16 comments

  • Gibbon1 7 hours ago ago

    About 25 years ago I saw a small remote parcel of land for sale. Nearest power to the property was something like two miles. I think running power would have been $25k which is as much as the property was selling for. Ran the numbers and solar would have been cheaper.

    I think about a heat map of where solar is cheaper. 2 years ago it would have been small splotches live that property. But over time as solar got cheaper the splotches got bigger and bigger. And now we're in the place where some places solar is cheaper than grid connection fees.

    • dan_grec 6 hours ago ago

      A commentor here on HN said they did their masters thesis on where in Canada it makes financial sense to install solar.

      It turned out to be a bad thesis topic, because panels are so cheap the answer was “everywhere”

      • gnabgib 6 hours ago ago

        With no consideration for where electricity is required? Cloud cover? Where the sun doesn't fall for a large portion of the year? (eg. magnetic north)

        • 2muchtime 6 hours ago ago

          I think someone considering a Ph.D thesis would have taken those things into account. That’s what makes the prior statement impactful.

          • gnabgib 6 hours ago ago

            Nobody said PhD.. that renders this statement impotent. Are you the commenter/owner of dan_grec? Sunlight with battery backup gets you through a cloudy day, but not winter.

            Edit: (Oh you've edited down to "considering PhD")

            • dan_grec 2 hours ago ago

              >Are you the commenter/owner of dan_grec?

              I am he.

              >Sunlight with battery backup gets you through a cloudy day, but not winter

              Wood stove for winter, gas for cooking.

              Panels and batteries get friends with a large house through Yukon winters for the last 15 years. The system would now be at least 10x less than they paid for it back then. Panels are stupidly cheap now

            • justinclift 3 hours ago ago

              > Sunlight with battery backup gets you through a cloudy day, but not winter.

              For that situation, don't people install stuff like wind power at the same time? Or whatever suits their location, if there's something which does.

        • dan_grec 6 hours ago ago

          All of that was considered.

          Friends in the Yukon have been off grid with solar for 15 years.

  • cowlevel 9 hours ago ago

    HN keeps telling me solar is so expensive and nuclear is the only practical source of energy

    • dan_grec 6 hours ago ago

      Solar is the biggest no brainer right now.

      Our 7.3kw system on the roof in snowy Canada was $13k all in. Take $5k off for a gov grant, and an interest free 10 year loan for the remaining $8k.

      It makes 7.7MWh of power a year, worth $1000. So in 8 years we will have paid off the loan without using a cent of our own money, then we get $1000 a year for the next 20 years or so.

      Best $20k I ever earned.

    • bergie 4 hours ago ago

      HN opinion on solar hasn't quite kept up with the panels becoming cheap.

    • hyperhello 9 hours ago ago

      But solar is nuclear power, in a way.

      • jiggawatts 8 hours ago ago

        It’s an unshielded fusion reactor in the sky that can give you severe radiation burns if you expose yourself to it for too long… outside.

    • krapp 9 hours ago ago

      HN keeps telling me vaccines are poison, all physics after Newton is a Bolshevist scam and LLMs are more alive than human beings.

      Maybe don't listen to anything HN has to say about anything if it doesn't involve programming and even then carry a saltshaker.

      • Isamu 8 hours ago ago

        HN keeps telling me programming is over and I should start looking for a different job.

      • ZnerflBerp 8 hours ago ago

        Think you might need a citation there sir. It's certainly not a consensus I've noticed.