138 comments

  • elif 6 hours ago ago

    This explains why it took me and my child almost 10 minutes to find an actual lego set in the 5 aisles of legos at target the other day.

    I ended up giving up and buying one of the character-focused-scene ones because it wasn't $100+ and it had blocks that could actually be built with instead of weird shapes that only belong in one specific place in one specific sculpture.

    Virtually all of them are now designed to be built one time and displayed on a shelf, or more likely, never to be built at all.

    • Glyptodon 4 hours ago ago

      Creator 3-in-1 is probably the best bet for unlicensed sets at a variety of price points with varying themes and more standard pieces. Classic is a little too basic. Friends is kind of between 3-in-1 and City but targeted as girls, with City and Ninjago being the other two more classic and long running Lego themes more traditionaly kid targeted. Most stores now have a lot of isle space devoted to the licensed themes (Star Wars, Mario, etc.), and Icons, Ideas, Botanicals, etc., IE the bigger more display oriented stuff, and have much less space by comparison for the more traditional sets.

      That said, most holiday seasons there is some kind of classic set with great price per piece being sold as a deal circa black Friday at the big box stores.

    • pizzafeelsright 3 hours ago ago

      Go to ebay. Bulk buy by the pound. Clean parts for $7-15.

    • rexpop 3 hours ago ago

      This is not LEGO's decision, necessarily. Target is optimizing their own revenue according to their own demographic.

      Not sure why you are financing bribery, however—Target are documented pay-to-play participants.

    • mcphage 5 hours ago ago

      Lego sets—even the fancy Lego set—are still designed using generic pieces. The things they can do with a frog, or a banana, or a cupcake topper. The same piece used for demigorgon heads is used for orchid blossoms.

      • illiac786 4 hours ago ago

        I disagree, the flower ones for example are full of pieces you cannot easily reuse for something else in my view. All pieces are “generic” in theory, but there is less and less simple bricks

      • adaml_623 4 hours ago ago

        There is some reuse but for kids you should buy the sets of generic blocks. Just my humble opinion. Otherwise they end up with completed models that they feel guilty about breaking up

        • euroderf 3 hours ago ago

          My kid has a bunch of Ninjago sets...cand when he wants to actually build a building, he doesn't have enough generic/"normal" bricks to do so.

        • voidfunc 4 hours ago ago

          They only feel guilty if you make them feel guilty about it.

        • watwut 4 hours ago ago

          Mine did not liked the generic blocs. They liked the ones with theme. Those were something they actually build and played with. They eventually naturally decompose.

          Most of the time, you are buying a gift and toy to make them happy for birthday, not being in the quest to force the most "educational" thing there is.

        • bix6 4 hours ago ago

          Why would they feel guilty? Creative destruction is dope!

    • kotaKat 6 hours ago ago

      We've lost so many good STEM building toys over the years.

      I, for one, constantly mourn the loss of Rokenbok[1]. A good beam-and-block-and-ball-sorting contraption with a bunch of RC construction equipment. What's not to love? Street sweepers and monorails and elevators and loaders and...

      Sadly not covered by Wikipedia was an early 2016 cyberattack[2] which essentially took them out of business (forcing the rebrand to 'Kid Spark' with a significant cutback to serve just education) a couple years later.

      [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kid_Spark_Education [2] https://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/article/No-busines...

      • KeplerBoy 6 hours ago ago

        Then again you can do a lot of that stuff with a 3D printer and some diy electronics these days.

        Bambulab has a questionable reputation for a reason, but if I had kids in the right age I would certainly try their cyberbricks with them.

      • emidoots 5 hours ago ago

        I would love to see a modern-day Rokenbok-like set! I think the idea is so great!

        A few years ago I went to several thrift stores and tried to find as much Rokenbok as I could, because i recalled it being quite fun.. well, nostalgia is a thing, and honestly they were fairly glitchy/iffy toys that didn't work all that well, so a modern day recreation would be super cool!

        I think STEM building toys are so underrated, Lego Mindstorms and Erector sets also come to mind!

      • waltbosz 5 hours ago ago

        I remember seeing and playing with a demo Rokenbok at a mall when I was a kid. I thought it was amazing but my family could never afford it. 30 years later I saw a set for sale at a Goodwill and snatched it up. My kids enjoyed it. I just saw it in my garage the other day. Maybe I'll get it out.

        • kotaKat 4 hours ago ago

          I also just realized the old showcase/demo/building plan CD-ROM's on the Internet Archive.

          https://archive.org/details/rokenbok-cd-vol-1

          It had a really wild little "virtual reality" game you could play and everything. I think I might have to fire up an old Windows VM and shove the CD in again like a kid...

      • taneq 6 hours ago ago

        We've gained some absolute gems though. I'd get my kids an Ender3 and a desktop CNC machine and teach them how to use them to build literally anything... if I could just get them to care about the real world instead of reaction videos to Minecraft livestreams.

    • IshKebab 5 hours ago ago

      As far as I know Lego has always been expensive and it has always been sold with specific build instructions rather than just a bunch of random pieces (I assume that's what you mean by "an actual Lego set"?).

      > Virtually all of them are now designed to be built one time and displayed on a shelf, or more likely, never to be built at all.

      They aren't. The whole 3-in-1 series is like 95% standard bricks.

      • cogman10 5 hours ago ago

        > has always been sold with specific build instructions rather than just a bunch of random pieces

        Surprisingly, no. My family owned this suitcase https://brickset.com/sets/790-1/Suitcase-blue which came with a random assortment of legos and no instructions.

        You can still buy a similar product https://www.lego.com/en-us/product/creative-suitcase-10713 , though it does now include instructions, yet not dedicated to anything other than "You can build these things".

      • ac29 5 hours ago ago

        > I assume that's what you mean by "an actual Lego set"?

        My guess is they meant most of the sets were based on movies/games/tv/etc IP, and not just just the generic "lego truck" or "lego house" sets that were most common decades ago.

      • evanjrowley 4 hours ago ago

        Specific build instructions, but also depections of what you could make with the same bricks. It was true in the 1990s. It's not easy to find examples of this since the alternate examples were never the main focus, never shown on the box, but it was a regular occurrence to see alternatives presented with a lego kit. The last pages of these assembly manuals are an example:

        - https://lego.brickinstructions.com/lego_instructions/set/693...

        - https://lego.brickinstructions.com/lego_instructions/set/619...

      • philipov 5 hours ago ago

        They were always sold with specific build instructions, but those build instructions used generic pieces that could easily be reused in other builds. A lot of people completely ignored the instructions completely. I'm sure a lot of the pieces are still generic blocks, but less so than before.

        • watwut 4 hours ago ago

          No, lego actually simplified bricks selection some years ago.

      • chrisoverzero 5 hours ago ago

        There’s a reason the product line that’s “a bunch of random pieces” is called LEGO Classic.

      • hattmall 3 hours ago ago

        Definitely not always sets, we just got Lego Tubs. They had instruction books of a bunch of things you could build.

      • bowsamic 5 hours ago ago

        No Lego have always sold big boxes of bricks. By actual set he means ones that aren’t adult architecture or a huge Star Wars ship

        • adaml_623 4 hours ago ago

          The big boxes of bricks are excellent for kids. Although they need to be bored before they start using them so there's a little bit of a painful period after taking their screens away

          • bowsamic 4 hours ago ago

            My trick with my children: never give them screened in the first place. Not saying this is all parents but I’m shocked at how often I see a perfectly happy baby relaxing in a public space and then the parent decides to put a bright screen in front of the child without the child even being fussy. Saw it today with a six month old

      • embedding-shape 5 hours ago ago

        > it has always been sold with specific build instructions rather than just a bunch of random pieces (I assume that's what you mean by "an actual Lego set"?).

        Yes, but LEGO used to put huge focus on that every piece in a set could be "reused" and used for your other own builds. The more "special" a piece is, the less you're able to reuse it. Nowadays, lots of bricks have prints and are specially made "for this specific purpose for this build" which I guess also makes things seem more expensive.

        > They aren't. The whole 3-in-1 series is like 95% standard bricks.

        How big is that series (or the Classic one) compared to everything else? Going to my local LEGO shop, those things are usually hidden in the back of the store or on the way to the cashier, not front and center which it used to be.

    • lifestyleguru 5 hours ago ago

      Where I grew up lego was really expensive and not quite available although I really wanted to have it, especially technic. During early childhood could be purchased only with USD in a country where possessing USD was illegal. Luckily I completely don't have the compensating syndrome as an adult, don't buy it neither for myself nor for any kids in family. When I see lego nowadays I just feel "meh".

  • Merrill 6 hours ago ago

    This presumably includes grandparent only households buying toys for the grandkids.

    Marriage age is rising, so there are more maiden aunts and bachelor uncles buying for their nieces and nephews.

    Plus divorced parents buying for their kids.

    • KeplerBoy 6 hours ago ago

      Just look at what is being sold as a toy these days. Nostalgia and collectibles are a common theme.

      • lo_zamoyski 5 hours ago ago

        I find it extremely bizarre for adults to be doing this. The sysops guy in a state of arrested development who has a bunch of action figures on his desk - and at work! - or the woman of a certain age whose house is full of plush toys and Precious Moments angels who overuses diminutive nouns, to give two stock examples. (I would add the phenomenon of going on walks with dogs in strollers as a third.)

        It's very concerning when this behavior becomes widespread enough to become profitable. At some point, we made not becoming a mature adult acceptable. We don't even have a clear and accurate picture of what that even means. Everything is culturally relative and arbitrary, or worse, childishness is celebrated. And then there are the political implications. It's not difficult to imagine out how children might would vote compared to adults.

        Perhaps this suits the oligarchic class because while childish people can be a nuisance, even a dangerous one as in the case of mass shooters, they are more pliable than adults. They can be more easily directed through appetite and fear. You could even say that the culture even penalizes and stigmatizes maturity.

        • mdlxxv 5 hours ago ago

          "When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up" (C.S. Lewis)

          • honeycrispy 4 hours ago ago

            Keep in mind the environment in which he said that is very different than what we see today. There's a balance. Disneyland was built for children, not childless 36 year-old Millennials.

            • nozzlegear 3 hours ago ago

              The Disneyland of yesteryear was built for children.

        • hattmall 3 hours ago ago

          You are being down voted, but I agree, it's weird and concerning. I have quite a few friends and acquaintances that fit this mold and all of them are prone to fits of melancholy, to put it nicely.

          And I'm somebody that enjoys and still plays with toys far more than a lot of other adults, it's the obsession over collections that's really the issue. It's not limited to toys though, it's really just being obsessed with collecting something you thought was cool in your childhood. The guy with the framed MTG decks isn't any worse than the 40 year old woman with 34 N'SYNC ticket stubs that will put a prayer request for a "Timbertouch" on Facebook.

          • D13Fd an hour ago ago

            I'm not a collector, but I honestly see absolutely nothing wrong with collecting as a hobby, and to me it's a better hobby than many things that might otherwise occupy a person's time, like scrolling TikTok or YouTube or watching TV and vegging out. I really don't see what is wrong with having a real-life hobby that brings you joy and fulfillment.

        • glimshe 4 hours ago ago

          I don't find it bizarre at all. I'm a middle aged adult who raised a family and experienced/handled many of the hardships of life: deaths in the family, health issues, kid problems in school, marital problems etc. I don't live in some fantasy world. Yet, I love little toys and videogames.

          Most of it is just nostalgia. I don't think I need to literally help He-man fight Skeletor. Duh. But it's good to remember a time when life was simpler. Not because life is bad, but because it's... fun to do that?

          The concerning trend is excess of free time because of lack of children. I think this is a simpler explanation than some big "this generation didn't grow up". You can find similar claims from previous generations: "Kids these days don't respect elders anymore, don't know how to do X, Y and Z, when I was a kid things were very different blah blah blah"

          • D13Fd an hour ago ago

            I think you nailed it that (1) there is nothing wrong with this and (2) it's a byproduct of a lack of kids.

            As someone with kids, I can confirm that they really do suck up most of your time and, worse, your attention. Toys and collecting are hobbies. I wasn't into toys and collecting, but I had so many more hobbies, and they were much more wide-ranging, before I had kids.

            (I'm not complaining - time with the kids is much more fulfilling, and I love them to death. But I do also miss my photography trips, my competitive gaming skills, my weekends spent reading, coding, or doing home improvement projects, etc. etc.)

        • origini 5 hours ago ago

          You sound depressing. How did you loose all the joy of things you like?

          The norm of 'becoming an adult' do you know what this looked like 50/100 years ago?

          Being emotional disconnected, going to work, drinking.

          Do you even realize how closed minded you are? How you follow norms of 'being an adulut' because thats the image of an Adult you hold up without knowing why?

          I'm mature, I still have a few legosets around. Surprise you can be both. I would even argue that i'm more mature than you ever be if you don't break out of your closed mindedness.

          Grow up and set yourself mentally free and decide for yourself what it means to be an adult.

          • ecshafer 4 hours ago ago

            You dont lose joy for what you love. You replace the love of building (legos) with the love of building (woodworking, smithing, stonemason, diy). You graduate to more sophisticated endeavors. You may love reading but you need to stop reading the box car kids and read infinite jest at some point.

            • hattmall 3 hours ago ago

              Yeah it's the lock in and focus of a "cool" thing from your childhood that indicates the lack of growth.

            • dpkirchner 3 hours ago ago

              More sophisticated perhaps, more time consuming and expensive absolutely

        • nerdjon 5 hours ago ago

          > We don't even have a clear and accurate picture of what that even means.

          I am pretty sure being a "mature adult" is just having a job, taking care of yourself (and those that rely on you), paying taxes, preparing for your future, etc.

          Nothing in there about what you find enjoyable, what makes you happy. I would argue that being able to actually figure out what makes ME happy should be far more of a measure of being an adult than anything else.

          Your opinion on what makes and doesn't make an adult is depressing. I can both be a successful adult with a partner, friends, and a life and then spend my afternoon building a lego set that seeing it on display just makes me happy.

          Maybe we should look at why there stereotype of adults being miserable or unhappy all the time still lingers and than we see comments like yours and it all clicks.

        • cajal 5 hours ago ago

          letting the autistic guy at work have batman on his desk without making him feel bad is NOT a sign of the collapse of western society you chud

        • Frondo 4 hours ago ago

          Yes, they should be more like my father, who had a life long career in law enforcement and... dedicated a whole room in the house to toy trains. Or my uncle who ran a regional construction firm and.. had a room in his very large house full of board games and RC planes.

          Stuff is very cheap as a rule now, and people make enough money to buy stuff, while all through my thirties and halfway through my 40s I was the only person out of my friend group who had a house, cause I always had a tech job and could afford one.

          What you're seeing now is a consequence of the economy being stripped for parts all our lives.

          • throaway1985asd 4 hours ago ago

            Honestly I only feel guilty playing with my toys when I know im avoiding responsibilities at the same time.

          • hattmall 3 hours ago ago

            I mean other adults would have definitely thought those were weird too at the time.

        • tehwebguy 4 hours ago ago

          A coworker shared one of their interests at work and you secretly despise them for it. Yeah THEY sound terrible lmao

        • dead_hn_theory 5 hours ago ago

          I hear you bud. This is just the next step of replacing children with pets [0]. Whether planned by the "oligarchic class" or not it doesn't really matter, these people are beyond gone. Imagine pointing out 40 year-old men shouldn't be lining up to play GTA VI. Holee sheet, let me give myself a downvote to start the wave. Fuck yeah, imaginary approval points!

          [0] https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/10.1027/1016-9040/a000552

          • mopsi 4 hours ago ago

              > Imagine pointing out 40 year-old men shouldn't be lining up to play GTA VI.
            
            Why not? If anything, more people should play games, because context switching has proven mental health benefits. Temporarily leaving everyday concerns, be it through reading or watching a movie or playing a game, is essential for reducing psychological fatigue. I'd be worried about people who don't do any of that.
        • VCFundedGenYer 4 hours ago ago

          [dead]

        • cajal 5 hours ago ago

          [flagged]

          • stevehawk 5 hours ago ago

            because we're better looking and the ladies like us more?

    • onion2k 6 hours ago ago

      Those are the 45%.

    • embedding-shape 5 hours ago ago

      > Plus divorced parents buying for their kids.

      That wouldn't count as a "adult-only household" unless one parent has the custody, no? It'd be a weird way to "hide" a bunch of real families otherwise.

  • PedroBatista 6 hours ago ago

    Yes, one of the reasons is what we think but let’s not forget to take into account gifts for kids of the family/ friends before we jump into conclusions too hard.

  • helsinkiandrew 7 hours ago ago
  • notenchange 5 hours ago ago

    We (Milenials and GenZ) are a generation of men and women that never grew up, because society never forced - or even expected - us to grow up.

    This is societal colapse. The first time a real crisis shows up - and it will show up - we will all be children in adult bodies, that only ever knew how to play make pretend with their empty lives.

    We replaced forming a family and having children, by some mindless fantasy existence. Never committing to anything due to million excuses while time runs out of our hands.

    Is this is a life well lived? Playing with toys in the evening alone with our partners, while during the day, at work, we complain on social networks about the "oppression" of modern society?

    • collinmcnulty 4 hours ago ago

      Ironically, I think this is a one dimensional and childish view. Is building an elaborate Lego set intrinsically less adult than golf? Than playing bridge? Than building a model train?

      Being an adult is about taking care of one’s responsibilities to yourself, your community, and society, not about what one does as a hobby. This sneering that because of one’s hobbies they won’t be prepared to handle responsibilities is unbecoming.

      • landl0rd 4 hours ago ago

        You have it backwards; they are playing with legos specifically because they perceive it as childish. Lots of folks used to build model things. The millennial chooses lego specifically because of nostalgia. There is a lot of joy to be found in the freedoms of adulthood but the millennial never found these. He never matured enough to re-experience them from the other side, that of the parent, so he has to imagine himself a child again forever. He will be seventy and still not know to put away childish things.

        • undefined 4 hours ago ago
          [deleted]
        • watwut 4 hours ago ago

          There is nothing more adult then nostalgia. Kids dont get nostalgic. Young adults dont get nostalgic.

          Nostalgia is literally one of the primary things distinguishing mature and older adults from kids.

          Also, adults coming back to stuff they did in their youth is not a new phenomenom. Be it music, books, train models, lego, crafts, ... even my grandmothers continued to listen to music from their youth and do passtimes they discovered young.

      • nerdjon 4 hours ago ago

        This is what drives me insane about this conversation.

        It was deemed perfectly fine for husbands to disappear on fishing trips, go golfing, going to the bar to watch sports, fantasy football, or anything that isn’t being with their partner.

        But god forbid I play video games with my partner, go to Disney with my partner, etc and suddenly I’m the problem. Suddenly I’m not an adult and will fall apart.

    • moffers 4 hours ago ago

      I think it’s a little heavy to claim societal collapse because people enjoy buying things and have less or no children. You may not agree with the lifestyle, but they don’t really owe you your idea of “society”.

      • timnetworks 4 hours ago ago

        Having no children is exactly societal collapse. If people don't have kids there's no more people. Am I missing something?

        • somenameforme 4 hours ago ago

          And at a rate dramatically faster than most realize, once it 'kicks off.' For instance if a country with a common fertility rate of 1 will end up losing about 2.5% of its population per year, compounding. This is why today will still be seen as 'the good ole days' for places like Japan, as they're currently "only" losing about 0.6% per year.

          This is because fertility rates also determine the age ratios within a population. You can intuit this by just working backwards. It's easy with a fertility rate of 1 because each previous generation is twice as large. 1 newborn -> 2 ~20-40 year olds -> 4 ~40-60 year olds -> 8 ~60-80 year olds.

          This also illustrates how immigration isn't a solution at all. At a 2.5% annual loss, you've lost 40% of your population in 20 years. They're literally aren't enough people on the planet to replace this degree of loss, even if we completely ignore the countless other issues such large scale immigration would entail.

          The above numbers/models are based on everybody having the same fertility rate. In a real/mixed situation, the show gets started when the first high fertility gen starts dying off. This is again why Japan seems so awful compared to South Korea even though South Korea's fertility rate is way lower. Japan's fertility rate collapsed in the 70s so we're starting to see 'the dying', whereas South Korea made it all the way to the 80s.

        • PowerElectronix 3 hours ago ago

          Do we need to sacrifice probably the biggest choice in our lives because society would collapse otherwise? What are we, ants?

          Society is a collective, and the individual should always put him/herself before society, lest we end up enslaved to the needs and whims of an emergent property of humans living close to each other.

          • hattmall 3 hours ago ago

            Not having kids is literally the sacrifice of your life. It's not about putting society first, but not recognizing that your life (the unbroken chain since the dawn of life which has led to your existence) is larger than simply your current conscience experience is inhumane to yourself.

          • notenchange 3 hours ago ago

            You don't need to sacrifice your choice. Your life is your own, you live it as you see fit.

            But that doesn't mean, you can stop people from calling out your choice. And that is what many comments here are really about.

            No-one is saying that you should be forced to start a family, but what you really don't want, is that people are free to tell you that not starting a family and instead choosing to spend your time playing with children's toys, is a childish thing and leaves you with an empty existence.

        • fnord77 4 hours ago ago

          Precisely. And it's an insidious form of collapse because it doesn't become evident right away.

    • dead_hn_theory 4 hours ago ago

      One salient, unfortunate observation in all of this is how much adult discourse is influenced by the immense consumption of "media" (social media, television, partly music). The talking points, the rebuttals, are all pre packaged. Maybe the term is overton window. I understand kids picking up whatever their friends are watching, and talking like their favorite characters, but I would honestly expect adults to think a bit more before they parrot someone else's ideology.

      In for a surprise as to what happens next? Not surprised in the slightest at this point. It has been a slow moving train wreck.

    • grep_it 3 hours ago ago

      This view is narrow minded and reductive. You imply playing with toys isn’t a life well lived, but peel back any value system that you’ve set up, explicit, or otherwise, and you may find nihilism at the end.

      A cage went in search of a bird.

    • PowerElectronix 4 hours ago ago

      I think it's not that we never grew up, we are raising families and having children just like our fathers. We just don't feel pressure from society to do it, and we don't pressure others to do it.

      People are not replacing having a family, they just don't want a family, the only difference is that nowadays we don't shun them or pressure them into it.

      As for how good of a life it is, I couldn't tell, but the ones I know seem to be having some fun for the time being.

    • pseidemann 4 hours ago ago

      Humans have evolved beyond pure procreation.

      If you're perceiving time as running out, then you might not be satisfied with your current situation. Find what you like and running might not be needed.

      • notenchange 4 hours ago ago

        This is playing with words. A species doesn’t “evolve” in the spawn of a few short decades.

        And no species, in absolute, evolves past procreation, ever.

        This is a shift in societal norms, there’s nothing natural about it.

    • piva00 5 hours ago ago

      This too shall pass...

    • OptionX 4 hours ago ago

      So climate change, covid and possibly the biggest upheaval in the job market since the industrial revolution don't count I guess.

      And besides, if people go home and play with legos instead of beating their spouses or lighting a burning cross on the lawn of their colored neighbor, apparently like good functioning adult do, maybe its not a a bad thing.

    • undefined 4 hours ago ago
      [deleted]
    • fnord77 4 hours ago ago

      I think this started to a lesser degree with Gen X. Why did it happen? I do not know.

    • Planktonne 4 hours ago ago

      I'm not sure cryptofascism is the right response to this; if the choice is Disney adults or the same tired dogwhistles of bigotry, I know which one I prefer.

    • UtopiaPunk 3 hours ago ago

      It's interesting that so many adults are buying toys for themselves. There's stuff to ponder, but blaming societal collapse on this seems awfully dramatic.

      Lol, if society completely poofed tomorrow, there's a list of things I would blame, but toys would not be involved. Consumerism, maybe. Late stage capitalism, definitely. An increasingly isolated lonely society, sure. Extremely high costs of living, especially housing, paired with an economy mostly built of precarious jobs, of course. If we are assuming that society is collapsing, adults buying a lot of toys seems like a symptom of these other forces, IMO.

    • VCFundedGenYer 4 hours ago ago

      [dead]

    • thin_carapace 4 hours ago ago

      thank you very much for acknowledging that we have a glut of children in adult bodies. this effect cascades in successive generations, such that lessons of how to behave properly are slowly erased from the public. why the fuck are middle aged adults buying kids toys to such a degree that i cant find some pokemon cards for the little ones without a ton of effort? its an embarrasing societal state. we could make conjectures regarding root causes ... i think whats more worrying is that your conclusion of playing alone with partners is likely in reality moreso simply playing alone ...

      • bix6 4 hours ago ago

        Perhaps it’s more embarrassing that we keep reusing the same old ideas. Is there not a new toy for the kids to focus on instead of something from decades ago? What Toy Story are we on now? 6? lol.

        • dpkirchner 3 hours ago ago

          Whenever I ask my sister what her kids are in to she replies with brands that I'd never heard of before. Superkitties? Aphmau? Miraculous Ladybug? I dunno what any of this is without looking it up.

      • nickthegreek 4 hours ago ago

        or they could print enough pokémon cards to meet demand? artificial scarcity is the fault of the producer.

  • djhworld 5 hours ago ago

    I'm part of the problem, I got into Lego during covid as something to do and found I really enjoyed the process of building the sets. A lot of them are display pieces I have around the house, especially from the Lego Art and Botanicals range. I'm not really into the licensed stuff.

    Is it distorting the market for children? I'm not sure, but whenever I go on the Lego website there's loads of small sets that are obviously aimed at kids for play purposes and are relatively cheap.

  • xnx 5 hours ago ago

    And adult diaper sales outsold baby diaper sales in Japan in 2011 (coming for the US and the rest of the world in the next decade).

  • t1234s 5 hours ago ago

    Are PS5 and Xbox considered toys? This number could have represented the purchase of consoles in anticipation of GTA6

  • cheschire 6 hours ago ago

    First half of the year. No toy-giving holidays. Parents are focusing the things they buy for their kids on sports and video games in those months. And saving for summer vacations.

    Meanwhile upscale data driven companies are leaning into an adult fad to get through what I imagine to be the standard spring drought.

    Cool. I just hope people don’t read into it too much.

  • 2OEH8eoCRo0 5 hours ago ago

    Do we count Chess sets or GTA?

    • undefined 3 hours ago ago
      [deleted]
    • embedding-shape 5 hours ago ago

      Both of those are games, not toys, so unlikely? Not sure why they would.

  • 7e 3 hours ago ago

    Every child has four grandparents.

  • mschuster91 6 hours ago ago

    Yeah no surprise there. Have you tried toy shopping, it's insanely expensive. If you got kids, better be prepared to learn some woodworking, everything else has become unaffordable.

    • footydude 5 hours ago ago

      > If you got kids, better be prepared to learn some woodworking, everything else has become unaffordable.

      My children have always been more than happy getting toys from the charity shop (thrift store in US?) or getting pre-owned toys from places like Facebook marketplace.

      We're fortunate enough to be financial secure so our approach is more driven by wanting to live by a more environmental friendly reduce/reuse mindset, but it is often significantly cheaper than buying the same item new too.

      It undoubtedly gets a bit trickier as the kids get older and have more specific wants, but certainly for the ages 0-8 or so you can find good quality toys for much lower cost than new with only very minor compromise (might not have a box to open it, might have some small signs of wear}.

    • RobotToaster 5 hours ago ago

      > better be prepared to learn some woodworking, everything else has become unaffordable.

      Have you seen the price of wood these days?

    • preommr 6 hours ago ago

      > be prepared to learn some woodworking

      Good luck.

      I think people forget how widespread woodworking was as a necessity, which meant lots of lumber, lots of offcuts, lots of... just stuff.

      All that's gone. My local box store doesnt even really carry lumber beyond pine for those kinds of things anymore, second hand market for hand tools is all out of wonk, everything is just ikea furniture and throwaway crap.

      If I am being honest, just buy video games, man... It is what it is.

  • libertine 6 hours ago ago

    I tie this with collectibles market, where people want to compress the experience of decades into waves of months. It's completely fake.

    People used to play and had fun with their toys, a small fraction took better care because there was something about it that was worth treasuring - not because they could resell it in the future, but because of what it represented, usually a memory.

    That's where scarcity of collectibles used to come from.

    Most people had to be lucky to have something in a special occasion.

    Now people turned this upsidedown and they're not even having memories with their toys, and companies are feeding into this.

    Or they buy stuff to keep it boxed in, we're talking about toys. I used to save the boxes of the toys I cherished the most, but I played the hell out of them.

    Now it's gambling, or artificial scarcity, or what ever this is that's completely hollow. There's no moment attached to it.

    I really struggle to understand this behavior, I mean, I get it but I don't understand how people play into it without feeling something is off.

    • ozim 6 hours ago ago

      Bonkers, what kind of "old times, better times" silliness.

      There were always modeling sets where people would assemble them once and then keep it on display or just put it in basement never to look at it again. People would buy puzzles and once they finish, they would frame it and hang on the wall.

      As an adult I don't have time to play with lego sets like I used to when I was a child. Now if I buy a set for Christmas it will most likely sit in a box not assembled for couple next months until I do get a slow evening. I will assemble it once and put it on a shelf as a decoration. Not much different from buying any other decoration, well maybe it is not "high art" or "high taste" but I like it - plus I do get to assemble it myself not just merely put it on the shelf - so I do it.

      • libertine 5 hours ago ago

        Where did I say old times were better?

        I wasn't referring to collectibles, it's pretty obvious I'm talking about regular toys that became collectibles over time, not designed to be collectibles.

        Of course people are free to do whatever they want with their money, and that's what's happening here: companies are choosing adults with more available income, willing to pay a premium, and they don't care if products meant for children are bought for adults.

        Heck there's a whole secondary market of scalpers because people are willing to pay a margin on top of MSRP - with zero value added to their experience other than it wasn't available because other adults got to it first.

        That's precisely my point, it's not better or worse, it's hollow, there's nothing there. It is what it is.

        This goes well beyond collectible Lego sets, like Pokemon cards, Nintendo merchandise, etc

        • ozim 4 hours ago ago

          Ok scalpers and manufactured scarcity I agree are just bad.

          Indeed there is bunch of things that shouldn’t be collectibles.

  • swyx 4 hours ago ago

    i, too, have a lot of friends with kids.

  • alansaber 5 hours ago ago

    The solution is obvious, no? Kids need to also be able to compete on the free market by generating revenue

  • amelius 6 hours ago ago

    Yeah because electronics/computers has become an unaffordable hobby.

    The next best thing is building a Cray-I using LEGO bricks.

  • tasuki 4 hours ago ago

    I can see why - kids make a huge mess with toys. I'm sure the adults play responsibly and clean up after themselves!

  • snapplebobapple 42 minutes ago ago

    Hot take but this reads as families replaced by losers...

  • Aboutplants 5 hours ago ago

    Solidifying the theory that “Everyone is 12 years old”

  • nemo44x 5 hours ago ago

    If you have kids you get a lot of opportunities to play with toys and engage in kid activities. Many people aren’t having kids so they use toys and “adult Disney” activities as a sort of surrogate for the phase of life where you’d raise and nurture your children by engaging in these types of things.

    • nerdjon 5 hours ago ago

      Why do people constantly act like those of us who choose to have kids are doing things to try to fill the void?

      I have zero desire to have kids and me playing with Legos, video games, or going to Disney has absolutely nothing with a lack of kids. (Hell as much as I love Disney I would LOVE an adults only night)

  • taneq 6 hours ago ago

    80s/90s kids finally able to backfill our childhoods.

    • NeutralCrane 5 hours ago ago

      Backfill? What was missing from being a child in 80s/90s childhood?

      • lifestyleguru 4 hours ago ago

        The stereotypical "80s/90s childhood" was available only in US, Canada, Scandinavia, Western Europe and some Mediterranean, maybe also Australia? Everywhere else it was ranging somewhere from poor to war.

    • lifestyleguru 5 hours ago ago

      If you ever have this urge - find an adult activity, they're even more fun and fulfilling.

      • mcphage 5 hours ago ago

        What qualifies as “adult activities”?

        • dpkirchner 4 hours ago ago

          Drinking in public, driving on public roads, doctor visits on your own, that sort of thing

        • alt227 5 hours ago ago

          Things you cant do as a child.

        • lifestyleguru 5 hours ago ago

          Things you can do having time, money, credentials, and permits available only for an adult.

      • taneq 2 hours ago ago

        Any activity is an adult activity if you do it when you're an adult. I bought myself a new-release BigTrak when I saw one for sale, after growing up reading about them and wanting one. It was janky out of the box and so it's currently half-disassembled waiting for me to upgrade it with a proper mind (when I have time sigh). I have more Lego than ever before (most of it built with my kids). I've rebuilt a 1997 5hp Johnford Bridgeport-style milling machine, stripping it to bare metal and re-assembling including fabricating the missing/broken parts. The first thing I machined with it, from a slice of hinge pin from a hydraulic boom, was a fly cutter, because of course. And of course because I'm a lost cause, I immediately pulled it apart again for a CNC conversion. I bought an "unrepairable" 15hp screw air compressor (I've always loved how screw compressors work) and fixed it (some domestic sparky had tried to diagnose the control panel) and now it makes me unreasonably happy every time it fires up. I don't know how 'grown up' any of these things really are (and most are a tangent to my IRL minmaxing critical path) but I reckon most are definitely 'adult'.

        Edit: Also I dunno where this sits on your spectrum from 'child' to 'adult' but these days 'go ride bikes' involves a 1200cc engine rather than a 20" BMX.

      • molybd3num 12 minutes ago ago

        [dead]

    • Telemakhos 5 hours ago ago

      80s/90s kids addicted to TV still responding to the ads that programmed them forty years ago. If it were about backfilling childhood, they’d be outdoors playing with the neighbors; the consumerism is a sustained reflex to the televised stimuli.

      • lifestyleguru 4 hours ago ago

        > 80s/90s kids addicted to TV still responding to the ads that programmed them forty years ago

        > the consumerism is a sustained reflex to the televised stimuli.

        It really is and it really was temporary. Have you watched TV nowadays? It's mostly vicious political and ideological indoctrination.

      • throaway1985asd 4 hours ago ago

        ^^^^^^^^^^^^

    • coffeebeqn 5 hours ago ago

      I get that this consumerism filling the hole in your soul is how these companies want to sell to you but is it really legos or TMNT figures you miss about your childhood?

  • honeycrispy 6 hours ago ago

    This is really sad.

    • arnejenssen 3 hours ago ago

      I agree. Adults staying like Peter Pan. Playing with toys and living in Neverland.

  • nozzlegear 3 hours ago ago

    This whole thread is filled with "the west has fallen" pearl clutching, and I say that as someone who does not collect things or buy legos or other toys as an adult. A pathetic showing from all involved.

  • newsclues 6 hours ago ago

    Broken economy and culture.

  • chao86825 6 hours ago ago

    [dead]

  • shagie 4 hours ago ago

    [dead]

  • danielktdoranie 6 hours ago ago

    [dead]

  • metalman 6 hours ago ago

    at one point I wanted to do an absurdist piece on all the mysteriously vanishing fish stocks filmed in seafood sections everywhere, as I do know a proffesional set dresser so the backgound would strobe but the interviews would be seamless in the foreground. and now we could do one on pedo pervs and the adultification and sexualisation of children bound to wholesale arrested development of juvinile type 'adults'

    edit: the unhealthy fetishisation of childhood is QUITE readily aperant and in no way inocent