Show HN: Online curling game/SIM with Three.js

(cloudcurling.com)

1 points | by nrjames 4 hours ago ago

4 comments

  • vunderba 2 hours ago ago

    I'm not really a curling person, so I wish I could offer more feedback. From what I could tell - even in the practice mode... it's a lot to take in.

    Here's what I would recommend: some games, especially sports games, offer an "arcade mode" that's drastically simplified (terminology, mechanics, etc)

    I think most people have probably watched curling and are familiar with only two things: the person who pushes the stone and the person who brushes the ice to coax the stone where they want it to go. So to get more people to play, it might help to offer a simple arcade mode with just these mechanics. Then even people whose only experience is with something like shuffleboard would be able to jump right in.

    • nrjames an hour ago ago

      Thanks for the feedback! There are a number of very arcade-like curling games on the various app stores. I was definitely angling more for a simulation here (even down to how the pebble wears down on the ice, etc), more out of curiosity as to whether I could create an accurate representation of how the stone move and the sweeping than anything else.

      Curling is more complicated than it looks at first glance. It's probably more similar to chess than to shuffleboard -- but chess where it requires skill to move the pieces.

      I will revisit the tutorial again to see if I can boil it down to the absolute basics for how to play. I guess my hope was that non-curling players who put in a few minutes to learn the rules and how to play might discover the strategic layer to it and find that interesting.

      Nevertheless, I don't plan to try to monetize it as it's just a hobby project. If you're interested in somebody else's non-hobby take, check out "True Curling: Granite 3" on the various app stores.

      • vunderba an hour ago ago

        > I guess my hope was that non-curling players who put in a few minutes to learn the rules and how to play might discover the strategic layer to it and find that interesting.

        Yeah I think that's a reasonable expectation. I feel like I was only able to provide limited feedback because I’m not the target demograph - in so far as I don’t find curling particularly interesting.

        I probably would have been more likely to invest in learning the rules if it were a sport that appealed to me (such as archery).

        Might be worth posting over on a dedicated subreddit like r/curling though!

  • nrjames 4 hours ago ago

    If anybody has thoughts or suggestions, I'd love to hear them! I know the tutorial could stand some improvement, but it does an ok job at the moment. The main thing it doesn't explain is Skip mode when playing. In that mode, you just call the shots and the sweeping and the computer throws stones for you. You also view the sheet from the skip's perspective.