"Race realism" isn't realistic–and it isn't good science

(theconversation.com)

6 points | by andrewl 6 hours ago ago

3 comments

  • throw310822 6 hours ago ago

    Insufferable. Let's be clear: statements like Trump's on Somali people are plain stupid, and real or imaginary ethnic differences are a topic that should be treated with the greatest caution, or not at all.

    On the other hand, it's simply unscientific to think that genetic variation between ethnic groups ends at the visible phenotype plus all the less evident but very established differences known to medical practice. This idea has no justification at all outside political correctness. The null hypothesis is that there are as many subtle differences in cognitive traits (of which intelligence is just one) as there are in physical ones. The contrary would be extremely surprising and would need a rock-solid proof.

  • NotGMan 6 hours ago ago

    Since most of the people in here are in tech ask yourself:

    1) How many white people, proportionally, are devs in tech?

    2) How many Asian (Japanese, Korean, Chinese) people, proportionally, are devs in tech?

    3) How many black people, proportionally, are devs in tech?

    Even if you do per-capita or HB1 for Chinese blacks are still basicaly close to 0 in devs proportionally.

    Two smart parents have a high likelyhood of having a smart kid.

    Two non-smart parents have a very low likelyhood of having a smart kid.

    So obviously its genetic.

    And if populations split throughout history different populations were exposed to different environments.

    This is just politics at this point: "we are all equal". No, we are not.

    I wonder how the people writing this article and holding these views would explain watching the World/Olympic sprints where most people are black or the NBA.

    Should NBA have a white people quota?

    If blacks are on average so much better at sprints and basketball, why is IQ verbotten all of the sudden?

    >> We believe it is unequivocal that race science is fundamentally pseudoscience.

    "Belive" is the problem here since looking at NBA and sprints immediately shows their belief to be wrong.

    • incognegro2004 6 hours ago ago

      >>Two smart parents have a high likelyhood of having a smart kid.

      >>Two non-smart parents have a very low likelyhood of having a smart kid.

      All you have to do to believe this nonsense is ignore all relevant context like: disparity in school qualities and 30 years of research on socioeconomic effects on test scores.