The joy of why is disappearing in math

(rtmkrptn.github.io)

4 points | by rtmkrptn 6 hours ago ago

3 comments

  • mxfactorial 5 hours ago ago

    > math is shifting from an invented science to an empirical one

    math is a language

    it was invented when discovering "add one to another one to form two" is a mess to transform

    assigning symbols to quantities isnt a science until u measure if they reappear when counting physical objects

    1 + 1 = 2 is just random symbols until physics says otherwise

    notice how easy it is to forget this when units go missing

    • rtmkrptn 3 hours ago ago

      I don't really got you point. I was elaborating on the fact that we might loose the full understanding of math by choosing applicability and convenience of AI.

      Regard the language, assume a creature, a jellyfish that can perceive only sensory data of pressure. What math could this creature invent? The only thing it experienced was a continuum of pressure, an idea of a real number for this creature would be way more natural then say integers. It's matter of fact that we built math as a language for ourselves, natural numbers arose because they are natural to us, however it took us hundreds of years to formalise real numbers. A child spends a fraction of time understanding natural numbers compared to rationals and reals.

      Indeed, math is built on our vague intuitions of the real world but what if we cannot built an intuition of a phenomena because it is beyond humans' cognitive capabilities but AI can.

      • mxfactorial 2 hours ago ago

        > I don't really got you point. I was elaborating on the fact that we might loose the full understanding of math

        heres the point once more out of courtesy: its a language

        studying it teaches u the thoughts of its author

        and ai is just describing the patterns in it

        ur concerned about the drop in intellectual exertion of humans

        some thoughts arent worth the exertion: https://github.com/mxfactorial/geonum/blob/main/tests/number...