Mike Lynch's superyacht had unidentified vulnerability to high winds

(theguardian.com)

3 points | by n1b0m 4 hours ago ago

4 comments

  • silverFork 3 hours ago ago

    It was built with a single taller mast for sailing record I believe so it had too tall of a mast relative to the size of the ship in my opinion.. They should have had multiple masts rather than one giant one I think.

    It could have flipped no mattered how the mast was secured.. 240 ft mast!! its massive.

  • manarth 4 hours ago ago

      > "This vulnerability had not been identified in the originally approved stability information available to the crew"
    
    I.e. the ship-builder did not recognise this as a risk and record it in the operating manuals.

      > "The weather forecast also did not indicate the risk of downbursts from the thunderstorms it predicted"
    
    This would appear to reduce the accusation of liability on the captain and crew, and frame this more as a tragic accident.

    Questions might remain with the ship-builder on the extent of the stability assessments.

    • DivingForGold 4 hours ago ago

      Why would a boat crew retract the weighted keel ?

      1) Avoid anchor rode fouling

      2) Shallow water access

      3) Raising the keel allows the boat to swing smoothly into the wind, reducing unwanted rolling and heeling

      4) Protection Against Grounding (tides)

  • bell-cot 3 hours ago ago

    For those unfamiliar - sudden-onset high winds and storms were regularly sinking ships and killing sailors back when the Pyramids were still being built. That's much of why the bottom of the Mediterranean is an ancient historian's fondest fantasy come true.

    And "we didn't bother about improbable worst cases" was human nature long before the Titanic met its iceberg.