1 comments

  • _wire_ 5 hours ago ago

    Nagel:

    "They are assuming that the physical substrate is irrelevant. They all think that the material conditions for consciousness can be given in functionalist terms."

    Chomsky disabused science of this argument in the 1990s

    There's no more understanding of the reasons for a physical organism to manifest consciousness than physical circuits.

    "Physical" is a buzzword to science that Newton destroyed by obviating the machine, leaving the ghost.

    Lacking any theory for how life forms manifests consciousness, there's no way to use a substrate distinction to refute appearances of consciousness.

    Nagel seems hopelessly lost:

    "It’s more than likely that the truth is one which links physical processes and systems of certain kinds to mental phenomena."

    Sure what kinds and how?

    (silence)

    "Bats are conscious. We just don’t have the imaginative capacity to form a conception of the aspects of that subjectivity that depend on echolocation."

    Having no theory, merely hand-waving, Nagel rediscovers the Turing Test:

    "It would be radically unscientific to conclude that bats are not conscious from the fact that we can’t imagine what it’s like"

    Chomsky quoting Hume:

    "While Newton seemed to draw off the veil from some of the mysteries of nature, he showed at the same time the imperfections of the mechanical philosophy (science); and thereby restored nature's ultimate secrets to that obscurity, in which they ever did and ever will remain"

    Chomsky quoting Bertrand Russell to Nagel:Human beings, like every organism, are subject to scope and limits.

    What are our limits. Given relative infinities, and the example of Nagel's bat, there's no contradiction between humans language capacity of "the infinite use of finite means" (Descartes) and realms of understanding that are forever beyond us.

    According to Chomsky, the only rational path towards understanding of language--humans most distinct and unique manifestation of consciousness--is through computational models.

    Chomsky says he in no way means to imply that any computer could be equivalent to a human, but that our knowledge is so impoverished and the limits of understanding are so profound in the domain of intelligence that it's pointless to draw substrate comparisons between human cognizance and anything else. Substrates are merely categories of the unknown and the Imitation Game (as stupefying as it is) remains the only means we have of reasoning about consciousness, unless someone can reformulate the notion of physical in some way that transcends Newton.

    Chomsky has lectured widely about these matters for his entire career and consolidated his views into an hour-long survey lecture titled "language, mind and the limits of understanding" which no other popular prognosticator (e.g. Nagel) can touch in terms of historical context of science and today's state of understanding of mind.