cyber that I know of all switched to different models or started to selfhost.

    They (including me) were happy customers back in January, though.

  • ChrisArchitect 4 hours ago ago

    Some later discussion on source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50553843

  • undefined 8 hours ago ago
    [deleted]
  • somewhereoutth 8 hours ago ago

    Worth noting that only around 5% of the company is being offered at this IPO, seems doubtful that a much larger fraction would get a similar price. In other words, the overall 1.5T valuation is somewhat engineered.