Why do tech leaders sound so illogical and off-putting?

(theatlantic.com)

77 points | by pseudolus 3 hours ago ago

100 comments

  • mark_l_watson 2 hours ago ago

    I think it is simply that some people are overwhelmed by some false illusion of their self importance. Love and kindness are the foundations of a happy and contented life, but people get caught up in their own life dramas and don’t think much of other people. I have worked at large stable companies (SAIC/Leidos), Google, Capital One, etc. and there is more of a sense of reality: people come to work to do a job. I have also worked at or helped many startups and usually it seems like it is some ego trip to save the world, or some other such nonsense.

    I don’t mean to be picking on anyone but there are tech leaders currently in the news that I don’t respect at all.

    • adriand 2 hours ago ago

      > Love and kindness are the foundations of a happy and contented life

      Thank you for saying this. It’s been on my mind a lot since the revelations of Huang’s affairs. When I saw a picture of his wife, who looks like a charming and nerdy woman who also looks her age, and then saw photos of the people he’s been sleeping with (younger, more attractive) it was rather heartbreaking. Building a company is incredibly absorbing. But when we are in our darkest moments - ill, or on our deathbeds, or after the loss of someone we love - it is not going to be the company who gives us comfort. It is going to be the wife or husband who has been with us through thick and thin.

      Or not, because we betrayed that person, so they left. Because we forgot that “love and kindness are the foundations of a happy and contented life”.

      • Eddy_Viscosity2 an hour ago ago

        Also know that the reason that some (not all) men pursue wealth and fame and power in the first place is specifically so that hot younger women will sleep with them.

        Not to downplay your point, which I do agree with, but the "men seeking power/fame/wealth for access to women, and women being attracted to mean who have power/fame/wealth" paradigm seems persistent across time and cultures. It could just be the way we are built.

      • kajumix an hour ago ago

        I don't mean to be cynical, but men with means, money and power have access to a bigger diversity and availability of potential mates, and they act like how you'd expect male animals to do. You and I are not above the reproductive impulse. Given the means, almost all of us will give in to it. In some non-western cultures (and in the pre-feminism west), wife and mistress roles co-exist without the drama. Not defending it, just observing.

    • bigDinosaur 2 hours ago ago

      Love and kindness may well be the ingredients to a happy life, but in general the people who change things and many of the most innovative or noteworthy people were driven by far more than love and kindness. In many ways we benefit from the obsessions that others have towards their work - and when they become too visible it's like seeing the sausage being made. There was no era where the people at the top of business or government were as a rule kind and loving.

    • dkrich 2 hours ago ago

      Right and over the past few years there’s been this herd movement where they all feed off each other and enforce each other’s egos. Like a club they all self selected into and they are astonishingly single minded and all agree on the same ideas, the latest to bring Jensen back and before that a list too long to recall. DHH, Tobi Lutke have been two of the most insufferable. Difficult to watch this transformation as DHH was someone who I held in extremely high regard. But money and fame does change people as they age. And to be clear my issues with these guys are not political, it’s really the boredom and single-mindedness that’s depressing. We seem to not really have any true leaders at the moment. Everyone is grifting and offering overhyped products and things that will never be released. Possibly signs that the tech revolution of the past 30-40 years has reached its maturity phase for now and nobody knows where to go next.

      • cowlevel 2 hours ago ago

        The club has a name, or a few: Effective Altruism, TESCREAL.

        I heard about two thirds of current congressional staffers are Effective Altruists, because EA prioritised seeking access to the levers of power.

        • codingdave 2 hours ago ago

          EA is a movement, not an organization. TESCREAL is not either, it is just a term.

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism

          • cowlevel an hour ago ago

            That's correct, the club (the big one, that you ain't in) isn't a formal organisation.

        • TacticalCoder 2 hours ago ago

          These EA motherfuckers are all but all altruists. They're downright scammers and thieves.

          They now made a TV series on SBF. The goal of it is obviously to paint this EA motherfucker as a victim so that as soon as the president changes, he'll get presidential pardon (one good thing Trump did is refusing SBF the presidential pardon).

          Shame on all those despicable, scheming, evil people.

        • dkrich an hour ago ago

          It does give me hope that there are so many who recognize the absurdity of the current period because the media fawns over so many totally mediocre people who, while amassing great wealth have not really done anything that’s that life changing. Creating Shopify is cool but you ain’t Thomas Edison. I think most of this movement can be explained by founders trying to emulate Elon musk

  • pseudolus 3 hours ago ago
  • beloch 2 hours ago ago

    "Tech executives are failing at politics for the same reason they’re struggling among regular Americans: They’ve been so monomaniacally focused on winning the AI race that they’ve ignored everything else, including the need to build consensus or even a baseline of enthusiasm for their plans."

    ...

    "This is what happens when the bet becomes so big—when the industry is so full of financial, geopolitical, and existential risk—that it creates its own warped logic. It transforms human innovation from a worthy ambition to an inexorable force and, finally, into something akin to a hostage situation. To stop now, Silcon Valley’s leaders argue, would mean losing not merely the future, but also the present. We’re committed to whatever happens next; nothing is more important than driving forward, and no price is too steep."

    ----------

    When you owe the bank a million dollars and you can't pay, it's your problem. When you owe the bank a trillion dollars and you can't pay, it's the bank's problem.

    When a corporation screws up a little bit, they might have to pay a settlement (depending on the quality of their laywers). When an AI corporation causes a catastrophe, they disappear in a cloud of golden parachutes and debt. The problem then belongs to everyone.

    This is the fundamental reason why tech executives have lost the political fight and why their heedless advance is a problem. They are making bets that the public is already being called upon to back while the potential gains remain theoretical. Like a bank limiting borrowing to protect itself, perhaps the public needs to limit the bets tech execs are permitted to make.

  • jpatten 43 minutes ago ago

    I think part of it is the financial ecosystem of Silicon Valley rewards founders who present their work as world-changing. People get excited about working at, funding or otherwise being a part of something that's going to change the world, so founders learn to frame their work in that way.

  • bshepard 2 hours ago ago

    Why do journalists constantly scapegoat? What power does it give to to them to insult ‘tech leaders’? What are the consequences of decades of journalistic alarmism?

    • BLKNSLVR an hour ago ago

      Have you not used the internet in the last 15 years?

      • bshepard an hour ago ago

        Yes and am tired of this dumbed down quasi evil bullshit from self interested journalists who regard themselves as tribunes of the people.

    • Vasbarlog 2 hours ago ago

      Think of the billionaires!

      • bshepard an hour ago ago

        Yes, they are humans too. Just because scapegoating feels good doesn’t make it right. To scapegoat also hurts your soul.

  • BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago ago

    They're fucked in the head by their singular obsession over their company's success because nothing else could possibly be as important to humanity. IQ, for whatever it's worth, is more likely part of the problem. At a certain point, an increase in IQ comes with an equivalent decrease in EQ (edited to add: I should have said that this is based on my own experience and is therefore anecdata only, apologies for implying that this was any kind of established science, it is categorically not).

    Perverse incentives and a lack of ability to regulate emotion or empathise with 'common folk'. They should never, ever be unmanaged leaders, much less spokespeople.

    There is definitely a brilliance to them, but they'll all fly too close to the sun without some force that keeps them tethered to reality, no matter how they struggle to divorce from it.

    • roromainmain 2 hours ago ago

      >>"IQ, for whatever it's worth, is more likely part of the problem. At a certain point, an increase in IQ comes with an equivalent decrease in EQ"

      Where do you get this from? I am not aware of any study pointing in this direction. See (1).

      What I experienced is people with strong analytical abilities tending to intellectualize conflicts or situations instead of experiencing them, but with the proper psychotherapy/coaching it changes rapidly.

      On the other end, the system itself incentivize for leaders to be jerks, no matter how high or low their IQ. That's where regulation and laws come into place.

      (1)"Emotional intelligence in gifted and non-gifted individuals: A systematic review with meta-analysis" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016028962...?

    • dhbradshaw 2 hours ago ago

      Imagine that EQ and IQ have a mild positive correlation.

      Imagine also that both are helpful in achieving success in a given endeavor.

      Success then becomes a filter that leads to a negative correlation because a high EQ can compensate for a low IQ and vice versa. So even though they are positively correlated in general they can become negatively correlated among those who achieve success in a particular area.

      Same effect for school. Smarts and athleticism can be positively correlated in general but if you need at least one or the other to get into school that filter or selection effect can mean that among those who got into the school they are negatively correlated.

    • BSPtree 2 hours ago ago

      I don't think EQ and IQ correlate negatively, but are distinct and the two are loosely related. Though I agree that specialized intelligence does not immediately translate to EQ. I also agree with your other statements about CEO's. People often forget, because they are immensely successful at something, that CEO's are at the heart, human; and are or could be potentially lacking in any other areas of life. Such as EQ, and thus empathy!

    • trimethylpurine 2 hours ago ago

      Comments on empathy are best served empathetically.

      • BLKNSLVR an hour ago ago

        Hahaha, you're absolutely right and my delivery was wrong.

        Having said that, I voluntarily, consciously have little to no sympathy or empathy for those who have both almost unlimited resources and little to no empathy.

        They seem, to me, like subsidised sociopaths. Hence my rude enmity.

        What I will say is that, were I not married, I would have likely become untethered, not due to any unusual level of intelligence and definitely not because of unlimited resources, but just because I could get caught up in my own ideas in my own head for too long, without the necessary cynicism of reality to maintain the tether.

    • larsonian 5 minutes ago ago

      I find it incredibly ironic how often the very same people calling Silicon Valley unempathetic nerds with no EQ display very little ability to consider things from the point of view of others without necessarily accepting it themselves (i.e. empathy).

      Take the gotcha the article starts out with: "if Anthropic believes AI carries existential risk, why are they making AI?". Anyone who has even a passing familiarity with the subject knows the answer: they think it's inevitable, so our best hope for a good outcome is that someone who takes AI safety seriously gets there first (i.e. them). The author clearly is familiar with the argument too, but offers no explanation as to why he thinks it's "illogical" beyond "well, I think you're just hypocrites who like money".

      Why is Amodei writing about "pacing the frontier" while raising money to push it further? Again, because it's going to happen with them or without them, and disarmament only works when everyone agrees to it. Otherwise all you can do is build your stockpile and hope it deters the others.

      Maybe these are bad arguments, sure. But the article makes no attempt to argue this point. We're just asked to take the author on his word that they're "illogical". The closest thing to a counterargument seems to be "look, Jacob Coxon is a hypocrite". Well, OK. That's not going to be very persuasive to anyone who is convinced of the "winner-takes-all" logic. So what's the point, again? "Look at the funny nerds and laugh at them"? How very empathetic.

    • undefined 2 hours ago ago
      [deleted]
  • Telemakhos 3 hours ago ago

    The illogical, off-putting bits fade away when you assume tech leaders are lying to make money. AI doomerism from AI giants coupled with enthusiastic development of supposedly destructive technology makes sense if you assume the doomerism is a stance calculated to trigger regulation and regulatory capture that restricts AI to SaaS AI giants who want to be able to rent to you instead of letting you run open weight models.

    • red75prime 2 hours ago ago

      What's your thoughts on vulnpocalypse, mathpocalypse? Or I'd rather say which strategy did you choose to ignore them?

      The development of "supposedly destructive technology" could also continue if the destruction isn't inevitable and the potential benefits outweigh the risks.

    • ahartmetz an hour ago ago

      Nit: the illogical fades away, the off-putting stays.

    • jordanb 2 hours ago ago

      Yes this is it! I listen to the All In podcast mostly to hear what the techno-chud hive mind is thinking, since they're all on group chats together. If you listen long enough it becomes obvious that they're all talking their own books all the time.

      You could even tell when they were getting cut into the Anthropic IPO because they switched from constant criticism to constant praise.

  • origini 2 hours ago ago

    This article itself assumes that the same people advocating for Nvidia are the same people and is the same thing as Anthropics 'behaviour'.

    Is it that you need to have a certain amount of intelligence to be able to keep two conflicting opinions in a reasonable fashion in. your head?

    Why would a person throw away their OpenAI shares just because they quit OpenAI and are warning about the danger?

    They are happily aware that they are in a construct in which this is not irrational, a model collapse or stupid.

    I'm an idealistic person too and I advocate for helping everyone and I also don't throw away my money. I can do both I can advocate for it and be ready when i realize that we as a society are moving in the direction and i can keep my self preservation strategy too.

    • undefined 42 minutes ago ago
      [deleted]
    • BoxOfRain 2 hours ago ago

      > Why would a person throw away their OpenAI shares just because they quit OpenAI and are warning about the danger?

      Credibility for the most part, if I'm telling everyone that climate change will be the single worst driver of war, famine, and general misery we have ever visited on ourselves why would anyone believe me if I had Shell, BP, and Exxon shares? You would quite reasonably say 'he can't take climate change that seriously if he's invested in the sector instigating it' and I'd have no reply to that. Being invested in something isn't a morally neutral act, it's a declaration that you morally licence whatever it is you've invested in.

      Anyone can have principles when it enriches them, but in my opinion a principle is only worth anything if you can stick to it despite it making you poorer.

      • origini an hour ago ago

        I can still easily argue with a necessity in a system which doesn't believe me.

        I might need a car, i might not be able to afford an EV, so I'm bound by society which doesn't listen to me.

        And we know how people think about other people being more 'radical': they are ignored so we know the impact is small.

        Credibility shoulud come from the logic itself, if people don't believe your logic and logic is not enough, you have lost already anyway

  • undefined 2 hours ago ago
    [deleted]
  • moishe_syzslak an hour ago ago

    Because we'd love to trade places with them.

    • swed420 an hour ago ago

      > Because we'd love to trade places with them.

      Speak for yourself. That amount of wealth and all of the interpersonal relationship problems that come with it sounds like a nightmare.

  • varispeed 3 hours ago ago

    If something is not clear, then it is always about money. Most people also are unable to follow logic, so these explanations don't sound illogical. They are just explanations about something most people don't understand anyway. What counts is appearance, how someone is dressed and whether they smile. A few keywords here and there and creation of feel good vibe. The information itself is irrelevant.

    • BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago ago

      Power.

      Learn the lessons of Scarface. Past a certain point, money becomes essentially meaningless in it's trade for power. Elon spent how much on the Texas midterms? An amount that could make a massive difference to the lives of a large number of people. And it made almost no difference to his total wealth.

      We're past following the money, we need to follow the power. If Jensen can be removed from his position of power (which was arguably the highest position of all the tech bros), then they all can. And that's something they don't want to face.

      Reinstall Jensen, because without him it might all fall apart. Same as if they remove Sam or Dario or Elon or Larry or Zuck or Bezos. They need to be protected from any and all consequences of their actions! For the sake of all mankind!

      Fragile little egos.

      • BoxOfRain an hour ago ago

        I would argue that money and power, like the fundamental forces, become increasingly difficult to separate at high concentrations. There's not really such thing as a politically neutral billionaire, just that much wealth existing in one place inherently attracts political behaviour from elsewhere. Their economic position can never be politically neutral even if they're personally disinterested, which they usually aren't.

        Republics shouldn't have private princes in my view.

  • bloopernova 2 hours ago ago

    I've wondered recently whether the Great Filter that prevents humanity from becoming a galactic species is not that space travel is hard. Instead, it's possible that we as a group are too easily misled by misinformation. That the lie can get around the world before the truth has time to lace up its shoes.

    Similarly, these executive class people live in a world soaked in misinformation. Their misinfo comes from their lack of pushback and criticism from others for various reasons, like being afraid of the power to fire anyone. Very much like a too-sycophantic LLM like the article suggests.

    Maybe if we had a few thousand years to let our brains adapt to not trusting anything, we might be OK.

    • jareklupinski 2 hours ago ago

      we still have a billion or so years before the sun explodes; plenty of time :)

      • svachalek 2 hours ago ago

        The sun won't explode unless we make it, and if it's on us we'd probably do it as quickly as possible.

  • lijok 3 hours ago ago

    Because you’re not the target audience. Effective communication is tailored to the audience. You wouldn’t inject yourself into the kitchen of a tasting restaurant and accuse the chefs of sounding unhinged.

    • blitzar 2 hours ago ago

      I doubt the chefs are talking about poisoning their patrons, either quietly or out loud

    • soco 2 hours ago ago

      I'm a bit bothered with comparing the techbros with fine cuisine. They are rather the mafia-owned pizza place. But you're right, one wouldn't get to accuse these either.

  • karahime 2 hours ago ago

    I think it's Atlantic writers who are "illogical and offputting". This is like the fifth time they've written this article and it has barely more value than "Look at those weirdos, eh, eh?"

    • rpastuszak 2 hours ago ago

      > "Look at those weirdos, eh, eh?"

      Honestly this is a pretty good reason to have more articles like this -- shame is a useful social tool if applied correctly.

    • ForHackernews 2 hours ago ago

      Consider that the normies might be right? Maybe we don't want a millenarianist cult ru[i]nning the economy.

  • xyzsparetimexyz 3 hours ago ago

    It's an in-group signal like a shibboleth. Similar to buccal fat removal or 'bogging'. If you don't get it, you're not in the club.

    • cyanydeez 2 hours ago ago

      I think this explains most of the detachment of modern society. Pre internet, mobile phone, etc, the billionaires had to have some level of interaction with the local rabble.

      Now, they can colude among themselves wherever which disconnects them from any potential scrutiny.

      We talk about social media bubbles while they're basically building the golden dome of reach around politics and beliefs.

      • undefined 2 hours ago ago
        [deleted]
      • adrianN 2 hours ago ago

        At what point did the ultra rich interact with the rabble at all? I can’t think of any point in the past where the interaction was different from ordering serfs around.

        • svnt 2 hours ago ago

          It’s more the other part: the rate of interaction among them. There were no exclusively billionaire signal groups.

          • adrianN an hour ago ago

            Weren’t they visiting each other for tea and meet at the club etc all the time?

      • xyzsparetimexyz 15 minutes ago ago

        I'm not really sure that's true. In the past you could be a billionaire on your estate and not interact with anyone except your hunting and/or golf buddies. Nowadays you have elon getting egged-on/ragebaited/influenced on twitter.

  • amelius 3 hours ago ago

    Tech leaders are just a reflection of what VCs want to see.

    • dgellow 3 hours ago ago

      There is a push/pull dynamic, it’s not a pure reflection

  • Marha01 2 hours ago ago

    > Last week, many of the industry’s top minds engaged in Olympic-level mental gymnastics as they defended the former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s affairs: We must excuse his dalliances with two employees and an alleged Chinese spy, they argued, not just because Huang is absolutely necessary to the American economy, which is being propped up by AI investment, but because we are in a geopolitical superintelligence race with China.

    Maybe I am a "tech CEO", but I don't see how this is illogical, or mental gymnastics? If you believe that there is this all-important superintelligence race, and that Jensen Huang has very unique expertise that is necessary for the US to succeed in this race, then it is entirely logical to suggest that some of his past transgressions should perhaps be glossed over in the service of the greater good. Just like the transgressions of Nazi rocket scientists were glossed over, in order to advance US rocket science.

    You might argue that such position is immoral, but not that it is illogical or "mental gymnastics".

    >Then this week, Anthropic, the company most vocally obsessed with the existential risk of AI, went public in an effort to raise $90 billion so that it could speed up construction of the very same systems it’s warning us about.

    Again, a very simple and logical explanation: Anthropic thinks that superintelligence is inevitable: sooner or later, someone will develop it. If this is true, then it is better if that ASI developer is a risk-obsessed company, instead of someone more reckless, or someone unaligned with the western concept of morality and human rights. The position is not about entirely avoiding the risk (that is impossible), but minimizing the risk, and maximizing the potential benefit (Dario Amodei is definitely not a pure doomer).

    • adrianN 2 hours ago ago

      If you believe in all the ifs, then it follows I suppose. But it’s a lot of assumptions with varying levels of argument behind them.

      • Meneth 2 hours ago ago

        > There was an AI made of dust

        > Whose poetry gained it man's trust

        > If "is" follows "ought"

        > It'll do what they thought

        > In the end we all do what we must

      • Marha01 2 hours ago ago

        Perhaps. It's pretty much what Dario Amodei believes, based on his published blogs.

    • amcsi an hour ago ago

      The fact that Jensen knowingly sold video cards (or access to thereof) indirectly to China makes the argument for Huang being necessary to the "American" economy invalid.

      • Marha01 an hour ago ago

        That is a non-sequitur. It's like claiming that Wernher von Braun was not important for the US rocket program, just because he helped the Nazis before.

    • komali2 2 hours ago ago

      > you believe that there is this all-important superintelligence race, and that Jensen Huang has very unique expertise that is necessary for the US to succeed in this race,

      Logic and ethics were both studied together by philosophers for a reason. "If I point a gun at someone, they do what I say," for example, is very logical, but also unethical.

      So what's missing from your premise is that the AGI race is important, and why it matters why the control of AGI should be in the hands of a given State or corporation.

      Outside of ethics I think it's also a questionable premise that Jensen is somehow uniquely experienced compared to some of the other senior engineers at his company, or other folks in the chip industry. Or the idea that the CEO as an individual is somehow the lynchpin of the operation and irreplaceable. It's just one guy.

    • Eisenstein 2 hours ago ago

      Your points are addressed, I think:

      > Some see this as a sophisticated form of argumentation, one that can eschew conventional morality (by risking rogue-AI swarm hacks or worse) for a greater purpose (achieving a technological utopia). Samuel argues that the hyperrational thinking deployed by these leaders is overly clever. “Commonsense morality is actually often commonsense for a reason,” she told me recently. “And that’s because it tracks intuitions. Usually, reasoning like ‘If you don’t want a doom machine, don’t build a doom machine’ tends to be good reasoning.”

      The argument seems to be that logical thinking that eschews intuition does not serve humanity past a certain point. That once you go beyond a common-sense morality in order to justify a hyperrational goal, you have skipped what normally compels people to stop before it gets too dangerous. That pursuing a goal can become an end in its own right, and that stepping back and judging from an intuitive perspective can bring a level of proportionality that was missing.

      That's my understanding, anyway.

      • Marha01 2 hours ago ago

        > “Commonsense morality is actually often commonsense for a reason,” she told me recently. “And that’s because it tracks intuitions. Usually, reasoning like ‘If you don’t want a doom machine, don’t build a doom machine’ tends to be good reasoning.”

        This entire argument hinges on the assumption that those people actually believe that AI is primarily a "doom machine". If they are not pure doomers, then it does not apply.

        I think that most AI company leaders, even at Anthropic, are not such pure doomers. They don't view AI as a "doom machine", they just think that there is some possibility of doom, but also of other, better outcomes. Like nuclear energy. You can warn about the risks of nuclear energy, while still supporting responsible nuclear development.

    • BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago ago

      For staters, it's a justification of their messiah complex; that everything hinges on the one person at the helm of the company. If Jensen is expendable, then they all are. That's not a narrative they want anyone to follow.

      The funny thing about it is that, if the whole thing haha apart as a result of a single person being removed from the board then, good God damn, the whole thing is so fragile that inevitably something else, even relatively trivial, will bring it down.

      Also gives enemies a pretty good set of targets to remove if their will to win is strong enough.

      On your second point, wanting to be the first to build the Torment Nexus so that we beat our enemies to building it, is just a little bit insane. What isn't proven, and where you're closer to being right, is that maybe it's not the Torment Nexus.

      What I will say that isn't 'fair' (and you're within your rights to say "boo-hoo, complain to the market") is their total domination of the RAM and GPU and other markets, to the detriment of all is tech folk consumers.

      I think I've said it here before: thank fuck that a single AI company doesn't need to lock up the use of 40% of the oxygen in Earth's atmosphere for next year (refer Spaceballs for that scenario).

      • Marha01 2 hours ago ago

        > What I will say that isn't 'fair' (and you're within your rights to say "boo-hoo, complain to the market") is their total domination of the RAM and GPU and other markets, to the detriment of all is tech folk consumers.

        This is a valid point. But, there is also a good counterargument: if someone truly believes that AI will solve serious diseases, or bring other comparable benefits to humanity, then making RAM and GPUs expensive for a few years is an acceptable price to pay. Human lives > RAM prices.

        • BLKNSLVR an hour ago ago

          I believe my company will solve all the ills of the world if I was given essentially unlimited resources.

          outstretches entitled hand towards world

          More serious answer: why are we allowing plebs to spend tokens on all the bullshit we're seeing on YouTube and linked to on HN rather than limiting this incredibly precious resource to only noble pursuits? They're owning the market and then renting a limited version of it back to us at a very inflated price.

          There's no moral argument to hide behind here.

          • larsonian 2 minutes ago ago

            Because selling access to not-quite-there AI allows them to earn money to continue developing their AI to the point where it does reach the inflection point. Anthropic's "moral argument" is "we must get there first, lest someone who takes AI safety less seriously will". Of course they will seek all possible means to do so.

  • bemtevi 2 hours ago ago

    Because they are rich pricks, basically. Tech leader is just another type of narcissistic wealthy person, an unfortunate disease of modern society.

  • perching_aix 3 hours ago ago

    > in Olympic-level mental gymnastics as they defended the former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s affairs: We must excuse his dalliances with two employees and an alleged Chinese spy, they argued, not just because Huang is absolutely necessary to the American economy, which is being propped up by AI investment, but because we are in a geopolitical superintelligence race with China.

    There is absolutely no mental gymnastics involved here, nor is this any illogical. Off-putting sure, but nothing about this is illogical. It's about as basic of a conundrum as it gets, and it was clear as day this was going to be a point of tension right from the get go. That's why it made such big news in the first place even.

    I really despise when people try to dress up their grievances and reframe them as matters of logic. The persistent group-identity profiling is hardly the mark of good faith reasoning either. Can't imagine the rest of this article being any more worthy of anyone's time.

    • watwut 2 hours ago ago

      >There is absolutely no mental gymnastics involved here, nor is this any illogical.

      If you are in super important geopolitical with China, Jensen conspiring in a smuggling ring is a traitor and helping the enemy. You have to pick up one - Jensen thing is nothingburger or we are in that geopolitical race.

      • Marha01 2 hours ago ago

        Except from now on, Jensen (if reinstated as CEO) will be under a very close scrutiny. There is no reason to think that he would be able to smuggle any more chips to China (if he even did so in the past, which is still not proven).

        • watwut 2 hours ago ago

          Jensen, if reinstated as CEO, will conclude he is indeed invulnerable, unaccountable and can do as he pleases. If he goes back, his behavior will get worst in all aspects.

          • Marha01 2 hours ago ago

            > If he goes back, his behavior will get worst in all aspects.

            Then he will be removed again, and could even end up in prison.

        • komali2 2 hours ago ago

          The opposite conclusion should be drawn - he knows he's under scrutiny, so he'll be more careful. He already indicated a lack of loyalty to the USA or Taiwan in stead of a loyalty to profit, why would getting caught have changed that?

        • blitzar 2 hours ago ago

          Giving a dog a treat when it pisses on the sofa is a sure way to stop them from pissing on the sofa ...

      • poszlem 2 hours ago ago

        There are good reasons to think that embargoing China will help it's own chip industry to get stronger instead of weaker, and that keeping them dependent on the western chips is the better idea. You don't have to be a Chinese spy to see that.

        • watwut 2 hours ago ago

          China can not buy chips or force its companies to not buy chips whenever it thinks it would be their advantage. Not allowing them to do something is not giving them any additional advantage.

  • jmyeet an hour ago ago

    I'm reminded of a (very old at this point) xkcd [1] because this whole thing has French Revolution 2.0 written all over it, meaning this whole thing is way more fragile than I think these "tech leaders" think it is. A guillotine or two and burning down the odd warehouse will remain surprisingly effective, just like the xkcd wrench.

    To start, Effective Altruism is complete BS. Somewhere around the Ayn Rand era an idea set into American culture that hyper-selfishness was somehow a virtue. To me, EA is the next version of that. the people who have the most power and have amassed the most wealth now see those as necessary steps to doing the most good except that good never arrives and they were going to do that anyway. It just tells the greediest, most narcissistic people that those traits are good actually.

    Once again, this isn't a technical problem or even a political one. It's an economic problem. There are two basic ways the AI revolution can go.

    1. It allows a handful of people to amass an unimaginable amount of wealth while society collapses around them as people are laid off, underpaid and/or permanently unemployed as there simply aren't jobs for them. There is no shortage of dystopian sci-fi about such a future; or

    2. Society can own and benefit from the collective good and labor displacement from AI so you only have to, say, work 10-20 hours a week (if at all). Considering that AI is trained on the collective output of humanity, some would consider this more than fair.

    These two ends of the spectrum can be succinctly and accurately described as "capitalism" and "socialism", respectively. Guess which one we seem to be choosing?

    In the short to medium term in the West the social welfare state will crumble. There won't be money for anything except for the police and the military, you know, to create "order" as society frays. And it will probably get incredibly violent, particularly in the US where there are more guns than people.

    So why do tech leaders sound so off-putting and illogical? Easy. Because they're try to uphold and unsustainable (IMHO) system that will allow them to amass unimaginable wealth at the expense of everybody else. They are actively spreading harm. And the best they can hope for is we end up in a world of trillionaire estates where the only jobs are working on such estates, at least until the robots come for those jobs too.

    [1]: https://xkcd.com/538/

  • jcarmackdaddy 2 hours ago ago

    [dead]

  • SivaKernx 2 hours ago ago

    [flagged]

  • PaulHoule 3 hours ago ago

    It’s been that way a long time, at least since the mid 2000’s. Part of Zuck’s origin story was getting brushed off by pharma-over-alles VCs in the Boston area and going to SV which was one of only two places that has a time when they’d fund social media sites. Or you could look at Mozilla that can’t find any ambitions than being a woke Chrome. At some point SV decided they were right about everything and won’t listen to anybody.

  • freddealmeida 3 hours ago ago

    [flagged]

    • codingdave 3 hours ago ago

      That may be the most elitist thing I've read in a while. The differences between the smartest people and the average person are not as huge as all that. Average people are not incapable of complex thought. Smart people are not a different species. IQ tests are just a score, not a measure of capability.

    • f646993e074382f 2 hours ago ago

      Thanks a lot for a great Friday afternoon laugh.

    • rf15 3 hours ago ago

      You are obsessing over IQ as if its a serious metric...

    • kristopolous 3 hours ago ago

      oh what's the brilliant ideas?

      A taxi service that uses your own car? Renting scooters and leaving them on sidewalks? An app for food delivery? Renting out an extra bedroom? Scrabble with friends? An app to share photos? Alright.

      Btw, scientists, researchers, scholars, academics, these are salaried positions. Manhattan Project, Alan Turing, Albert Einstein, Claude Shannon...all salary. Apollo Program, CERN, people at the LHC...

    • ozgrakkurt 3 hours ago ago

      Saying tech CEOs have higher IQ than people they employ is a very bold statement.

      • Hugsbox 2 hours ago ago

        It's like when people talk about what a genius Elon is for all of "his" accomplishments. His accomplishments being; sitting around doing ketamine while real engineers actually make shit happen.

    • brettermeier 3 hours ago ago

      As if all those guys are super high intelligent... sometimes its just luck or inheritance.

    • combobyte 3 hours ago ago

      "No salaried person can understand complex ideas"

      What a crock of shit.