The Market Is Down

(anihil.com)

70 points | by anihil 4 hours ago ago

54 comments

  • mgdev 3 hours ago ago

    It's never been easier to start a business.

    It's never been safer to walk down the street that you live on.

    It's never been easier to build grand works, larger than any single person could have built, just 100 years ago, 10 years ago, 4 years ago, 2 years ago.

    This is creative destruction in action. This has happened with every major technical innovation for the past 200 years.

    We're all still here.

    What seems to change is we all have a shared narrative of what life should be like. And that shared narrative is wrong. Kids don't have to be expensive. Housing doesn't have to be expensive. Some of the things we think of as staples might actually be luxuries.

    But people don't want to move to small towns, even though they would gladly accept them. People don't want to go without the latest gadget, even though they don't need it. People don't need to go on luxury vacations. That's an idea that has only recently become mainstream among the middle class.

    I'm not trying to make a case for stoicism, but I do think our measure of what success looks like is awfully broken. People in the United States, in particular, got drunk on the excess that comes from being the world's reserve currency. We expect a lot for very little input.

    Jimmy Carr often says, "Happiness is your current situation minus expectations" and I think it rings very true.

    • moribvndvs 2 hours ago ago

      It’s never been easier, it’s never been safer, if you’re already privileged. I’ll probably hear next about how even the worst off have it better than in the past, and that may be true to an extent. It rings pretty hollow, though, when you’re grinding along the bottom or struggling to keep above water in the middle, while you and your family’s prospects dwindle and the privileged relative few absorb everything with no end and no compunction. The system requires money to survive, you get money through being productive and valuable in some way, and the system shows little sign of changing that arrangement meaningfully, all the while that same system lavishly rewards those at the top for minimizing if not removing you from the equation entirely. That’s extermination without direct violence. Extolling the virtues of austerity while the elite crush the life out of the world’s inhabitants with their immense, ever-expanding weight offers little in the way of succor. AI could maybe be used to free us, but it is instead being used by the current degenerate social order to anesthetize us before sending us off to the glue factory. They are the ones that expect too much and are drunk on excess, not us.

      • mgdev an hour ago ago

        If you're on this site, you're privileged.

        > The system requires money to survive, you get money through being productive and valuable in some way

        The system requires consumers to survive. Yes, money is a proxy for value exchange. The system would survive without money (we'd find another proxy) but not consumers. At some point, enough people opt out (by choice or by force), and its no longer economically interesting to pursue a given end. The system adjusts. It could be a normal market adjustment. Or it could be a Butlerian Jihad. But regardless, life goes on.

        Go touch grass, find God, have kids, and grow some food. It's a bountiful life.

        The only thing special about this circumstance is speed. Everything else, from a system perspective, is the same as it ever was throughout human history. Some things feel bigger than they are because we elevate them to be bigger than they are. Careers matter way less than having kids. GTA6 matters way less than a home cooked meal with your parents or kids. But our priorities are all messed up, so AI feels like some kind of doomsday event.

    • jansport123 3 hours ago ago

      I agree in principal but being too accepting of things also leads to bad outcomes. You can literally be a slave and think "We'll my master is much better than other masters so it really isn't that bad" but that is really not what we want people to think. We setup up society in a certain way as to maximize outcomes for most people and if that social contract isn't working, we can change it. The social contract right now is failing for many people and i don't even think that is because their expectations are large. Young people seem to be struggling in finding jobs and building a life - asking them to go to a coal mining town to work at 711 isn't a reasonable answer. At the very least, we need government enforcing competitive practices where as it seems like anti trust is basically a fiction at this point. We can seriously be heading towards feudalism and aristocracy, image if robots came in and acted as a personal army for corporate ceo's and owners - the collective negotiating power of the masses disappears.

      • mgdev 3 hours ago ago

        I think it's ridiculous to jump straight to a coal mine or a 7-Eleven as an example of the types of jobs young people should have.

        We're already seeing that Gen Z is much more amenable to blue-collar jobs than the Millennials are. They love them. They're making lots of money doing them. Millennials poo-pooed them because their parents and grandparents told them to poo-poo them and get degrees that they could never get jobs for.

        In prior generations, this problem was solved by starting businesses. The young people are also doing this in the form of side hustles to start, but eventually those will become full-fledged businesses.

        In fact, the future of work probably looks a lot like much smaller companies, maybe even companies of one or two, doing person-to-person service offerings. This is much closer to how it was a long time ago, before people became the bottleneck, and we started forming corporations to collectively gather our labor behind efforts that were too large for any single person.

        Is this strange and foreign to our current sensibilities? Of course it is. Is it any more or less attractive? It really depends on your perspective.

        • jansport123 3 hours ago ago

          why wouldn't robots eventually be able to do these other jobs if AI can do white collar jobs in the near future? Imagine going into the trades and getting laid off in 15 years because robots can do your job 24/7 for a fraction of the money.

          • mgdev an hour ago ago

            Because innovation has a long-tail distribution.

            Because physical things are much harder than digital things to get right.

            Because our appetite always outstrips our capabilities.

            There will always be a frontier.

            • jansport123 an hour ago ago

              "There will always be a frontier." - this is just you using knowledge of the past to project into the future. In the last 100 years, we've made more progress more quickly in more fields than in the last 100,000 years of mankind. What makes you so sure that some breakthrough wouldn't make physical things also solved in a similar way to digital things?

              Just as you build software to be able to accommodate future change, we should build out society to accommodate future change. I'd be very happy if humans were still needed for anything productive in the future and just typing this comment out someone from anthropic announced that they have the proof for the Riemann hypothesis.

      • luke5441 3 hours ago ago

        You can look at Russia as an example of where this ends.

    • lovich an hour ago ago

      > But people don't want to move to small towns, even though they would gladly accept them

      It’s hard enough to get work in the urban areas. Moving to a small town with even less opportunities just shackles you to the 1-2 employers in the area if you’re lucky enough to even have hiring.

      On top of that your pay is probably less so the lower cost of living doesn’t really help and now it’s much harder to return to urban areas.

      I’ve looked into small towns and trade work or local jobs in those areas since I’ve apparently been filtered out of software. The math never showed an improvement in income vs cost, just a lower quality of life in general. At least economically speaking, small town life is a lifestyle that can have value on its own to some people.

    • glimshe 3 hours ago ago

      Loved you post. I was thinking about that yesterday. I left my high stress, highly paid west coast tech job a few years ago in my 40s and moved to a transitional/rural town 50 miles away from a big city in the American South.

      I accumulated a good chunk but not enough for a lavish lifestyle. I shop at Walmart, buy used books and drive a good, but unexciting car I bought new for under 30K. I'm the millionaire next door walking around in old clothes, carrying an old phone.

      I look at some of my friends who could do the same but are chasing a mini mansion somewhere in Florida. It's okay, no judgement, but not for me.

      I spend my days reading, going to the movies with my wife (on a movie subscription) and making software I share online for free or at a small price.

      Honestly, when I think about how my life could be any better, the only thing that comes to mind is "It would be cool if I was 10 years younger".

      And I realize that the same thought will come in 10 years and I'll remember that I was here, now, free.

      • jansport123 3 hours ago ago

        I came up in tech during the 2010's and i will say it was a very lucky period so we shouldn't assume others coming up these days have it quite as good.

        • mgdev 3 hours ago ago

          100%. We were all on the gravy train and didn't really realize how good it was. However good we thought it was, it was actually 10 times better.

      • skeeter2020 3 hours ago ago

        >> the only thing that comes to mind is "It would be cool if I was 10 years younger".

        If you were 10 or 20 years younger you wouldn't be in the same position, where there's a highly paid job from which you can save without being a miser and hope to one day buy a home - anywhere. That's the point of the original post; none of theis hits evenly, with the vast majority of the spoils going to the very top, a few crumbs for people like you and me and worse than before outcomes for a lot of people.

        • glimshe 2 hours ago ago

          I have acquaintances who are 20 years younger and in the same path right now. They put themselves in place where they have good income and maintain low expenses. Balance sheet rich. One of them just got a house in a high cost of living area.

          I've heard this nonsense my whole life. I experienced recessions where I grew up plus the dot com crash, covid and the great recession here in the US.

          Someone else always has it better, right? Someone else is always "lucky".

        • Joeboy 3 hours ago ago

          Right. Per the article it's a great time to be "super-super-rich". But it's still a pretty good time to be merely rich, if you're sensible about it.

      • fuzzfactor an hour ago ago

        I never had a highly-paid job so it took me until more-traditional retirement age to earn enough to stop and enjoy a similar non-lavish lifestyle myself. Not much different than when I was working really as it pays to be conservative when preparing for an uncertain future.

        >the only thing that comes to mind is "It would be cool if I was 10 years younger".

        At my age I don't even feel that way at all.

        More like "It would be so cool if younger people were more mature" ;)

      • lovich an hour ago ago

        > I'm the millionaire next door walking around in old clothes, carrying an old phone.

        You realize this lifestyle works because you were incredibly privelaged enough to become a millionaire in the first place and this isn’t an option for 95%+ of the population to achieve in their 40s?

        You might as well be a lottery ticket winner telling people they should just play powerball until they win and then move to a small town to retire.

        • glimshe an hour ago ago

          Yawn. I grew up in a poor country and climbed my way to this. I couldn't speak proper English until my 30s. I have a mild visual disability. I remained an indentured servant of my H1B employer for years while American coworkers got better opportunities for having freedom of employment and better English skills.

          If I won the lottery ticket, I was well towards the back of the lottery ticket line.

          If you are reasonably healthy, born anywhere in the developed world and went to college, you have a better ticket than mine.

    • fergonco 3 hours ago ago

      > Kids don't have to be expensive?

      I don't know, maybe they can study for free. But they have the bad habit of eating every day. And there is no AI bringing food to the table. A realistic horizon is "no parent bringing food to the table". Who will do it?

      Read the impact of the tractor in rural areas. That was painful. Whole communities disbanded to the cities. Market was fucking down at that time. I've heard old people say "we had to work so hard to just bring a few chickpeas to the table".

      At least that was slow. You had to manufacture tractors. A AI replacing people won't give you time to react.

      • mgdev 3 hours ago ago

        I have four kids. We currently spend maybe 1.5x on food what we used to spend just as a couple. So, feeding two adults plus four kids is about the same as feeding three full adults, at least while they're young.

        These are not linear increases if you learn how to prepare food for a family.

        But again... couples who DoorDash tend to DoorDash for their kids, and then it does start to add up. Maybe don't do that.

        I agree that technology is disruptive. Are you arguing that we should not have built tractors, though? Do you think the net positive that has come from having tractors outweighs the short-term pain of transitioning to them? Especially when it's driven by market forces instead of forced upon them by some central authority?

    • fuzzfactor 2 hours ago ago

      I say it rings very true myself.

      >people don't want to move to small towns, even though they would gladly accept them.

      Also true, but looking at it the other way around, all too often the small town may not accept the average "outsider" much less the obvious "outlier" :\

    • moolcool 2 hours ago ago

      "I don't want to be an entrepreneur. I just want to live"

      • zhoBEENG an hour ago ago

        This is such an entitled take.

        “I don’t want to make anything myself, I just want to enjoy the things others make.”

        • moolcool an hour ago ago

          I don't think that's what the quote is saying at all. It's saying that a normal person should be able to do an honest day's work for an honest day's pay, and still be able to live a good middle class life. Not everyone wants to be an entrepreneur. Not everyone would be a good entrepreneur. I also don't think the market would bear everyone being an entrepreneur.

  • spicyusername 3 hours ago ago

    It always feels like this as you get older and the turning of world events are more comprehensible and immediate.

    It's easy to start getting trapped in cynical stories about life and lose your ability to see the positive side of things. In our modern life of abundance, that's actually the worst thing that can happen to you, not any all Street Journal article.

    There are a million life lessons and platitudes about this, and there will be a million more.

    It's fine, it will be fine, every problem, big or small, in life has a solution, and no time period is ever without its challenges. We soldier on anyways!

    The goal isn't no news headlines. The goal is to be at peace each morning. For there will always be news headlines and mornings.

  • bathtub365 2 hours ago ago

    > A world where art isn't created for fun, where reading is relegated to information extraction and everything is a dashboard for pleasure or resource maximization.

    I don’t understand how AI means art is no longer created for fun. You’re free to continue to create art for fun, it’s being a professional artist that has been devalued by it.

    There are still plenty of things to read that aren’t dashboards.

    I feel like I’m living in a different world than the one the author presents.

    • probably_wrong 42 minutes ago ago

      The problem is that these cheap, disposable art pieces suck the air out of the room and make the necessary conditions for personal art more difficult to achieve, the same way that weeds suck the nutrients out of a plant. If my fanfic submission to AO3 is hidden in a sea of AI slop, the encouragement and criticism required for me to grow as an artist (not to mention the fun) is just gone.

      > You’re free to continue to create art for fun, it’s being a professional artist that has been devalued by it.

      The artists I know work on a "one for you, one for me" model where one piece advances their skills and one piece pays the bills and the equipment. Fewer professional artists means fewer well-funded quirky projects, less room for mentorship, and fewer exchange forums. Art progress has always depended on money one way or another, after all.

  • pwdonald 3 hours ago ago

    I do not disagree but just to be a bit more optimistic: once we become accustom as a species to the "AI labor" the things AI can't do become the most valuable tasks and that's where the humans that are capable will spend their time. Secondly, there will be groups of people who reject anything AI touches, similar to the Amish and electricity. Thirdly, eventually governments will realize they need a new tax model and then things will get interesting.

    • vinyl7 2 hours ago ago

      > Thirdly, eventually governments will realize they need a new tax model and then things will get interesting.

      This has been the case for a long time, but governments refuse to do what's needed. I think governments will collapse before they start raising taxes on the corporations and the rich

  • bad_username 3 hours ago ago

    > A world where our voice doesn't matter as much as long as they can hunker in their bunkers and slow drip us the promise of a capitalist salvation. ... With families successfully pulverized and the social contract broken, we sit alone trying to consume as little as possible for the incoming doom cycle to subside

    It is a bit inconsistent to bash capitalism and lament the pulverization of families in the same paragraph, because the dismantling of the nuclear family is one of the goals of modern marxism.

    • cowlevel 3 hours ago ago

      The modern emphasis on the nuclear family came about around the 1960s as a capitalist device intended to sell products and houses to more households. Of course nuclear families always existed, but there was nothing special about them until that time.

      Did you never notice, the point of the nuclear family is that each one is separated from all the others?

      Just like, say, smoking being cool. Several things we take for granted today actually result from successful ad campaigns. Another well-known but small one is the kiwifruit, formerly known as the Chinese Gooseberry.

      • everdrive 3 hours ago ago

        >The modern emphasis on the nuclear family came about around the 1960s as a capitalist device intended to sell products and houses to more households.

        This is silly, and not even remotely true. The importance of the nuclear family is written into our genes, into ancient law and social custom, and more.

        • Martinussen 2 hours ago ago

          > The importance of the nuclear family is written into our genes, into ancient law and social custom, and more.

          By any reasonable standard, this is just wrong - extended family groups are, nuclear families of two parents and their kids are very much not. If you look at history, a best there are a few countries in Europe where it was kinda common, and even that is debated. Most of the world, whatever part of the world you look at, did not work like that at all.

        • byronturncoat 2 hours ago ago

          Ancient law and social custom also allowed slavery. Humans used slavery since near the beginning, so is that "written into our genes", or does it only apply to things you like?

          • everdrive 2 hours ago ago

            I didn't evaluate if it was good, just whether or not it was invented in the 1960s by capitalism.

            • byronturncoat 2 hours ago ago

              Yes, and my point was that social constructs are never "written into our genes". If you don't think it came from the 1960s, that's different than pretending that nuclear family is core to humanity

              • everdrive 2 hours ago ago

                If you think that caring for our children, and caring for them more than we care for strangers is not written into genes, I just don't know what to tell you.

                • byronturncoat 2 hours ago ago

                  Yeah, that's not even remotely the definition of "nuclear family".

    • undefined 3 hours ago ago
      [deleted]
    • byronturncoat 2 hours ago ago

      Could you provide an example of "modern Marxism?"

      • fuzzfactor an hour ago ago

        That's what I was thinking :)

        "Modern" and Marxism have always been two completely different things, and will continue to diverge as they have since the beginning.

    • Eddy_Viscosity2 3 hours ago ago

      > It is a bit inconsistent

      You do know there exists more then two political/economic ideologies yes? And even under the broad tents of both capitalism and marxism are many many sub-varieties that can have contradictory beliefs (which is why they separate).

      So no, it is not inconsistent.

    • cajal 3 hours ago ago

      “modern marxism” the hell are you talking about lmao. who is one “modern marxist” you’ve heard of? hahahhaha

    • mcphage 2 hours ago ago

      > the dismantling of the nuclear family is one of the goals of modern marxism

      Also one of the goals of modern capitalism.

  • chmorgan_ 3 hours ago ago

    [dead]

  • inatreecrown2 3 hours ago ago

    Beautifully expressed. AI would never...

    • anihil 3 hours ago ago

      Thank you

  • cowlevel 3 hours ago ago

    So is the enemy's gate. And my web server.

  • nixosbestos 3 hours ago ago

    Anyone do sentiment analysis on HN? I swear, now that information work is threatened there's a growing palpable shift in politics. ~"Gosh now that my work is not valued, I sure have feelings about the capitalism machine."

    I guess I shouldn't look a solidarity horse in the mouth.

    • skeeter2020 3 hours ago ago

      I actually sense it going the other way; there seems to be an anti-anti-AI wave about how it's "set them free" and life has never been better.

  • Matascruzstiven 3 hours ago ago

    [flagged]

  • Matascruzstiven 3 hours ago ago

    [flagged]