15 comments

  • zenincognito 7 hours ago ago

    Australian here. The problem is that there is not enough power for most of these to be run in suburban region for example the next DC data centre is right in the middle of a residential area see below.. They run generators day in day out running on diesel and they are not interested in anything but the IP and their stock price... https://www.google.com/maps/place/NEXTDC+Melbourne+Data+Cent...

    The effect of this is that the electiricty prices are soaring and the grid is simply not built for 2026. I run 10.5 KW solar on my roof and produce on some days upto 150KW per day and all of this is fed back in the grid and yet pay close to $200 per two months in electricity bills. This is because we dont get a rebate like we used to early on for solar. I barely use about 5KW per day. Supply charges are insane and we dont have enough labour and so everything is twice as expensive.

    • cavisne 6 hours ago ago

      Electricity prices have been soaring for decades in Australia, this was actually the first year in a long time they didn't go up (because the government pumped billions in battery rebates in).

      I do think its a shame they put dc's like the NextDC one near cities but its not exactly a "residential area". It's an industrial area right next to houses, and from satellite imagery has clearly always been that way. I doubt the pump factory it replaced was quite...

      • anenefan 4 hours ago ago

        Yes I'm sure feel for folks down south where their state was convinced to fully privatise the power grid. I don't care [1] what some people might try to prove or attest, but those folks I've known down in the Southern end (NSW, Vic and SA) once their network went private all I heard from time to time is how the power prices went though the roof. One day people will work out the private companies that do really well and can afford to buy up ready to go assets, didn't get there by being friendly and altruistic.

        I have heard at least 2 or 3 times (last I heard this was three years ago) that some of the private companies down south are claiming some customer's entire solar power output produced as their own - and their customer never sees a cent. Things may have changed but ... possibly it was one of the fly-by-night make a quick buck and exit type of profiteer.

        Yes and being near an industrial area isn't fun at times. Probably not a bright idea to move or buy into such an area for housing purposes. Sadly this is what people do, typically by near airports and then protest for the airport to move for the noise it makes. For a brief period I worked nearby a retreading business where the smell of burnt rubber permeated the area at times and there was little escape. I don't know what a data centre does for it's diesel generators, if the exhaust is scrubbed or just let loose, but many residents would be rightly uncomfortable with what they might have to expect in the years ahead.

        [1] https://www.uow.edu.au/the-stand/2022/should-australian-gove...

    • msuniverse2026 5 hours ago ago

      "we dont have enough labour"

      This is editorialisation of the issue and detracts from the rest of your anecdote.

  • linzhangrun 8 hours ago ago

    They should go build data centers in China, where centralized management and centralized power supply won't affect any residents (and residents won't even consider opposing it at all), lol

    • dhx 3 hours ago ago

      One of the main reasons for the hate is _this_ project will be the intended coal seam natural gas power source. Landowners cannot refuse to having injection and extraction wells drilled on their agricultural land and pipes and access roads installed. They do however get some financial reimbursement for the loss of amenity in the land and for messing up the aquifers more than agriculture was already responsible for[1]. Some landowners are on board with it all due to the extra income they earn from their land from wells but many are furious because they don't get a choice in the matter or much ability to negotiate.

      Take a look at Open Infrastructure Map which highlights the coal seam gas wells and electricity infrastructure in the region[2]. Look at visible imagery for an understanding of the _current_ scale of gas extraction and the impact it has on the landscape. It's approximately on par with environmental impacts of wind turbine installations throughout China if you ignore aquifer and carbon emission impacts.

      At least this project proposal has the benefit of placing data centres in proximity to electricity generators avoiding extra load on transmission lines (and towers) which towns and cities will need for household and private transport electrification. And it also avoids wasting high value land in close proximity to towns and cities for buildings that are mostly empty and which require people and infrastructure to waste time and resources routing around in daily life.

      [1] https://www.ogia.water.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/000...

      [2] https://openinframap.org/#10.72/-27.2259/150.9398/A,B,L,O,P

    • undefined 6 hours ago ago
      [deleted]
    • cavisne 6 hours ago ago

      Thats why much of this opposition is directly funded by China. One minute we are meant to be bringing manufacturing & technology back to Australia, next we cant build a warehouse full of computers in the middle of nowhere with a few air conditioning units.

      • sivakon 5 hours ago ago

        > Thats why much of this opposition is directly funded by China

        Can you provide a source for this statement?

        • simianwords 4 hours ago ago

          Its not. DC opposition is very organic. The problem is that it is framed as a water/electricity problem. But this is just a facade for the real grievance that is people hate the tech industry, capitalism and its leaders.

          • anenefan 3 hours ago ago

            In Australia though while a number of people don't like the idea of LLMs, there really is an issue with water and electricity ... it's also no mystery and many would be aware what's occurring in the US, with big tech being well flushed taking the lion's share of the power at times and power prices being thrust upwards. Fewer here would be aware that in at least one region in the US - a local grid was told they've had to go shopping for power from elsewhere as their usual power supplier was now fully committed to a data centre company.

            I expect that in reality water could be recycled, cooling towers if not using heat recapture so it wouldn't be a great issue once the data park was up and running - the area around Dalby can get awful dry, if there was no water recycling, I doubt it would be viewed as tenable. The noise is they will be aiming to use air cooling or some such ... that would be interesting to see pan out.

      • defrost 6 hours ago ago

        > Thats why much of this opposition is directly funded by China.

        Cool. Where can I apply, what's the contact number, and how much an hour can I get for protesting?

      • anenefan 5 hours ago ago

        "The site, 37km north-west of Dalby, is currently home to a 24,000-head feedlot owned by Wambo Cattle Company." [1]

        I doubt China is funding opposition to this proposed digital park. I do suspect it's the loss of jobs from the local area and the realisation by residents they would slowly be displaced and would-need-to-relocate if they wanted to enjoy a similar lifestyle to what they enjoy currently.

        Also I suspect some who complained are just representative of the ground swell against LLM data farms and what use of A.I. represents.

        Though I don't think it's a factor - a smaller part in whining when a rural farm is sold and bought with another farming purpose, such as forestry occurs when typically that market had been quickly squeezed perhaps manipulated in order for the big boys of the industry to swoop in and snag a deal - and they are not very happy when they miss out they vent, call the media and rant and ...

        [1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-08-24/plans-for-australia-l...

        Edit near hour later -- brain dead proof reading I read in what I thought I wrote not what I actually wrote added - would-need-to-relocate - removed an orphan word

  • feverzsj 7 hours ago ago

    95% of Australia is uninhabited and they still choose to annoying human.

    • dzhiurgis 2 hours ago ago

      Ah yes, put them where there is no infrastructure.