14 comments

  • A_D_E_P_T 3 hours ago ago

    America thinks it is a martial power, a superpower. This is completely wrong. America has always been a mercantile power. There's ample proof of this everywhere, but just consider this: Its greatest contribution to WWII was lend-lease, and its army has always been most famous for its logistics.

    China, too, has always been a mercantile power. The problem is that China has in recent decades played the game better, with smarter industrial policy and less concentration of wealth and power in the financial and service industries. So it is growing into becoming the engine of the future; the other side of the coin is that the American mercantile empire is cannibalizing and turning in on itself. The two have become interlocked.

    India is neither a martial nor a mercantile power. To both China and the US, it's largely irrelevant; there's no foreseeable future where India can displace America's concentration of wealth or China's development trajectory.

    • muzani 3 hours ago ago

      Hey, I wrote about the same thing! But India is expected to outdo US GDP by 2050.

      Let's take Bangladesh as a tangent. They did textiles and now they're taking over fashion and clothing. One day, Made in Dhaka may be sexier than Made in Milan.

      Levi's is made with Bangladesh, but it's still an American brand. Unlike BYD or Xiaomi, they're not a threat to the American image. Same goes for India.

      • dormento 44 minutes ago ago

        > Hey, I wrote about the same thing! But India is expected to outdo US GDP by 2050.

        (important caveat: IIRC this is total economy, not per capita)

        > Unlike BYD or Xiaomi, they're not a threat to the American image.

        Now this is a very important point I had not considered. I imagine the 2050 scenario involves a young demographic, green energy and internal consumption, but there's nothing preventing what you said. With the gradual diminishing in American soft power, Hollywood will also become less relevant, which means what today is "exotic" could become the new "pop".

      • A_D_E_P_T 2 hours ago ago

        > Hey, I wrote about the same thing!

        Did you publish it anywhere? I'd love to see it.

    • AnimalMuppet 3 hours ago ago

      Its greatest contribution was lend-lease? Only if you restrict yourself to WWII in Europe. The US did most of the heavy lifting against Japan.

      Its army has always been most famous for its logistics? That seems like an overstatement, too, but it's not completely wrong. I read once that a German division ran on 200 tons of supply a day, and an American division on 700 tons. That led to American divisions having more food, fuel, and ammunition than German ones.

    • jcarmackdaddy 3 hours ago ago

      I disagree with your stance. China can leverage India to displace the technology sector growth which is the actual vanguard of the current US legacy in addition to defense spending. (and finance/service you mentioned)

      Geopolitically speaking that already seems to be happening and there is a leveraged Chinese-style censorship culture growing around it.

      If one didn't know better one would call it an entirely communist program.

  • dormento an hour ago ago

    There's tons of political nuance about this.

    China is poised to dominate the technology scenario in the not so far future, and there's not much the US can do but to keep the crosshair of public opinion on them. At the same time, American businesses are laying off en masse while seeking H1B and hiring overseas. It does not help that there are some pretty high profile south-Asian CEOs and CTOs, which ends up attracting even more scrutiny.

  • ferguess_k 3 hours ago ago

    I think the default is to treat everyone else as a thread-actor and then rank them. Then in propagation you only talk about those you want to target based on the current political climate.

  • AnimalMuppet 3 hours ago ago

    China has been threatening to conquer Taiwan, for years. They have been building up their military, for years, with the explicitly stated goal of being able to conquer Taiwan. I haven't heard of India doing anything like that.

    China has had their secret police bullying and threatening Chinese people abroad, trying to get them to support China's positions. I haven't heard of India doing anything like that.

    China has been using critical materials - rare earths - as a political weapon. I haven't heard of India doing anything like that (though perhaps from lack of opportunity).

    Notice the wording - "I haven't heard". I do not absolutely say that India is not doing such things. But if they are, it doesn't make the press out here.

    But for the above reasons, we don't trust China, or at least the Chinese government.

    And then, China's government seems to have control over Chinese companies when they want it, in a way that India doesn't. For that reason, we don't trust critical tech from Chinese companies, because we fear that it may abruptly become unavailable to us in a crisis.

    • dormento 35 minutes ago ago

      > I do not absolutely say that India is not doing such things. But if they are, it doesn't make the press out here.

      Just one of these things we become more aware the older/more experienced we get. One says "Pooh Bear/Tienanmen'89", the other says "Blue Star/Hyderabad'48". I'd say its the norm, as awful as it is, that a political regime has some skeletons in the closet.

      When I was a kid, the US were the "Leaders of the Free World". When I was a teen, I learned that some incredibly talented, rich people who acted in the movies that made me think of the US as heroes would drink themselves to stupor and eventually die due to substance abuse. As I got older, I understood why. The magic fades as you understand how the world works, how deals are made.

      In other words, now I understand that the reason I had uncharitable opinions on China for so long was not exactly because of the Chinese.

  • Henchman21 31 minutes ago ago

    People in the West still think of each and every Indian person as if they were the reincarnation of Ghandi. That is: non-violent. Which is absolutely absurd but here we are.

  • factorialboy 3 hours ago ago

    Meanwhile, Trump's imposing tariffs on India -while- sucking up to Xi and Putin.

  • krunck 3 hours ago ago

    Who are the allies and who are the scary communists?

    • muzani 3 hours ago ago

      That's a good question. China has always felt "scary capitalist" to me. In fact, much of the tension is because they're out-capitalizing the US.

      They're selling things for cheaper, making better technology, developing a prosperous middle class. They're making better progress with renewable energy and education. Dark factories are commonplace - they made 10x more industrial robot installations tuan US. BYD and Geely are dominating the EV market.

      But wait, they're communist? Does that mean communism works? That AI and dark factories aren't going to make people homeless?

      Allies is another interesting question. They were everyone's top trading partner for a while, but being friends with Russia/Iran and anti-Israel means they're probably not on the same side.