71 comments

  • zug_zug 7 hours ago ago

    I think the more obvious concern nto me is whether any writes happened rather than just reads. I'd love to assume the government is more competent than that, but I don't.

    • tclancy 6 hours ago ago

      I was thinking it would be some beautiful logic riddle if someone broke in to enter their name in the database.

      • prossercj 2 hours ago ago

        Nah, they just wanted to normalize the schema.

        • timacles 2 hours ago ago

          they dropped an index on the `users.id` column. Entire system crashes

      • saagarjha 3 hours ago ago

        Waiting to see if Claude told on itself there

    • webdoodle 24 minutes ago ago

      When DOGE scraped all of the U.S. Federal Government data, I wondered how deep it went. As both Trump and Musk were in the Epstein files, I wondered if that was the real goal, to find any incriminating evidence, so they could have it hacked and deleted later.

      • 93po 2 minutes ago ago

        it's really disappointing that there's a mountain of evidence that Musk visited pedo island countless times and it's all being covered up

    • thatsabadlook 5 hours ago ago

      The governments it people are probably a lot more competent than you think. Unfortunately, with budget cuts and ai roll out smoke screens plus so dumpster fires a lot of things could happen right now that ordinarily wouldnt

      • calgoo 3 hours ago ago

        The way i look at it is that they fired all the competent sysadmins, so the people running things now are the yes men that bent over backwards for Trump / Elon.

  • roamerz 2 hours ago ago

    The security is only as good as its weakest interface. After years of training and audits it’s getting better for sure but the fact remains that there are a large number of systems that have read/write access to the system that have substandard security controls. At the scale this system operates it’s almost an impossible task to ensure each of those systems is secure and that’s not mentioning potential abuse / mistakes by end users.

    • mmooss an hour ago ago

      Yes, from the OP:

      > The National Crime Information Center (NCIC) database is used by federal and local law enforcement to share information on warrants and background checks.

      Who needs a technical hack? With authorized availability all over the country (and maybe in partner countries), there must be effectively infinite ways in.

      How could it be secured? Permanently audit who accessed what and when, but I hope that's already done. Maybe minimize access to a low rate, and then minimize query result data and restrict full record access to a lower rate? That is, make scraping large parts of it much more expensive. For example, a fingerprint search's query results could be limited to the top 30 (if that's sufficient) and not show names or other data, just a confidence score. Maybe the user could narrow the search by location or other data (age, etc.), still without names. They may only need the names and full records of a few.

  • o_-_o 7 hours ago ago

    The fact that these systems are not air-gapped[1] is very troubling.

    [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_gap_(networking)

    • EvanAnderson 3 hours ago ago

      As Stuxnet showed us, and Ed Skoudis (of SANS fame) said during his keynote at DerbyCon 3:

      "At best, an air gap is a high-latency connection."

      The usability of a truly air-gapped system rapidly approaches zero, so inevitably air-gapped systems end up growing contrivances and compromises that make them not air-gapped anymore.

      "The network is the computer" might seem like trite marketing speak but seeing how the utility of computers has taken off as ubiquitous networking has become available speaks to the statement's truth. The amount of utility the FBI could get out of an air-gapped system would be dramatically less.

      Floppy diskette-based computer viruses in the 1980s were enough proof alone that air-gapping isn't a panacea.

      • MichaelZuo 2 hours ago ago

        What? By definition the moment anything at all bridges the air gap (other than manual data entry) it’s no longer an air gapped system.

        • EvanAnderson an hour ago ago

          Yes. Tell that to all the "air-gapped" systems I've seen over the years that were no longer air-gapped.

          Edit: On one pentest I attacked a homemade "data diode" system called "the airlock". The self-delusion was strong with that one.

    • bigfatkitten 5 hours ago ago

      How would you propose that the 64,000+[0] local, state and federal law enforcement and other related agencies that NCIC is intended to serve access that system?

      [0] https://www.princeton.edu/~ota/disk3/1982/8203/820307.PDF

      • onionisafruit 2 hours ago ago

        Massively increased travel budgets. Initially each agency individually sends agents to Lebanon Kansas (centrally located) with queries and updates. They write the result on a napkin and bring it back. Eventually that becomes resource-intensive, so somebody starts a query courier service that transports napkins across the country. One courier with big pockets can carry hundreds of napkin queries from all the agencies in a region. But that is still high latency. A competing service sets up an office in Lebanon. Agencies can email a photo of a napkin with a query on it. They take the photo into the server room, run the query and write the result on a fresh napkin to be photographed and sent in an email back to the agency. That’s the final stage. Everything is running efficiently. But what about all the diners and hotels in Lebanon built to serve the traveling agents? I don’t know. I guess it’s the price of progress.

      • morkalork 5 hours ago ago

        Obviously a secretary pool of women that you can only send and receive requests to by pneumatic tube.

        • Telemakhos 5 hours ago ago

          A pneumatic tube is the antithesis of an air-gapped system.

          • tharkun__ 4 hours ago ago

            Ackshually, it seems like it fits perfectly. The air gap even travels with the message, doesn't it? Nobody said the air around must be perfectly still. SCNR

          • jameshart 3 hours ago ago

            I think you misspelled apotheosis

        • lazide 3 hours ago ago

          Can they all be heavily tattooed and wear skimpy outfits while working? If so, I’m in!

    • wcoenen 7 hours ago ago

      Let's say you put the air-gapped database somewhere in the middle of the US. How would agents working on the east or west coast (>2000km away) interact with the database?

      • rdmuser 7 hours ago ago

        Through humans with local access to the computers. A connection to computers doesn't need to be a direct one. I admittedly don't have any relevant expertise though.

        • __s 6 hours ago ago

          This was how natcloud worked at Azure, & I'm assuming other clouds. If they had issues they couldn't even copy/paste, instead someone with two laptops would type out error messages for support & type in any commands they needed to run

          https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/azure-government/doc...

        • ratio53 6 hours ago ago

          That is how AWS handles isolated partitions. Teams must contact someone with access to a physical location to perform the task.

        • MisterMunchkin 6 hours ago ago

          Okay so we set up your genius system of using phones to call people who then manually do the work for the person… and then a Russian agent just calls up those people and pretends to be FBI, allowing them to access all of the data. Incredible idea!

          • smashandgrab 3 hours ago ago

            “Hello, this is John American. I need all of the data.”

          • calmworm 5 hours ago ago

            Imagine if you will a time before all computers were interconnected…

            • pixl97 2 hours ago ago

              I lived there, do you realize how much fraud occurred then too? Hell, you wouldn't find out for months to years some times.

              There aren't even enough people in the US to take up all the jobs that would be required if replicating the same amount of information exchange as happens now.

          • Geezus_42 5 hours ago ago

            Damn operators didn't do their phishing training...

        • dboreham 2 hours ago ago

          There are many high profile cases that were solved through running queries across large data sets (e.g. Lockerbie). Hard to do that through a meat proxy.

      • oefrha 7 hours ago ago

        Every major military has a completely separate backbone, to give you a well known example.

        • bigfatkitten 5 hours ago ago

          And most of it is carried over commercial telecommunications infrastructure using high assurance cryptographic equipment.

        • kotaKat 6 hours ago ago

          Ehhhh. There's still VPN endpoints to get in. Sometimes it's a couple layers of them, but there's still probably 1-2 IPv4 addresses "out there" that are the magic door.

          After all... there's some way for the little portable 'enclave' equipment to phone back home all the way into SIPRnet (or other government equivalants)...

          • MichaelZuo 2 hours ago ago

            I’ve never heard of any setup where that is allowed.

            At most it’s someone physically reading things on one computer and manually typing it in on a second computer beside it. (with usb ports removed or superglued of course)

            So it’s a very tiny air gap of maybe 30cm, but there’s no way directly plugging them into each other wouldn’t trigger huge alarms.

      • o_-_o 7 hours ago ago

        These agencies should have a separate network that is completely isolated from the public internet. Use there own encrypted fiber optics, satellites.

        • unrented7977 2 hours ago ago

          I don't think you have any idea how difficult and expensive that would be, even for the US government.

          • 15155 2 hours ago ago

            What do you think Starshield is?

            • o_-_o an hour ago ago

              Starshield is extremely unreliable as war in Ukraine showed.

              • 15155 27 minutes ago ago

                Could it possibly be that Ukraine is a charity case and that the service might work better for the country paying for it? Is there some fundamental indictment of the technology?

              • SV_BubbleTime 26 minutes ago ago

                Can you point to outages on the US side of starshield?

                If you change your news sources you may find that the outages in Ukraine have been on the starLINK side because allegedly (by Starlink) that Ukraine was using the consumer side for military actions.

    • throw0101d 5 hours ago ago

      > The fact that these systems are not air-gapped[1] is very troubling.

      Not necessarily wrong, but a reminder that an air gap did not stop Stuxnet:

      * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuxnet

      Also, the CIA triad is part of most security thinking:

      * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_triad

      with the "A" standing for availability: if regular/authorized users can't access and process the information (somewhat conveniently), how much value does the service actually have?

      • SV_BubbleTime 21 minutes ago ago

        Let’s not pretend that stux was some marvel of defeat engineering.

        It was a USB autoplay attack.

        Someone internal to the network plugged in and infected USB. It was likely a spy.

  • bita_nidir 3 hours ago ago

    Crime database or criminal database? There's a subtle but very important difference, and in this day and age nothing surprises me.

  • torben-friis 7 hours ago ago

    >After that hack, one former FBI agent told the BBC he feared for the safety of current employees, whose personal information could soon become available online to criminals and hostile nation-state hackers.

    As an outsider, it is hard to imagine what US intelligence capabilities will look like from now on. Has it been effectively gutted? Not only speaking of this specific incident, but also leadership changes, etc. for which this might be a symptom.

    • Geezus_42 5 hours ago ago

      One thing no administration is going to fuck with is their ability to spy on people within the country. Look how hard they've pushed the rollout of FLOCK and similar tech.

      • skinfaxi 3 hours ago ago

        Is flock being pushed nationally by the administration or by local governments?

  • didntknowyou 6 hours ago ago

    they would usually throw a comment speculating a country immediately so i’m guessing it’s some company or AI and they are working on a PR release together

  • guillybarres 5 hours ago ago

    Two huge hacks against FBI in the span of a few months is really worrying. Is it the result of advances made possible by AI, or has a taboo fallen?

    • smashandgrab 3 hours ago ago

      I’m going to take a different road here. Honestly I wonder if the risk/reward of doing that isn’t more important.

      For anyone reachable by the USA it would be incredibly risky to hack the FBI. They aren’t going to pay you the millions you might get from hitting a commercial entity and they’re sure going to come find you to save face.

      For someone in an adversaries geo space you don’t have to worry about the risk to much and the reward might be more worthwhile.

      Then again, they might also already have that information 20 times over.

      With that being said, I wonder more if the reason isn’t necessarily just AI but also because these systems have rarely been tested (by experienced threats) before.

    • Cthulhu_ 5 hours ago ago

      I want to say it's because of the advances; for decades, hacking the FBI was a meme and / or a pathway to get a job offer in security so I'd imagine every avenue into hacking has been done and done again. It feels like AI has fresh ideas and can try a lot of them very fast (relative to a human).

    • BryantD 5 hours ago ago

      It wouldn’t be at all surprising if AI was involved, but the other key factor is that it’s a very bad idea to fire a whole lot of agents for voting for the wrong party.

    • acdha an hour ago ago

      Federal IT departments were already significantly understaffed[1] before they lost 20k workers last year so my default assumption for this, the NSA, FAA, USDA, etc. is that you’re seeing what happens when leaders “optimize” all of the resilience away right before the threat level ramps up.

      1. Contractors fill in a little but only to the extent that the government had skilled technical staff to oversee them.

  • back_to_basics 6 hours ago ago

    >The FBI is investigating an apparent breach of its criminal information database, US media report citing two people briefed on the issue.

    I find it very curious that unnamed sources are *leaking* such sensitive information.

    Cui Bono from such an acknowledgment of a breach?

    Ahhh, the opponents of Open Source AI (or anything Open Source, for that matter).

    If I am correct, then you'll soon see a narrative being crafted along such lines.

    • NooneAtAll5 3 hours ago ago

      I'm concerned that this is UK newspaper talking about US news

      was there no US-based coverage? what kind of biases do people from outside add?

    • g-b-r 4 hours ago ago

      As much as I support open source AI, I see other much better reasons for "leaking" it (giving an indication of the security of the FBI systems, and warning that some information might have gotten changed).

  • monster_truck 6 hours ago ago

    Can I look myself up in it yet? Not that I've done anything...

  • doublerabbit 3 hours ago ago

    Do CIA next.

  • vivzkestrel 2 hours ago ago

    - all these attacks made by uncensored llm models with little to no guardrails? any ideas?

  • camillomiller 7 hours ago ago

    These are the consequences. FAFO at global scale. Good riddance US, the damage inflicted by the Trump, Musk, Miller, Patel, Hegseth and co criminal syndicate, aided and abetted by billionaire oligarchs, is probably irreversible.

    • jamesbfb 6 hours ago ago

      There is a certain level of irony in all of this.

      • CoastalCoder 6 hours ago ago

        How so?

        • jamesbfb 6 hours ago ago

          Sorry, I probably should have prefaced that comment with that the irony aspect is wrapped in an agreement of what you said. Something something the destroyer of us is a result of what we created, that being Trump, Musk et al.

    • 0xy 3 hours ago ago

      There were multiple large government hacks from 2021-24.

    • jfengel 4 hours ago ago

      As much as I despise the people you list, this likely would have happened under any administration. There's a good chance that the underlying security fault started years ago. (Including, perhaps, the prior version of this one.)

      Presidents have always gotten praise and blame for things they had no control over. The current administration deserves a ton of blame for crises that haven't happened yet. So it's a bit ironic that they'll receive the blame for something they probably couldn't have prevented.

      They do have control over their reaction to it, and given past actions will likely spend it blaming their usual enemies rather than trying to fix anything.

      • basilgohar 4 hours ago ago

        I think a lot of people will point to this administration's cutting of huge amounts of government jobs related to IT and security and oversight and the increase in incidents like these. This goes back to DOGE and co.

        • pixl97 2 hours ago ago

          I mean I think it's a double tap.

          Goofs in office + Automated AI bug finding and hacking.

      • mmooss an hour ago ago

        I think we can't really know for sure, but we need to make the best judgment we can. We can't just say every time, 'well, we don't know for sure' or there is no accountability. This administration has prioritized political loyalty over expertise to a great degree, so problems like this one are certainly a risk.

        > Presidents have always gotten praise and blame for things they had no control over.

        That observation usually refers to the economy, something external to government which presidents have limited immediate ability to help but can definitely screw up. The FBI is an agency of the executive branch; that's very different and this isn't day 0 for the current administration.

        Each administration is responsible for what happens on its watch - if you can't handle manage that, you shouldn't have taken on the responsibility.