I've received a bunch of mailers from Amazon about this, as well as a seriously slanted phone survey with incredibly loaded questions.
Their claim is that if they need to pay their delivery people as if they were employees, they'd have to raise prices for everyone in order to pay for it.
How about they eat the US$20,000,000/annum or so to make sure their delivery people are treated like human beings. Which is 0.0014% of Amazon's 2025 net income (income, not revenue) from 2025[0].
Picking that up would have no real impact on shareholders, but could significantly improve the lives of their workers.
I'm pretty disgusted with how hard they're fighting this -- they're probably spending more to fight it than it would cost them to comply with the proposed law -- yuck!
>But isn't what they do a valid optimisation strategy within the system they operate?
I guess that depends on the definitions of "valid" and "optimisation" you want to use, yes?
From that perspective, I guess spending more money than such legislation would cost the company to block being forced to treat their service providers (who are, essentially, employees despite the "contract worker" fiction) from being treated like human employees to keep those uppity grunts in their place. Next they'll be trying to (gasp!) form unions and demand a living wage. The horror!
Which is really bad because the triple-damned gub'mint won't let them hire Pinkerton[0] to beat and kill anyone dumb enough to stand on a picket line any more. Sheesh! What has the world come to? /s
Title: Amazon fights the Delivery Protection Act with homepage banner, in-app pop-up (fits in submission limits)
True.
But I use my taste, I thought it was too long.
Did you think I was misleading? Not my intention
From the submission guidelines[0]:
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.htmlI've received a bunch of mailers from Amazon about this, as well as a seriously slanted phone survey with incredibly loaded questions.
Their claim is that if they need to pay their delivery people as if they were employees, they'd have to raise prices for everyone in order to pay for it.
How about they eat the US$20,000,000/annum or so to make sure their delivery people are treated like human beings. Which is 0.0014% of Amazon's 2025 net income (income, not revenue) from 2025[0].
Picking that up would have no real impact on shareholders, but could significantly improve the lives of their workers.
I'm pretty disgusted with how hard they're fighting this -- they're probably spending more to fight it than it would cost them to comply with the proposed law -- yuck!
[0] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AMZN/amazon/net-in...
I agree.
But isn't what they do a valid optimisation strategy within the system they operate?
>But isn't what they do a valid optimisation strategy within the system they operate?
I guess that depends on the definitions of "valid" and "optimisation" you want to use, yes?
From that perspective, I guess spending more money than such legislation would cost the company to block being forced to treat their service providers (who are, essentially, employees despite the "contract worker" fiction) from being treated like human employees to keep those uppity grunts in their place. Next they'll be trying to (gasp!) form unions and demand a living wage. The horror!
Which is really bad because the triple-damned gub'mint won't let them hire Pinkerton[0] to beat and kill anyone dumb enough to stand on a picket line any more. Sheesh! What has the world come to? /s
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_union_busting_in_th...