4 comments

  • realityfactchex 7 hours ago ago

    Are they (mostly) obviously vibe coded projects, with obviously AI-written landing pages (e.g., the README files on github)?

    If so, I would conjecture that's probably what's getting the posts killed.

    This place is half pro-AI, but still seems to want POSTS to be either not AI-created, or, if AI was involved with their creation, very open about it, and, at best, completely overcoming that aspect with the value it brings, and at minimum, not chock full of "annoying, in your face" AI-isms.

    That's just my guess, though. You'd know for sure if it applies. If this does not apply, then, obviously it's not this.

    BTW I'm not casting judgement, just offering a hypothesis. I see a lot of systems making participation in various systems harder for real human users, as a result of having to fend off the bots and AIs.

  • anenefan 7 hours ago ago

    HN is presently been said to be flooded with projects, much is said not to cut the mustard and as such Show HN has been limited.

    Generally when the submission fails, the show hn topic will be simply marked as dead. Those who set their profile to see dead posts, who visit the newest section will see them - if they happen to deem the show hn worthy, they'll vouch. The last show hn of yours I can see is from 13 days ago is about agents - LLMs isn't something I do, so I wouldn't know if it makes the cut. I'd guess immediate refusal has something to do with reposting the same.

  • genezeta 5 hours ago ago

    HN receives a lot of spam. Given how easy it is to submit, this is not surprising. And so they have other mechanisms to avoid spam, mainly to automatically mark submissions with various criteria.

    Now leaving the most blatant forms of spam aside, as the guidelines state the main focus of the site is "curiosity". As such, there's a guideline that reads:

      Please don't use HN primarily for promotion. It's ok to post your own stuff part of the time, but the primary use of the site should be for curiosity.
    
    What they appear do here is take into account your posting history to check if what you're doing is self-promotion. Checking your submissions it certainly looks like you're posting exclusively, or almost exclusively, your own projects. And so the checker marks them as such.

    > kind of makes me just generally not want to post projects here.

    Not to be unwelcoming, but that is exactly the idea. Again, while people can do so from time to time, the intention is precisely that you do not post your own stuff so often or so exclusively.

  • selectedambient 8 hours ago ago

    worst part is i have emailed the mods like 3 times now over several months.