No Bailout for the AI Bubble, Anthropic IPO Protesters Say

(techpolicy.press)

33 points | by cdrnsf 5 hours ago ago

17 comments

  • joegibbs 2 hours ago ago

    Is there any evidence at all that they will need a bailout, or that the government has considered giving them one?

    • whateveracct 2 hours ago ago

      BAAJA is getting rammed through by a lame duck Congress, conveniently timed with the IPO..

  • ethnrob 4 hours ago ago

    > We have AI deciding medical outcomes and treatments in this country. Shame. Shame.

    What about cutting triage times for strokes, solving novel protein structures, or catching early-stage cancers? I'm not saying AI should be making final judgments on people's health, but this framing feels pretty one-sided.

    • mhitza 3 hours ago ago

      AI shouldn't be allowed to make decisions. Unless you want a more opaque future in which no corporate/state person is even responsible of negative outcomes "because computer says so".

    • nancyminusone 2 hours ago ago

      What about it? Should people be socially treated worse even if the medical treatment is better?

    • apercu 3 hours ago ago

      Capitalism- it’s not about health, it’s about novel ways to reject insurance claims.

      • tt24 3 hours ago ago

        Are insurance companies supposed to accept all claims without question? I don’t understand your view

        • unrented7977 27 minutes ago ago

          How do you feel about insurance companies denying and delaying in the hopes the patient dies before they have to pay for treatment?

        • mikestew 2 hours ago ago

          No one is saying that but you, I fail to understand how you got that out of OP's comment.

          • tt24 2 hours ago ago

            What’s wrong with finding novel ways to reject insurance claims?

        • mindslight an hour ago ago

          Valid claims for services performed by a licensed doctor on an insured patient, yes.

          If this is too much there is a simple way to avoid it, the way most everybody else does - don't write insurance policies that purport to cover people's medical issues.

          • tt24 an hour ago ago

            What makes a claim valid vs not? Who determines that?

            • unrented7977 26 minutes ago ago

              A licensed medical professional who has seen and laid hands on the patient. Not a bureaucrat or an algorithm.

              Nobody has any right to make decisions about a patient's healthcare other than their physician.

            • mindslight an hour ago ago

              Sorry, my sentence structure was a bit ambiguous. By "valid" I mean conforming to the two conditions I followed with.

              The licensed doctor is the one exercising judgement of whether a given treatment is medically prudent. An insurance company asserting that it is entitled to create its own medical opinion on which to deny care is sophistry. If the insurance company has a reason to believe that the doctor is violating their professional responsibilities, then the insurance company should take it up with the medical board.

              (I think our healthcare system needs much more wider sweeping reform than this, although I'm not predisposed towards single payer. My angle here is pointing out the corruption of the current system)

  • boshalfoshal 2 hours ago ago

    How are random protestors so easily able to identify a complex financial and economic bubble? Feels awfully presumptuous to claim this is a bubble already. It really does feel like two completely different worlds between being in a high tech company/area and the average American. These appear to be way too kneejerky and not actually attacking actual problems that powerful AI might lead to. Also what bailout are they referring to?

    To me, the utility promises of AI have basically been met. This technology basically obviates verticals of knowledge work that can be done at a computer, imo. Theres clearly utility here and the technology is not a bubble. Perhaps certain companies will go bust in the process, but pandoras box has been opened. There are far more pressing things to argue against than a "financial bubble" and "datacenter water usage," but I think these issues are way larger and more complex than a group of average people are going to platform.

    To paraphrase an anonymous openai employee on twitter: I think people want this to be a bubble because they are not emotionally prepared for the world where it isn't.

  • tt24 3 hours ago ago

    Have they asked for a bailout?

  • 999900000999 an hour ago ago

    Here’s what’s going to happen. They’ll keep expanding and over extending.

    Even when it becomes mathematically impossible to get a decent ROI. Then when it falls apart they’ll be declared a national security priority and get billions upon billions in tax payer money.

    You don’t want us to fall behind the COMMUNISTS do you. Thus to beat the communists we must become them. How much of Intel does the government own at this point ?