These drugs are fascinating to me. The global changes to nutrition over the past two hundred years have been immense- reduction in fiber, increase in sugar and fat. The human brain has two separate reward pathways for food, one for sugars and one for fats. No food which exists in nature which is edible in its raw state contains both at the same time in significant quantities except the fresh young peanut at a specific balance point in its development. (Happy to learn of others- considered coconut and cocoa pods, but the sweetness and fat are located in different sections of the nut and pod. It still might count. There's a reason they are popular.) (Side note, if you have availability and no allergies, go pick your own peanuts and boil them. They are absolutely a different flavor when fresh.)
A huge amount of human food prep is in mixing sugars (or sugar precursors like starches) and fats to trigger both reward pathways at the same time, as a double-whammy of brain reward. Fatty meats with sweet sauces like barbecue and ketchup, bread and butter, the old pemican recipes, peanut butter and jelly, halva, pastries, sweet ginger on sushi with fatty tuna and avocado, grilled cheese, sugar as an ingredient in powdered nacho flavoring on chips, pizza, ice cream, etc, etc. It's a universal underpinning of all culinary traditions worldwide. (Obviously Not All Foods, but yes all the most popular foods in all culinary traditions, so please don't be deliberately contrary about this one.) Our brains don't really have a defense against this double whammy. They love what they love, and motivate us to seek it out and make it.
But everything counts in large amounts. And for the first time in history we have large amounts of food meeting the double-reward criteria, available at all times in all situations. It doesn't take effort to eat, it takes effort not to eat. Since food providing a double whammy of a reward is cheap, legal, available, and socially acceptable, people are using it like a drug to cope with the anxieties of an increasingly socially disconnected world, where the safe, welcoming, in-person interaction your brain needs to be healthy is often missing. And that's how you get insane levels of obesity.
It's also how you get huge numbers of kids with endocrine disruptions from poor nutrition in childhood. Too much sugar too young from formula as a baby through easy access to soda and candy in teen years leaves a lasting mark, which can impact hunger signaling throughout life (insulin, ghrelin, etc). It takes a LOT of parenting work to keep kids away from what equates to an ubiquitous and commonly accepted drug. And most people are simply unaware of the reward pathways and interactions on ghrelin and insulin, because who has time to learn that or access to easy to understand explanations? Most folks don't even know there's something new to learn about it all.
So back to the start: my lingering question on drugs that impact appetite is this: are the drugs resetting people to some state of appetite they would normally be in if they had not had early childhood exposure to so much highly sweetened food?
These drugs are fascinating to me. The global changes to nutrition over the past two hundred years have been immense- reduction in fiber, increase in sugar and fat. The human brain has two separate reward pathways for food, one for sugars and one for fats. No food which exists in nature which is edible in its raw state contains both at the same time in significant quantities except the fresh young peanut at a specific balance point in its development. (Happy to learn of others- considered coconut and cocoa pods, but the sweetness and fat are located in different sections of the nut and pod. It still might count. There's a reason they are popular.) (Side note, if you have availability and no allergies, go pick your own peanuts and boil them. They are absolutely a different flavor when fresh.)
A huge amount of human food prep is in mixing sugars (or sugar precursors like starches) and fats to trigger both reward pathways at the same time, as a double-whammy of brain reward. Fatty meats with sweet sauces like barbecue and ketchup, bread and butter, the old pemican recipes, peanut butter and jelly, halva, pastries, sweet ginger on sushi with fatty tuna and avocado, grilled cheese, sugar as an ingredient in powdered nacho flavoring on chips, pizza, ice cream, etc, etc. It's a universal underpinning of all culinary traditions worldwide. (Obviously Not All Foods, but yes all the most popular foods in all culinary traditions, so please don't be deliberately contrary about this one.) Our brains don't really have a defense against this double whammy. They love what they love, and motivate us to seek it out and make it.
But everything counts in large amounts. And for the first time in history we have large amounts of food meeting the double-reward criteria, available at all times in all situations. It doesn't take effort to eat, it takes effort not to eat. Since food providing a double whammy of a reward is cheap, legal, available, and socially acceptable, people are using it like a drug to cope with the anxieties of an increasingly socially disconnected world, where the safe, welcoming, in-person interaction your brain needs to be healthy is often missing. And that's how you get insane levels of obesity.
It's also how you get huge numbers of kids with endocrine disruptions from poor nutrition in childhood. Too much sugar too young from formula as a baby through easy access to soda and candy in teen years leaves a lasting mark, which can impact hunger signaling throughout life (insulin, ghrelin, etc). It takes a LOT of parenting work to keep kids away from what equates to an ubiquitous and commonly accepted drug. And most people are simply unaware of the reward pathways and interactions on ghrelin and insulin, because who has time to learn that or access to easy to understand explanations? Most folks don't even know there's something new to learn about it all.
So back to the start: my lingering question on drugs that impact appetite is this: are the drugs resetting people to some state of appetite they would normally be in if they had not had early childhood exposure to so much highly sweetened food?