Prisons get OK to jam contraband phones

(arstechnica.com)

36 points | by turbocon 6 hours ago ago

77 comments

  • montroser 4 hours ago ago

    The micro-jamming system blocked 911 calls, interfered with public safety and other communications, and caused interference that impacted wireless network infrastructure up to two and a half miles away.

    This doesn't seem especially worth it, if you ask me. Among the many losers in this deal will be the COs and prison staff, who already have a tough job to begin with.

    • mt_ 3 hours ago ago

      You can have other protocols for emergency SOS...

      • spwa4 2 hours ago ago

        Effective ones that the prison system will pay for? Not a chance.

    • cowlevel 4 hours ago ago

      On Americans' priorities list, hurting prisoners is one of the highest priorities. They'll say it isn't, but POSIWID.

      Things like working 911 are less important than hurting prisoners.

      • persolb 3 hours ago ago

        Unfortunately, as an American, o can confirm this. I’ve spoken with engineers working on prisons systems trying to passively stop cellular and actively provide room specific WiFi (for guards and as a good behavior benefit).

        When I’ve mentioned the WiFi to family, they are aghast that prisoners have WiFi and devices.

        I understanding segregating violent prisoners, but the level of punishment in minimum security like shown in ‘You Can See Anything’ seems more humane while still being a punishment.

      • unrented7977 3 hours ago ago

        You're being downvoted, but you are correct. There is a very large cohort of Americans who believe that any and all prisoners deserve harm and punishment regardless of anything else. And not even for any purpose, just for the sheer malice of it.

  • Molitor5901 4 hours ago ago

    I support this but I hope prisons will increase landline redundancy, and greater communications with the rest of the world. Maybe that is using AI to monitor and analyze more, spending more in prisons to rehabilitate better, I'm not sure.. But prisoners, especially violent offenders, should have only controlled access with the world. An un-monitored cell phone..isn't the best thing for inmates to have.

  • wtmt 2 hours ago ago

    The crux of the matter is in the last two paragraphs:

    > There is no way to jam some communications on a spectrum band but not others. That is because radio jammers ‘block all wireless communications on affected spectrum bands,’ and, as the FCC has noted in the past, ‘cannot differentiate between contraband devices and legitimate devices.’”

    > AT&T said that “there is simply no way to limit the reach of jammers to the confines of a given facility. Jammers have been shown to cause interference outside the facilities in which they operate, greatly increasing the risk that someone living or traveling nearby will be impacted.”

    We have this problem in India, where jammers are used around prisons and it really affects people who live in the surrounding areas (in a radius of a few kilometers). They cannot use calls or SMS OTPs or the internet or mobile payments reliably. Here’s just one recent news report in the “Silicon Valley of India” (Bengaluru/Bangalore). [1]

    [1]: https://www.cnbctv18.com/india/no-calls-poor-internet-delaye...

  • dartharva 5 hours ago ago

    Can someone please educate a non-American why this was a federal issue in the first place? Couldn't counties and their municipal systems themselves decide their planning accordingly?

    • hackingonempty 5 hours ago ago

      The spectrum is regulated by the Federal Communications Commission because radio crosses state borders.

    • unrented7977 3 hours ago ago

      Jamming radio signals is illegal on the federal level precisely because doing so could interfere with 911 and other life-critical operations.

    • Simon_O_Rourke 5 hours ago ago

      Spectrum is licensed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).

  • jMyles 5 hours ago ago

    I'm not sure there's anything about today's world we'll look back on with greater astonishment and shame than the fact that we once put human beings in torturous conditions and forced them to work as slaves for our major defense and fast-food corporations, pretextually in response to their having committed some kind of offense to society, although the victims of such offenses (in the cases where one existed at all, which was by no means a sure thing) recouped nothing from this configuration.

    That and factory farming; though I don't think that the animals are permitted cell phones either - in some sense, the "ag gag" laws are a sort of "no phoning home from here" rule.

    • grey-area 5 hours ago ago

      "pretextually in response to their having committed some kind of offense to society"

      Some people in prison have committed horrible crimes, that is in no way false, contrived or up for debate. Whether prison is an effective punishment or rehabilitation method I doubt, but your comment is deeply wrong on this score and you should fix it.

      • atmavatar 2 hours ago ago

        There's a pretty wide range of offenses covered by the US prison population. Almost half are there for drug offenses, which can cover things as innocuous as being caught with a small bag of pot, and there's a strong argument many if not most of those offenders shouldn't be there.

        See: https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offen...

        Given that, I think GP's comment is perfectly valid.

        Just because some inmates are monsters doesn't mean we should treat all as subhuman, especially when you consider the origins of the war on drugs.

        • grey-area 27 minutes ago ago

          I’m absolutely not for treating anyone as subhuman or for the awful slavery inherent in the current US penal system. But we have prisons for a reason and some people should be locked up as they will harm others if they are not.

          Weasel words like ‘prettxtual’ and ‘some kind of offense’ try to pretend that reality doesn’t exist.

      • jMyles 5 hours ago ago

        The fact that some people have committed horrible crimes doesn't make their sudden obligation to manufacture McDonald's uniforms more coherent.

        McDonald's wants slaves; people having committed horrible crimes (in some cases, and no crimes at all in others) is their pretext for acquiring them.

    • sjducb 5 hours ago ago

      How else do you deal with psychopaths, and people who have been socialised to behave like psychopaths? These are extreme 1-2% of the population .

      Some people look at things from a 100% selfish perspective. They don’t think about the costs to the victim at all. These are people who will spray acid in a delivery cyclist’s face to steal his e-bike.

      To control these people you need to make sure that the punishment for a crime (multiplied by the probability of being caught) is worse than the benefit to the criminal. The potential criminal can then selfishly decide to do something else, ideally something that’s not a criminal offence.

      • rendx 4 hours ago ago

        > How else do you deal with psychopaths, and people who have been socialised to behave like psychopaths?

        You figure out what they need in terms of support, and help them process the trauma that was done to them.

        You may not personally care about them. But you do care about your own community, friends, family, those that are close to you. If you don't help the broken families heal, they/their families/their decendants will get to you and fuck you up. It's really that simple. It is a VICTIM perspective.

        How Legal Punishment Affects Crime: An Integrated Understanding of the Law's Punitive Behavioral Mechanisms. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-lawsocsci-111524-094646

        “Survivors tell us what they want. We should listen.”

        https://lithub.com/what-survivors-of-trauma-demand-from-thei...

        • sjducb an hour ago ago

          If they can’t be rehabilitated then do you support long punitive sentences?

          Fundamentally I don’t think most prisoners can be rehabilitated, and I don’t want to risk creating more victims when rehabilitation fails.

          I’m being kind to their next victim, the one who never becomes a victim if the prisoner stays in jail.

        • devilbunny 3 hours ago ago

          Some people are just thugs. Not all criminals are, but some are. They terrorize their families, too. Removing them from society is the only choice.

      • BobaFloutist 3 hours ago ago

        > How else do you deal with psychopaths, and people who have been socialised to behave like psychopaths? These are extreme 1-2% of the population

        You restrict their freedom, but treat them humanely.

        • sjducb an hour ago ago

          I can support this. Everyone else arguing against me is muddling the two separate issues of long sentences and work while in prison.

          Prison work for outside companies should be optional.

      • unrented7977 3 hours ago ago

        How does slavery solve any of these problems?

      • cowlevel 4 hours ago ago

        Does making psychopaths sew clothes for McDonald's in particular make them less psychopathic or something?

        • sjducb 4 hours ago ago

          What would you do instead?

          • unrented7977 3 hours ago ago

            Treatment and rehabilitation, maybe? Soemthing that has a positive effect on their life and society in general?

            Or should we enslave people because we're just too lazy to think of anything else?

          • cowlevel 4 hours ago ago

            What a weird response to that question.

            "Are you sure sacrificing the village elder's firstborn makes the crops grow better?" "What would you do instead?"

      • 3949499559 4 hours ago ago

        [flagged]

        • sjducb 4 hours ago ago

          No it’s one or two percent.

    • gosub100 3 hours ago ago

      the prison isn't as bad as the courts and sentencing system. Why should someone lose years of their life for having the flower or extract of a plant ffs?

      > although the victims of such offenses ... recouped nothing from this configuration

      If you want to go there, then fine, let inmates sell a kidney, donate blood, and undergo medical trials to repay their debts to the victims. That will constitute recompense for the victims.

      • burnedbyhell 2 hours ago ago

        Courts have largely dehumanized people. Has it always been this way? It's an assembly line where a person isn't a person but a line on a spreadsheet and just another checkbox on the list.

    • deadbabe 5 hours ago ago

      Ah sure, prisoners being forced into slavery because of their crimes against society will be our peak shame, not the actual enslavement of innocent people who were kidnapped and sold off to work in fields in some far away land. What a white way of thinking.

      • jMyles 5 hours ago ago

        Well, we don't presently have a legal framework that provides for that, though of course we benefit from products made with cobalt, etc., that are acquired this way.

        I didn't mean to downplay the severity and shame of chattel slavery in 2026, which of course is alive and well, but rather to comment on the particular way that we justify what it has evolved into on the US mainland.

      • nign 4 hours ago ago

        Just ignoring the disproptionate rate of incarceration of the descendants of those very enslaved people. Calling prison abolition a "white way of thinking" is laughably absurd.

        • jMyles 4 hours ago ago

          > Calling prison abolition a "white way of thinking" is laughably absurd.

          Presuming good intentions, I think that they probably meant that as commentary on the real and ongoing slavery crisis in Africa, which the rest of the world exploits to acquire cheap resources including for our fancy batteries.

          Even then, I don't think it's responsive to the point I was making, and I appreciate that you've point out what I thought was obvious about my underlying message: that the existing "corrections" system is a lineal descendant of chattel slavery, legalized by the 13th amendment.

      • Jtariiiii 5 hours ago ago

        Other people a long time ago did the slavery thing, "we" are currently doing the bad things happening today.

        • singlow 5 hours ago ago

          They aren't talking about the past

      • phoghed 5 hours ago ago

        And then someone comes to well ackshually you with the holocaust. This is such a tedious way to comment on anything. You know what they meant dork.

        • deadbabe 5 hours ago ago

          The US alone enslaved over 10 million people.

  • pmkary 5 hours ago ago

    Excuse my out of date information, but isn't jamming cancerous and badly harmf?

    • gavinsyancey 5 hours ago ago

      No. Jamming uses the same frequencies as the signal being jammed. It's non-ionizing radiation so no cancer risk.

      • neuroelectron 5 hours ago ago

        The idea that radiation is safe because it's non-ionizing a pseudoscience bullshit. Stop repeating it.

        • kstrauser 4 hours ago ago

          Proving that it’s dangerous would be worth a Nobel because it would rewrite our understanding of physics, and yet no one has managed it.

        • TheSkyHasEyes 4 hours ago ago

          Manners. Don't forget what forum you are on. Go to reddit for rude useless retort.

        • unrented7977 3 hours ago ago

          You should really attend a science class at some point in your life.

    • connicpu 5 hours ago ago

      Radio frequency electromagnetic radiation is non-ionizing, a jammer is the same signals put out by the communications devices but containing random data to mask the real signals so they can't get through.

  • RunSet 4 hours ago ago

    > Freedom of the Press Foundation Chief of Advocacy Seth Stern said the FCC should have considered the benefits of contraband phones being used to document abuses inside prisons.

    > “Prisons are the most secretive government institutions in the country and people wishing to expose abuses and inhumane conditions from the inside often do not have many options,”

    Oh, they considered it.

  • MattCruikshank 5 hours ago ago

    Explain to me how it is that we think airport security does anything...

    When prisons have tons of contraband.

  • MitPitt 5 hours ago ago

    Back to pigeon mail it is

  • neuroelectron 5 hours ago ago

    Tldr: they're too incompetent to do it correctly and it's illegal to do it, but they're the feds so fuck you.

  • nekusar 5 hours ago ago

    How exactly do they plan on only jamming contraband phones?

    And do they plan on metal shielding, ala a SCIF, to prevent leakage?

    This seems to be pretty hair-brained.

    • QuantumNomad_ 5 hours ago ago

      If the jammers only works short range it seems fine.

      They can (and probably do?) use walkie talkies for communication between prison guards.

      As long as they don’t accidentally jam communications for others outside of the prisons, it doesn’t matter that all phones within the prison, contraband or not, get jammed.

      I don’t know how accurate this image is, but from movies I get the impression that prisons generally are located in semi remote places without any neighboring buildings. If that is how it really is, then there aren’t anyone located in the immediate vicinity to be negatively affected.

      • gWPVhyxPHqvk 5 hours ago ago

        Northern State Prison sits between EWR and the city of Newark https://maps.app.goo.gl/o6ZmEqgQcxNovSBQA (bordered on both sides by I-78 and heavily used railroads)

        • stackskipton 5 hours ago ago

          That's pretty unusual. In most states, mine included, Prisons are in pretty rural areas since rural residents are thrilled for steady jobs they provide.

      • exe34 5 hours ago ago

        I know of at least one prison in the UK that's right in the middle of a town, with busy roads on all sides.

        • hnlmorg 5 hours ago ago

          There’s a few in the UK like that. It might even be common. But UK prisons aren’t governed by American legislation so wouldn’t be affected by the outcome described in the article.

        • davidwritesbugs 5 hours ago ago

          Wandsworth, Pentonville, Cardiff etc. etc. - Perhaps it would work in the US but in the UK it would cause havoc

        • QuantumNomad_ 5 hours ago ago

          I meant specifically for the USA.

          In my own country we also have several prisons that are right next to other buildings.

    • janice1999 5 hours ago ago

      They can use a Stingray type device (local higher power tower device) and whitelist IMEI numbers.

      • kadoban 4 hours ago ago

        Can't you bypass Stringrays if you know they're there? I thought they're essentially just towers with IDs you can either blacklist or whitelist if you really try.

      • SOLAR_FIELDS 5 hours ago ago

        Extremely questionable from a privacy perspective (I have to hand over my IMEI for the crime of living near a jail?) and also does not solve the problem of "I happened to be from out of town and driving near the jail. I wrecked my car right outside of a jail ditch and my leg fell off but I can't use my cell phone to dial 911 so I guess I'll just bleed out and die"

    • metalman 5 hours ago ago

      I would advocate for putting very localised fine tuned cell 'towers' that overwhelm outside signals and only connected through tightly controlled servers, certain things like wiki , government, legal, could be mirrored localy. Gang bangers and heavy criminals are actualy targeted and used as 'honey' pots.

      • SOLAR_FIELDS 5 hours ago ago

        This actually seems slightly more palatable than the original proposal because it would allow emergency calls through vs the jamming approach which would block them. But it still has similar flaws. The core issue is a combination of two things:

        - there is no way to discern legitimate traffic from bad traffic without an invasion of innocent bystanders privacy

        - there is no way to cover only a specific area

        Combining these two facts reveals that anyone who not only lives near the prison but anyone else who drives by is sucked into the dragnet without their consent

        Unsurprisingly these are some of the core issues with operating a Stingray in general and why no law enforcement agency will allow use of stingray to be tried in court

        • metalman 3 hours ago ago

          I believe that by putting a 'farady net' similar to drone netting, hint hint, and carefully tuning the external and internal cell brodcast services an almost perfect hermetic data seal can be built, further to which as I suggested would be inserted 'flaws' that are actualy honey traps for the realy bad guys, ie: organized crime.

    • connicpu 5 hours ago ago

      > CTIA says nearby phones will be jammed too.

      Sounds like that's a problem they're not even going to try to solve

    • snickerbockers 5 hours ago ago

      Well, TFA makes it pretty clear they don't.

    • nakedrobot2 5 hours ago ago

      you mean hare brained

      • nekusar 2 hours ago ago

        No. I don't want to insult rabbits.

        Rabbits are smarter than pigs.

    • cowlevel 4 hours ago ago

      They just flood the relevant spectrum with noise and for the second question, they DGAF

    • jmclnx 5 hours ago ago

      Yes, maybe a faraday cage around the prison :)

      > despite warnings that jammers will also block lawful phone calls outside the prisons.

      Wait until the first law suite when someone cannot call 911 for a serious health reason. Also, will the prison guard union be happy with this ? I kind of doubt it. In a way I wonder if some of these phones come in via guards themselves ?

      • davidwritesbugs 5 hours ago ago

        In the UK prison I was in the walls had shielding, poor man's Faraday cage and even blocked VHF

      • VladVladikoff 5 hours ago ago

        I wonder how small a phone could be these days. Could you hide it inside an electronic birthday card, the kind that plays a silly song?

        • stop50 5 hours ago ago

          in theory you just need a piece of paper, conductive inks and then you could print it. the circuit cuold be hidden in an postcard. an battery could be supplied by the inmate to hide it better.

        • davidwritesbugs 5 hours ago ago

          Look up "Beat the BOSS" phones: Zanco Tiny T1, 21mmx12x47mm (BOSS = bodily orifice scanner to detect phones in the rectum.)

        • TeMPOraL 5 hours ago ago

          You could probably hide it in the coin cell battery that powers the silly card.

      • neuroelectron 5 hours ago ago

        That's really expensive and cuts into for-profit prisons' budget.