Apparently not. Jenny Lorraine Nielsen has a history of making spurious claims of having solved major mathematical problems herself, while repeatedly attacking AI-generated proofs without providing substantive mathematical arguments. A quick look into her previous claims makes it difficult to take this particular objection seriously.
Especially given the statment from Lean experts, currently discussed here[1], where they seem quite satisfied the proof is correct and importantly proves the correcy statement.
From the Lean Zulip discussion about this “paper”:
@_Bogdan Grechuk|972933 "said" (https://leanprover.zulipchat.com/#narrow/channel/113488-gene...):
«I get an e-mail from a colleague with link https://philarchive.org/rec/NIEIOT-2 claiming that the proof is wrong. Is it a serious claim?»
Apparently not. Jenny Lorraine Nielsen has a history of making spurious claims of having solved major mathematical problems herself, while repeatedly attacking AI-generated proofs without providing substantive mathematical arguments. A quick look into her previous claims makes it difficult to take this particular objection seriously.
Especially given the statment from Lean experts, currently discussed here[1], where they seem quite satisfied the proof is correct and importantly proves the correcy statement.
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50589618
This is from a notorious crackpot
The PDF is invalid for me on my Android Firefox