I'm reserving celebrations until UK people understand they will not have the same perks[0] and waivers/opt-outs[1] they had before leaving, and when the PM eventually has to tell them about giving up the Pound.
Question for Brits - so far, does your new PM seem high-functioning enough to stay in 10 Downing for a while? Nobody's expecting another William Pitt, or even a Tony Blair - but your previous 5 PM's seemed to be drawn from the shallow end of a rather brackish talent pool.
(No, I'm not saying us Yanks have done well in staffing the White House.)
Burnham seems good. Seems to be on the right track with everything for now, isn't making any mistakes that anyone actually cares about so far.
Then again, in normal times, Cameron, May and Starmer would've been fine.
Conversely, Johnson was pathologically dishonest, in the sense I think he didn't understand the term "liar" as anything more than an insult.
The forgettable one with the lettuce, of course, as you say.
Sunak was clearly inexperienced, but I don't know if it was a fundamental failing of the guy to be so inept.
But for the others?
While one may argue Cameron made an unforced error in holding the referendum at all, someone would probably have been manoeuvred into it soon enough if not him: Johnson and Farage (and others) had been pushing hard against (what is now) the EU for about two decades by the time the referendum actually happened.
May's biggest mistake was wanting the job. It was guaranteed to be cursed at that point, because of Brexit meaning different things to a bunch of people who did not want anyone to tell them they all disagreed with each other. Only a liar could bring the country together and actually get anything done at that point, which is how Johnson replaced her and got stuff done.
Starmer had the charisma of a blank sheet of paper, but that was his only real problem. Kinda the exact opposite of Johnson, whose only strength was charisma.
Burnham could be a repeat of Cameron; but he does have more charisma than Starmer, more experience than Sunak, and doesn't have May's curse. There's also none of Johnson's reputation, and no sign of anything remotely like Truss-level nonsense.
That's a fair summary, though I personally would take a slightly dimmer view of both May and Sunak.
The former was a decent, principled administrator but would never have been an inspiring leader even under better circumstances. And Sunak's lack of experience came at least in part because of his lack of curiosity, which left him with a simplistic "hard work pays off" worldview that was found spectacularly wanting when he was forced to confront failure for the first time in his life whilst in office.
We had five PMs in a row who were found to be seriously lacking in one way or another. I do worry that Burnham tends to be too much of a people pleaser, which might be storing up problems for the future - but he's easily the most well-rounded leader since Cameron.
So I'd say that he's very likely to remain in office until the end of the current parliament and has a good chance of winning the next general election (due before mid-2029) thanks to a badly split opposition.
I'm reserving celebrations until UK people understand they will not have the same perks[0] and waivers/opt-outs[1] they had before leaving, and when the PM eventually has to tell them about giving up the Pound.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_rebate [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opt-outs_in_the_European_Union
Question for Brits - so far, does your new PM seem high-functioning enough to stay in 10 Downing for a while? Nobody's expecting another William Pitt, or even a Tony Blair - but your previous 5 PM's seemed to be drawn from the shallow end of a rather brackish talent pool.
(No, I'm not saying us Yanks have done well in staffing the White House.)
Burnham seems good. Seems to be on the right track with everything for now, isn't making any mistakes that anyone actually cares about so far.
Then again, in normal times, Cameron, May and Starmer would've been fine.
Conversely, Johnson was pathologically dishonest, in the sense I think he didn't understand the term "liar" as anything more than an insult.
The forgettable one with the lettuce, of course, as you say.
Sunak was clearly inexperienced, but I don't know if it was a fundamental failing of the guy to be so inept.
But for the others?
While one may argue Cameron made an unforced error in holding the referendum at all, someone would probably have been manoeuvred into it soon enough if not him: Johnson and Farage (and others) had been pushing hard against (what is now) the EU for about two decades by the time the referendum actually happened.
May's biggest mistake was wanting the job. It was guaranteed to be cursed at that point, because of Brexit meaning different things to a bunch of people who did not want anyone to tell them they all disagreed with each other. Only a liar could bring the country together and actually get anything done at that point, which is how Johnson replaced her and got stuff done.
Starmer had the charisma of a blank sheet of paper, but that was his only real problem. Kinda the exact opposite of Johnson, whose only strength was charisma.
Burnham could be a repeat of Cameron; but he does have more charisma than Starmer, more experience than Sunak, and doesn't have May's curse. There's also none of Johnson's reputation, and no sign of anything remotely like Truss-level nonsense.
That's a fair summary, though I personally would take a slightly dimmer view of both May and Sunak.
The former was a decent, principled administrator but would never have been an inspiring leader even under better circumstances. And Sunak's lack of experience came at least in part because of his lack of curiosity, which left him with a simplistic "hard work pays off" worldview that was found spectacularly wanting when he was forced to confront failure for the first time in his life whilst in office.
We had five PMs in a row who were found to be seriously lacking in one way or another. I do worry that Burnham tends to be too much of a people pleaser, which might be storing up problems for the future - but he's easily the most well-rounded leader since Cameron.
So I'd say that he's very likely to remain in office until the end of the current parliament and has a good chance of winning the next general election (due before mid-2029) thanks to a badly split opposition.